5 ms·
> it's on you to improve yourself Incels call this "maxxing". It doesn't seem to be particularly effective for them. > Pushing the blame outwards to some othe
by matheusmoreira 6y ago
> it's on you to improve yourself
Incels call this "maxxing". It doesn't seem to be particularly effective for them.
> Pushing the blame outwards to some other group for not bending to fulfill your needs is a real problematic stance.
Why? Reducing inequality in dating seems like a fair goal to me. People become incels because everyone else rejects them. If that doesn't change, the number of incels will keep growing.
- Pfhreak 6y agoIt's not working because they believe the wrong things about why they are struggling to find companionship. It's not just find some stat to max and done, positioning the problem this way is itself part of the problem. > Reducing inequality in dating What does this mean, be specific. I cannot think of anything except absolutely ghoulish ideas that remove agency from women.
- matheusmoreira 6y ago> It's not working because they believe the wrong things about why they are struggling to find companionship. So they don't need to improve themselves, they just need to believe in the right things and suddenly women will value them. Really? > I cannot think of anything except absolutely ghoulish ideas that remove agency from women. And yet it's this agency that created such a thing as incels. Look at data from online dating services, plenty of evidence showing over 80% of men are rejected outright. Do you think this is normal?
- Pfhreak 6y agoNo, you misunderstand. They are optimizing for what they think will get them success, not what will actually get them success. > And yet it's this agency that created such a thing as incels. No, incels were not created created because women have agency in who they date. What toxic nonsense. And also, you still haven't put forward any changes you'd like to see to remedy the situation as you see it. Bring solutions to the table if you think there is a problem.
- matheusmoreira 6y ago> not what will actually get them success Which is? > incels were not created created because women have agency in who they date Did you not look at the evidence? Online dating is already the primary means of forming relationships. There's data showing women reject over 80% of men they see on dating apps. They actively choose to compete over the other 20%. They'd rather share a top 20% man than settle with a bottom 80% man. How is this supposed to not create a class of universally rejected men? > Bring solutions to the table if you think there is a problem. Why bother? I doubt you'd consider any real solution since they would naturally result in disadvantages for women in favor of men and would therefore be "toxic nonsense".
- Pfhreak 6y ago> Which is? Let me use an analogy. As a manager I help my folks get promoted all the time. The folks who struggle the most are the ones who think about promotion as a set of checkbox items they have to cross off. The ones who are easily promoted are the ones who are looking less at the criteria and more at how they can be introspective and develop themselves. Framing finding a relationship in a "I'll just check these checkboxes and then I will immediately get a relationship" fundamentally misunderstands that we aren't generally selecting partners for one trait. No one is working from a checklist when they select their partners, so why set yourself up to fail by imagining they are. Develop a growth mindset, focus on building your skills, build rich and fulfilling friendships. Ask for feedback and accept it. Build others up. People will want to be around you. > Did you not look at the evidence? I did a cursory Google search, which suggested online dating results in roughly the same outcomes as in person dating. > How is this supposed to not create a class of universally rejected men? If you are suggesting that 80% of men will face universal rejection, I find that extraordinarily hard to believe. It's quite frankly trivially falsifiable. > Why bother? Because you've made vague gestures that somehow society is to blame, but won't say how you'd fix it. Either that means you aren't sure, which undermines the idea that society is actually to blame, or your ideas are so repugnant that you are afraid to show them the light of day. You do not get to claim a moral victory by claiming to be a victim and then failing to engage with even the lightest questioning of your narrative.