3 ms·
>> But then again, aren’t we all doing the same, regurgitating bits and pieces that we heard or read before and liked? We can do that. We can also not do that.
by YeGoblynQueenne 6y ago
>> But then again, aren’t we all doing the same, regurgitating bits and pieces that we heard or read before and liked?
We can do that. We can also not do that. Language models can only do that.
My comment is stripped of nuance (language models don't do that exactly) but it should point at the difference: humans can be as dumb as bricks, or as smart as humans. Language models don't even come close to our brighter moments. They don't even come close to the brighter moments of our pets, and our pets can't generate human language.
You have kids? Think of whom you'd like to spend the next decade or two around: a five year old human or GPT-3? Which one would you find more interesting, original, curious, do you think?
I think people who are the most excited about GPT-3 are the ones who are used to even dumber, more boring interactions with computers than the repetitive and unoriginal text generation of language models. Or perhaps it's humans who are used to boring interactions with other humans. Technology has done some weird things to us of late I fear.
- WesolyKubeczek 6y ago> You have kids? Think of whom you'd like to spend the next decade or two around: a five year old human or GPT-3? Which one would you find more interesting, original, curious, do you think? Kids and language models are very different kinds of "interesting". I like to be around my child, because I love her and it's good for the soul. If I only have one time slot and a choice who to spend it with, GPT-n can go pound sand, I'll be with my kid. A language model can certainly be fascinating in other ways. It brings me into a philosophical mood and spurs some questions about the humanity and quality of human knowledge, and efficiency of passing ideas around, but those don't imply answers I'd like to have, and tend to eat my soul away.