3 ms·
> Terrible article, Amazon didn’t pay profit taxes, because Amazon didn’t make profits but instead, a loss. How is this an issue? Because if Amazon makes a los
by mschuster91 6y ago
> Terrible article, Amazon didn’t pay profit taxes, because Amazon didn’t make profits but instead, a loss. How is this an issue?
Because if Amazon makes a loss on selling 44 billion € of merchandise, either Amazon is incompetent beyond belief or they engage in somehow-legal tax dodgery at the expense of European countries whose infrastructure they mercilessly wreck.
Simple logic leads to the latter explanation being more likely.
- whitepaint 6y agoShould Amazon give away their money voluntarily? Just by playing by the rules is not good enough? When you do your taxes, don't you with your accountant try to pay as little as possible?
- cynix 6y ago> When you do your taxes, don't you with your accountant try to pay as little as possible? As a salary-earning individual, there's very little you can do to actually reduce your taxes by a meaningful amount, let alone down to zero like these corporations can.
- whitepaint 6y agoI'm a freelancer, I'm sure many here are as well. I do my own taxes (or more precisely, my accountant does). And it was more to demonstrate, does anyone pay more than they have to? Why do we expect businesses to act differently than how individuals do?
- wolfretcrap 6y agoThen why not start a company if the grass is sooo much greener on other side. It's true you can claim a lot as expense and register zero profits but only when you really don't have money. People forget, Amazon gets its money from stock market - this money is someone's pension funds and savings, they are investing because people believe Amazon will one day then profit, they don't care about these losses. So what's the alternative? Prevent people from investing into profitable things?
- rlpb 6y agoAmazon is renowned for choosing growth investments over profit. The latter is taxable; the former isn't. Therefore it's possible that their tax reporting is entirely legitimate. I welcome investigation that shows otherwise, but in the lack of any actual evidence, I don't think it's reasonable to claim tax dodging.
- mytailorisrich 6y ago> Therefore it's possible that their tax reporting is entirely legitimate It's pretty much certain that Amazon's tax reporting is completely legal and above board. They cannot afford to not to. They are not your local tradesperson who is paid in cash and cooks the books. They are a massive, publicly traded company with all eyes on them at all times.
- IkmoIkmo 6y ago> Simple logic leads to the latter explanation being more likely. Simple logic would be to conclude that a US company with >$400 billion in revenue looking to take-over an EU market is going to make long-term investments that aren't profitable in the first years and generate losses on $40 billion of revenue in this new market. There's nothing strange about that. The article doesn't even mention your logic, nor provides any evidence for it, not even a specific allegation by expert opinion. That's why I think it's poor reporting. (I should not have said terrible reporting). I'd be happy to receive arguments against Amazon's faults because I'm not an investor, not a consumer, not a fanboy, and concerned about the larger issues. But I want to see the facts.