5 ms·
How do they impact deserts? Are there some species that can only thrive in the searing sun? Plus, to my untrained eye, what else, except for bacteria (and even
by oblio 6y ago
How do they impact deserts? Are there some species that can only thrive in the searing sun?
Plus, to my untrained eye, what else, except for bacteria (and even that, in limited amounts) thrives in desert conditions?
Everything I know about biology tells me that deserts are relatively bereft of life compared to temperate or tropical climates.
Also, what alternative is less harmful to life, in general?
- mcny 6y agoYou raise a good question. I wonder, just a thought experiment, if providing shade in a desert might create refuge for plants that can't survive directly in the desert sun...
- Symbiote 6y agoThose would be different plants than the ones already living there (ones that can survive in direct sunlight). The usual aim is to preserve the full variety of the world's ecosystems, and encouraging or allowing non-native species into a desert works against that.
- evgen 6y agoYes, there are some species that require desert conditions in order to live. They have adapted to this particular harsh environment and the conditions in these places help keep out competition for the scarce available resources. You really should do some basic research or at least watch an Attenborough documentary because "everything you know about biology" is apparently quite limited. Yes, deserts have less life and far less obvious signs of it given the lack of resources, but that also means that the web of life between the various organisms is far more fragile and takes a lot longer to recover from any injury or intrusion. A far better place to put solar panels are in places where we know the impact of people and machines will be barely noticed and where life will spring back quite quickly. Put them in the middle of farmland. We have far more arable land than we need to be using, taking it out of production for a decade or two will be good for the soil, and it will spring back to life within days of the construction machinery leaving.
- patrickk 6y agoDeserts have been growing though, particularly the Sahara due to human activities like farming and grazing animals. So perhaps there’s opportunities to reduce deserification by combining solar and agriculture, and also provide power to poor regions. According to this link there is promising benefits: https://cleantechnica.com/2019/09/09/combining-solar-farming-benefits-both/ https://cleantechnica.com/2019/09/09/combining-solar-farming...
- californical 6y agoThe California desert is so different though - there is so much life everywhere. Spending nights camping out there, you just see so much. There are these really cute rat-looking things that eat bark and make a crazy scratching sound while you’re trying to sleep. There’s a huge variety of birds, some of which are brutal — they’ll pick up those rats and throw them at a cactus to impale them so they can be eaten more easily. Then there’s mice, ants, coyotes (woke up in the middle of the night to a big pack running by), tons of crazy plants. There’s even some spots with water & real oasis feeling - palm trees, frogs, insects, and running water - right in between some cliffs, tucked away, with no people around as far as you can see. I always thought the desert was just mostly sand and occasional cactus, but have been proven SO wrong after spending lots of time there.
- oblio 6y ago> A far better place to put solar panels are in places where we know the impact of people and machines will be barely noticed and where life will spring back quite quickly. Put them in the middle of farmland. We have far more arable land than we need to be using, taking it out of production for a decade or two will be good for the soil, and it will spring back to life within days of the construction machinery leaving. "We need to be using" from a metric you just conjured, or we are actually using?
- evgen 6y agoUsing the US as an example, too much land is used for cereal grains like corn and wheat, to the point where it has become politically necessary to subsidize worthless and inefficient usages like ethanol just to get rid of the surplus. Ergo, I am making the assertion that if the US can afford to waste arable farmland growing corn that then needs to heavily subsidized to turn into ethanol and HFCS this arable land is being wasted and could be better served as space for solar panels. Taking land like this out of production will serve the purpose of supporting crop prices (limiting the political fallout of such a move) and it is well-established that modern farm practices have done significant damage to topsoil and that leaving land fallow or planting gaps between panels with prairie grasses will help build back some of the topsoil and soil nutrients. Do you have a counter-argument to refute my assertion?
- dubyah 6y agoIt's not like the area is straight up (coarse and rough and irritating) sand. Tortoises, foxes, lizards, snakes, rodents, bats, birds, etc. Flora wise, it's going to be predominantly desert scrub bush and to a lesser degree, microphyll woodland. Even in the article photo, you can see desert scrub in the undeveloped portions. I think environmentalists that care about the desert would much prefer solar development to occur on already disturbed land.
- oblio 6y ago> would much prefer solar development to occur on already disturbed land. Where? "Disturbed" land is taken.
- ben_w 6y agoIn fairness, plenty of rooftops still don’t have PV on them. We never did manage to get solar roadways strong enough to use and cheap enough to be economical; but I wonder, could we do better with solar between the rails of railway lines? Or high enough above them to enclose them and their trains?
- javagram 6y agoSolar roadways were always a terrible idea. Solar railways would have the same problem. Putting solar above parking lots and parking decks is a much more viable way to use vehicle-related infrastructure for solar. Using desert habitats are probably superior since we are in a climate emergency and need to build as much solar and wind as possible as fast as possible. Ground solar is cheaper than elevated solar as I understand it.
- ben_w 6y ago> Solar roadways were always a terrible idea. Solar railways would have the same problem. As I understand it, the problem was it was too expensive to make it sufficiently damage resistant, that damage being continuous wear from all the traffic. Just outside my window, there is a tram line. Grass grows in the spaces between the rails. I suspect you could put normal panels in those gaps where grass currently grows, and most of the panels would last just as long there as they would on a rooftop.
- Symbiote 6y agoThere's a brief overview of the flora and fauna in this desert here [1], and much more detail on the "See also" pages. In particular, note the endemic flora — these species live _only_ in this desert. I don't know what impact this development will have, so I won't comment on that. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Colorado_Desert#Flora_and_fauna https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Colorado_Desert#Flora_and_faun...
- nindalf 6y agoGoing to guess limited impact. The Colarado Desert is 7 million acres. This project will use 2000 acres. That's 0.02%.