4 ms·
I don’t understand the first picture. I expect the sum of the green arrows to be zero or point inwards to turn the train with the curve. If the forces were as
by Someone 6y ago
I don’t understand the first picture. I expect the sum of the green arrows to be zero or point inwards to turn the train with the curve.
If the forces were as indicated, wouldn’t the train derail?
- dredmorbius 6y agoThe diagram shows force vectors, not centre of gravity. Railcare rolling stock typically has low CG. Bogies, switches, and related equipment are located low in the car and have significant mass. The carriage shell itself is typically far lighter construction (less so in the US, due to higher crush-strength requirements based on the assumption that passenger and freight rail share trackbeds, significant enough that it's limited the maximum speed of US-based rail initiatives even presuming sections of dedicated track so long as any shared rights of way exist). For a CG diagram, I'd expect the CG to remain well within the wheel gague width, resulting in a stable vehicle.
- roelschroeven 6y agoThere would be a force towards the outside of the curve, yes. But that doesn't mean the train would derail: in the extreme case the flanges on the wheels would prevent it, but what actually happens in normal circumstances is the same thing that keeps trains centered on straights. In a nutshell: since the wheels have a larger diameter on the inside than on the outside, and since the left and right wheels are on the same solid axle and thus rotate at the same speed, any deviation caused negative feedback. The required superelevation for a given curve to eliminate lateral forces depends on the speed of the train; since not all trains travel at the same speed, and you have to account for slow or even stopped trains, the superelevation is always a compromise.
- aidenn0 6y agoThe vectors are the perceived force (which must be centrifugal) rather than the net force (which must be centripetal as you suggest).