3 ms·
> the vast majority of these M&A destroy capital Even if true, it's irrelevant. The vast majority of VC investments also lose money, or as you put it "destroy
by crazygringo 6y ago
> the vast majority of these M&A destroy capital
Even if true, it's irrelevant. The vast majority of VC investments also lose money, or as you put it "destroy capital" -- that's just high-risk investment generally. Nobody knows in advance what the future holds, which is why you spread your risk with lots of investments (or acquisitions).
But as long as you have enough runaway successes, then acquisitions are an overall profit-making, not profit-destroying, strategy. Even if the profit only comes from a small minority of them.
And that's only if you're counting the direct future profitability of an acquisition. Many times, the acquisition is also for key expertise or employees that may otherwise be prohibitively difficult to get, patents, the only way to compete in time, or is even strategically defensive -- to prevent your main competitor from acquiring the same critical technology/team.
- hedora 6y agoI think the point is that there is some real business subsidizing the failed M&As. If a VC lost money on average (mean) with each investment, they’d run out of money, and the problem would self correct. If a company is able to print unlimited cash, they can use the revenue on unlimited ill-advised acquisitions, and do unbounded damage to the economy.
- caseysoftware 6y ago> If a company is able to print unlimited cash, they can use the revenue on unlimited ill-advised acquisitions, and do unbounded damage to the economy. At some point, they're still bound by what lenders will give them or how much investors will buy their stock for. But apply the same to a government that can print unlimited cash.. (We may quibble over "unlimited" but it has been US Fed policy for decades and appears to be accelerating now.)
- crazygringo 6y ago> there is some real business subsidizing the failed M&As Citation needed. This is a common claim, but it flies in the face of common sense and financial incentives. Corporate boards simply do not approve acquisitions because they've got no better ideas of what to do with cash, that's a fantasy. Boards are held accountable to investors, and investors want to make money, not fritter away cash. Investors want rising stocks or dividends at the end of the day, period. Like I said, acquisitions are investments and investments can be risky, and so it's super easy to say in hindsight that an acquistion was dumb and that the board must be irresponsibly frittering away money instead of returning it to investors. But hindsight is always 20/20, right? As a general rule, companies simply are not "subsidizing" M&A's. It's just not how businesses or boards work at all.
- mrep 6y agoInstagram was bought for 1 billion and is now estimated to be worth over a hundred billion dollars. Facebook has acquired 89 companies according to crunchbase so even if all of those cost a billion each which they didn't, Instagram would have made up for all of them single handedly.
- gogopuppygogo 6y agoAnd yet the “other bets” from Google don’t yet have a hit… “The next big thing” is super hard work.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]