3 ms·
A yes, the famous S500K problem. Like the even more famous Y2K problem people (a small number in this case) will rush to fix it in time, and then the consensus
by gumby 6y ago
A yes, the famous S500K problem. Like the even more famous Y2K problem people (a small number in this case) will rush to fix it in time, and then the consensus will be that the whole thing was overblown.
Making limiting simplifications is one of the important legs of engineering (the other two being making tradeoffs and focusing on accomplishing the goal).
- samplatt 6y agoWhat is the famous S500K problem? Your comment here is the first result on google for "S500K". Completely agree wrt the other points though...
- gumby 6y agoSorry, it was a bit of a joke: Y2K was Year 2000 and my made up name S500K was Stockprice over around $500K. I suppose I should have written "famous". Those of us over a certain age remember how much work went into patching the Y2K issue, and how it changed the software industry, and yet was pooh-poohed by the general press in the final year of the last millennium (2000) when nothing material went wrong. My point was the article was a little bit alarmist, which it almost had to be to spin out a brief article about what is otherwise an amusing piece of trivia that would fit in a sentence: "Berkshire Hathaway's price has almost reached the point where it can't be represented in NASDAQ's computer, but they are patching their code and expect everything to work fine by the time the stock reaches that point, if ever." I'd be glad to chuckle in passing upon encountering that sentence, but was annoyed at the padding used by the poor reporter to make an article of it. Given the state of the world it's hard to blame anyone (reporter, editor, Bloomberg management...) for this phenomenon.
- LorenPechtel 6y agoNothing material went spectacularly wrong. There were things like the supermarket whose inventory computer was tossing a bunch of perfectly good product until someone noticed that the "expired" goods they were disposing of weren't expired at all.
- gumby 6y agoThat was thanks to a tremendous amount of work beforehand. The nasdaq thing will be easily fixed in time too.
- oblio 6y agoOn the other hand, some of these limitations, especially ones made after 2000 or so, can be really shortsighted. All of mainstream computing should have 64 integers by now, 4 digit years, etc.
- gumby 6y agoWhen you are designing a very high throughput system you do often end up needing to trim bits from a transaction in order to fit an integral number into a page/packet/buffer or even a cache line. Other kinds of code may not have these kinds of requirements in which case I agree that these kinds of limitations can be short sighted. But that kind of decision is what I was talking about with respect to engineering.