5 ms·
Dell patches 12-year-old driver vulnerability impacting millions of PCs
- lgats 6y agohttps://cve.report/CVE-2021-21551 https://cve.report/CVE-2021-21551
- excalibur 6y ago> This bug is nothing out of the ordinary. In summation
- anonymousiam 6y agoSeems to be an optional package. It's not on any of my Dell hardware. Not the sort of thing a security-conscious person would willingly install anyway.
- martey 6y agoFrom the security company's report at https://labs.sentinelone.com/cve-2021-21551-hundreds-of-millions-of-dell-computers-at-risk-due-to-multiple-bios-driver-privilege-escalation-flaws/ https://labs.sentinelone.com/cve-2021-21551-hundreds-of-mill... : > The firmware update driver component, which is responsible for Dell Firmware Updates via the Dell Bios Utility, comes pre-installed on most Dell machines running Windows and freshly installed Windows machines that have been updated. Dell's security advisory page (https://www.dell.com/support/kbdoc/en-us/000186019/dsa-2021-088-dell-client-platform-security-update-for-dell-driver-insufficient-access-control-vulnerability https://www.dell.com/support/kbdoc/en-us/000186019/dsa-2021-...) suggests that it would be installed if you installed any of a number of their update programs: > This driver file may have been installed on your Dell Windows operating system when you used firmware update utility packages, Dell Command Update, Dell Update, Alienware Update, Dell System Inventory Agent, or Dell Platform Tags, including when using any Dell notification solution to update drivers, BIOS, or firmware for your system.
- greenyoda 6y agoThe "Process Hacker" tool that this article refers to seems quite useful. It can be found here: https://processhacker.sourceforge.io https://processhacker.sourceforge.io (free GPL software)
- w7 6y agoYes, +1 for Process Hacker, it's basically an open source alternative to Sysinternals Process Explorer[0]. The service alerts noted in this article in particular led me to getting spooked and discovering that Windows Defender likes creating fun malware-like driver service names like MpKslasdfas3.sys. I'm at the point where it's always open to increase system awareness, and for quick filehandle views when I forget what application is stopping me from ejecting a USB. [0] https://docs.microsoft.com/en-us/sysinternals/downloads/process-explorer https://docs.microsoft.com/en-us/sysinternals/downloads/proc...
- _carbyau_ 6y agoI find it weird that Windows doesn't already tell you what app is holding a file/directory/USB locked when you try to move/delete/eject something. Is there some common use case that makes this hard?
- w7 6y agoYeah I don't believe windows tells you in the pop-up at all. Spawning questions like https://superuser.com/questions/87364/can-windows-tell-me-what-is-using-my-usb-drive https://superuser.com/questions/87364/can-windows-tell-me-wh... For me sometimes it's something as simple as a "rogue" notepad I lost track of on another monitor.
- _carbyau_ 6y agoI agree it doesn't tell you. Your link has some great pointers, even the event log will straight up tell you. So why doesn't the popup tell you? It doesn't seem like a complicated issue, hence my query as I feel like I am missing something here.
- annoyingnoob 6y agoWhen you manage a number of Dell computers, the Dell Update package is helpful. Dell Update will alert you when there are updates available. Not so different than Windows Update. Keeping up to date with drivers and firmware is a security-conscious thing to do. I don't use any of the other Dell software/packages but I find Update helpful.
- darig 6y agoDude!
- anonymousiam 6y agoI have always used the DOS/FreeDOS method to update my Dell firmware. Seems silly to let an insecure OS such as Windows have write access to the BIOS. It would provide an easy path to the holy grail of malware persistence.
- secondcoming 6y agoEvery time I've updated the BIOS on my Dell laptop it's been done on the next boot, before Windows starts.
- orev 6y agoThe update process that runs in the OS would need to use the driver at issue here to write the new firmware into flash at some staging location. After that is done, then you reboot, and the chips see there’s a staged update and applies it.
- cesarb 6y agoThat's not how UEFI capsule updates (which AFAIK is what modern Dell computers use) work. The update is written to the EFI partition, the computer reboots into an EFI updater which loads the update to RAM and tells the BIOS where it is, the computer then reboots again and the BIOS itself loads the firmware update from the staging location in RAM and writes it to flash (which is still unlocked at that point in the boot sequence). At no point does anything other than the BIOS write to the flash.
- chenxiaolong 6y agoThat's matches what I've observed on my ~2017 Dell XPS. On Linux with fwupd (and Windows), it would write the updater to the EFI partition and then set it as the default boot entry for the next boot. I had to manually add Dell's certificate to the EFI "db" variable when I switched to using custom secure boot keys.
- brian_herman 6y ago
- DeusExMachina 6y agoIt's not clear from the article, but my reading is that while the bug was introduced 12 years ago, it was discovered and fixed only now. Which is different from knowing about it but ignoring it for 12 years.
