3 ms·
I've worked at a lot of places where politics was discussed casually. In my experience, political discussions at work tend not to be such a bad thing, provided
by bitwize 6y ago
I've worked at a lot of places where politics was discussed casually. In my experience, political discussions at work tend not to be such a bad thing, provided that assholes can keep their mouths shut and not sow acrimony. When I read about the blowup a few days ago, I thought Basecamp had a cryptofascist in there somewhere and when he opened his mouth, shit hit the fan. Sure enough, it was Singer.
I'm beginning to understand why Andy Wingo emphasized filtering out fash when doing your hiring: https://www.wingolog.org/archives/2017/09/04/the-hardest-thing-about-hiring-is-avoiding-the-fash https://www.wingolog.org/archives/2017/09/04/the-hardest-thi...
- AnimalMuppet 6y ago> Unfortunately, one participant was stuck on free speech side of the debate. All day the conference has been doing logical programs and term equivalence, but somehow this person didn't deduce the result "free speech fundamentalism == fash", at least within the current evaluation context. Really? Someone who writes that is where you're looking for guidance? Words fail me to describe how appalling this is. Free clue: You can believe in strong free speech protection without being fascist. You'd be amazed at how many people do so - who believe in free speech on principle, not because they want to be able to say their secret horrible beliefs out loud. Putting them in the fascist category merely shows that your brain has turned off, and you're willing to harm completely innocent people in order to try to protect against your current bogeymen.
- bitwize 6y ago> Really? Someone who writes that is where you're looking for guidance? Words fail me to describe how appalling this is. Did you read the rest of the blog post? Or did seeing "<my dearly held American value>=fash" stop your thought? As Andy says, free speech really only works in a context where everybody is of equal power. In an asymmetric power context, speech against those with less power is objectively more damaging than speech against those with more power, and is therefore more legitimately subject to restriction. Tolerating speech against the marginalized thus pulls society further in a pro-fascist direction. You should really consider whether it makes sense to be more appalled by someone calling out tolerance of hate speech as fascist, than by the hate speech itself.
- AnimalMuppet 6y agoReplying late. I was going to just let all the downvotes be your answer, but after thinking about it for a day, I decided that this deserved more of a reply. Yes, I read the rest of the blog post. I see a couple problems with your position here. First, fascists - real fascists - aren't free speech advocates. They restrict the speech of their opponents. So calling someone fascist because they advocate free speech is rather off. In fact, your position is closer to the fascist one. Second: "fash". Part of the fascist playbook is short, dismissive, contemptuous labels for their opponents. It's part of the dehumanization process. And here you are, doing exactly that. That's two different parts of the fascist methodology that you (and the blog poster) are exhibiting. You might think carefully about that. When opposing tyranny, be careful of the methods of tyrants, lest you become one.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]