5 ms·
Algae biofuel has definitely been a thing that people have tried over and over again and it hasn’t happened after a few decades so presumably there is some issu
by bobthepanda 6y ago
Algae biofuel has definitely been a thing that people have tried over and over again and it hasn’t happened after a few decades so presumably there is some issue with commercialization.
Wikipedia claims algae has very high water requirements (>600L of water for 1L of fuel) https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Algae_fuel https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Algae_fuel
- BelenusMordred 6y ago> 600L of water for 1L of fuel Is this actually the problem or is there other factors? A lot more is needed for 1kg of beef or certain crops. I live in the tropics and water usage is just never an issue and if it was they'd actually store some of what falls from the sky. Truly doubt that water is the real bottleneck here. edit: From the wiki page Among algal fuels' attractive characteristics are that they can be grown with minimal impact on fresh water resources, can be produced using saline and wastewater
- bobthepanda 6y ago"Can be" != commercially viable.
- sunshineforever 6y agoIm proposing a conspiracy theory here, but the basically all of the world's most profitable companies are involved in fossil fuel production. They definitely have an incentive to not want this technology to thrive and their leaders have a lot of influence and money. The retort to this theory would be that a company with a lot of resources could simply invest in the new technology. But with the level of lazy corruption in the world it seems possible that these entities might be suppressing the technology somehow.
- ForHackernews 6y agoIt doesn't take a huge amount in the way of active suppression: hire a some of the brightest industrial chemists and pay them well to work on your stuff instead of untested, unprofitable algae technology. Other smart people will similarly work on financial derivatives or cost-per-click optimisation instead of money-losing algae. It's not a conspiracy, it's just capitalism chasing returns.
- sideshowb 6y agoOn the other hand if one of them cracks algae fuel production they get to make an awful lot of future money off all their existing fuel distribution infrastructure. Iirc several of the big oil companies were at least experimenting with it 10 years ago.
- pjc50 6y agoAlgal systems are ecosystems, and artificial ecosystems are (ironically) prone to collapse. It's like waking up one day and discovering all your houseplants have died, except it's a thousand tonnes of now-dead gunk in your algae bioreactor.
- corty 6y agoDoesn't matter since you want to dump the gunk somewhere anyways. Just dump it and start over.
- bobthepanda 6y agoLosing entire batches of your product on a regular basis is pretty bad for a commercial product
- corty 6y agoIt is not lost, just a little more dilute than usual, and the gunk is not the end product, just a step in between. It is like prematurely harvesting grass. You get shorter stalks, and some extra work, that is all.
- bobthepanda 6y agoExtra work can make a difference if you are trying to get to competitive with fossil fuels and electricity.
- pjc50 6y agoIt's not the loss of the product but the process; you have to start it up again. Like accidentally killing your sourdough starter.
- andelu 6y agoMaybe Elon Musk suspects that effective algae biofuel production is a strong candidate for his 100M price, which would benefit SpaceX greatly. Maybe even feasible on Mars, in artificial atmosphere there.