- antibuddy 6y agoI'd infer from the CVE naming (CVE-2021-21551) that it was discovered this year.
- dspillett 6y agoIt was publicly documented by the people generating those codes this year. It could have been discovered quite some time before that, and going by some tweets already posted (caveat: I've not verified anything here) some parts of it at least we're noticed, and Dell notified about them, in 2019.
- afrcnc 6y agothey actually ignored it only 2 years: https://twitter.com/aionescu/status/1389713670138073089 https://twitter.com/aionescu/status/1389713670138073089
- 45ure 6y agoI read this CVE with some interest, to see if it provides a solution to a frustrating problem, involving a Latitude 5300 (2-in-1). The problem: once the device is fully charged and subsequently shutdown, it rapidly drains the battery to around 80% within a few hours ─ at which point it retains the remaining charge. The problem is less pronounced, when it is put into sleep mode. I have been through numerous suggestions and permutations; 'hard' shutdown by holding the power button for varying durations, BIOS updates, OS updates (W10 latest build/version/updates/drivers), manufacturer specific driver updates, fresh rebuilds, tweaking power,wake,idle,throttle settings for CPU, network adapters (via BIOS and OS), date/time anomalies, turning off Modern/Connected-Standby, Registry hacks etc. Furthermore, I have contemplated using Wireshark and other tools to diagnose the problem, but that would require a significant chunk of my time troubleshooting a device, which I expect to work, out of the box. I resent the fact, that no explanation or a solution is forthcoming from Dell, which is a matter of concern. The post below describes my conundrum, fairly accurately. https://www.dell.com/community/Latitude/Latitude-7400-battery-drain-after-shutdown/td-p/7507300 https://www.dell.com/community/Latitude/Latitude-7400-batter...
- aetherspawn 6y agoI’m not sure if this helps, but if the battery is charged to 100% and then stored for a long period of time, it will not last long at all. 2 years, tops. As an engineering approximation that we use in the industry, each 5% undercharged may very well double the cycle life of your battery. 80% is usually the good point of compromise for most consumer electronics. My XPS has options for smart battery charging/storage so you might try playing around with the optional battery optimisation apps to see if one of those charging modes is enabled. Chances are it might be “fake charging to 100” but intentionally limiting to 80 based on your usage pattern.
- 45ure 6y agoThank you for engaging, and for your suggestions. I have owned the machine from new, for a little more than a year. It was manufactured approximately 4 months prior to the date, it came into my possession. The laptop was displaying the problem described, from the outset. I am in full agreement with your assessment on ageing devices exhibiting the Bathtub Curve, and also your suggestion on undercharging. However, the battery on this device has less than 15 cycles in total. Furthermore, when in Sleep mode, it only loses 2-3% daily from its designed capacity -- which is an acceptable range. Hence, the reason for my curiosity to determine the precipitous drop in charge, when the machine is in a complete shutdown state. You are correct, there are a lot of features in the latest BIOS for management i.e. CPU, power, network, battery etc. I have disabled most of them or opted for the best possible option, where appropriate. The point about the battery is moot, as I am more concerned about an undocumented feature which might be causing the high drain. There are more reports of Dell laptops exhibiting this unsolvable behaviour, than any other manufacturers combined ─ which usually relate to Modern Standby and/or Intel Management Engine(IME).
- dang 6y agoWe've changed the URL from https://therecord.media/dell-patches-12-year-old-driver-vulnerability-impacting-millions-of-pcs/ https://therecord.media/dell-patches-12-year-old-driver-vuln..., which points to this. From the guidelines: "Please submit the original source. If a post reports on something found on another site, submit the latter." https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
- giuliomagnifico 6y agoOkay thanks!
- marcodiego 6y agodbutil_2_3.sys ... it only affects windows dell machines, right? https://xkcd.com/272/ https://xkcd.com/272/
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- seemaze 6y agoThis is why we don't let 12-year-olds drive
- richardfey 6y agoI believe a consistent number of users will have their systems compromised but not top-notch security skills or support to understand why, and thus Dell will not get any negative PR from it.
- sloshnmosh 6y agoThis is why having preinstalled bloat ware on your computer is bad. I’ve seen a lot of old outdated apps on consumer grade PC’s that reinstall themselves after a factory restore that could be used by malware. HP seems to be even worse than Dell in doing this and it’s recommended that you format the hard drive and install a clean OS
- paulmd 6y agoif a vendor makes use of the Windows Platform Binary Table then it can use the UEFI to persist even through a format. This is how Lenovo did the superfish thing (also used by various asset-theft-tracking services) and afaik it was never removed from Windows or the UEFI, Lenovo was just shamed into not using it.
- sloshnmosh 6y agoExcellent point! I had forgotten about the problem with this.
- Ghidradev 6y agoAwesome research!