8 ms·
Oxitec's GMO mosquitos were previously released in Brazil (450,000 during 2013-2015) and lead to unplanned genetic contamination of the local mosquito populatio
by walterbell 6y ago
Oxitec's GMO mosquitos were previously released in Brazil (450,000 during 2013-2015) and lead to unplanned genetic contamination of the local mosquito population, https://gizmodo.com/genetically-modified-mosquitoes-are-breeding-in-brazil-1838146152 https://gizmodo.com/genetically-modified-mosquitoes-are-bree...
> tests conducted by Oxitec prior to the experiment suggested that around 3 to 4 percent of F1 offspring would survive into adulthood, but it was presumed these lingering mosquitoes would be too weak to reproduce, rendering them infertile. These predictions, as the new research shows, were wrong … portions of the genome from the transgenic strain had “incorporated into the target population,” ... anywhere from 10 to 60 percent of mosquitoes analyzed featured genomes tainted by OX513A … the Oxitec scheme worked at first, resulting in a dramatic reduction in the size of the mosquito population. But at the 18-month mark, the population began to recover, returning to nearly pre-release levels. According to the paper, this was on account of a phenomenon known as “mating discrimination,” in which females of the native species began to avoid mating with modified males.
- kungito 6y agothis is like, the first thought you have when thinking about this problem. why would the females choose the infected one
- 0-_-0 6y agoBecause they can't tell the difference. It's not obvious that they can evolve to tell the difference until you try.
- trhway 6y ago>Because they can't tell the difference. you're kidding. I mean to people of course all mosquito look the same. It is a top of anthropocentrism though to think that mosquito would not differentiate. The basis of selection is "best fit" (to bring in and/or bring up new generation), and the weakness to the point of infertility is naturally selected out very quickly.
- 0-_-0 6y agoIt's not obvious that a gene responsible for reproduction would produce an external characteristic that can be recognised by other mosquitoes.
- ganafagol 6y agoNeither is it obvious that it would not. And that needs to be shown here. There is actually evidence to the contrary of your position. The grandparent post mentions mating discrimination.
- JimBlackwood 6y agoThat was found as a result of the experiment, though. I think he was just pointing out why the expectation was missed (or not seen as likely enough) before the experiment started. I don’t think it’s weird to assume mosquitoes won’t be able to tell the difference. It turns out that was wrong, I hope it’s taken into account in this experiment.
- hahajk 6y agoIt’s also not guaranteed that a gene that makes you glow red under fluorescent light will be noticed by other mosquitoes, but we can probably toss that in the pile of growing evidence. “A fluorescent marker gene that glows under a special red light. This allows researchers to identify GM mosquitoes from wild mosquitoes.” https://www.cdc.gov/mosquitoes/mosquito-control/community/sit/genetically-modified-mosquitoes.html https://www.cdc.gov/mosquitoes/mosquito-control/community/si...
- arghwhat 6y agoYou're getting natural selection backwards. Evolution quickly selects against reproduction or immediate survival failure, but this modification leads to successful male offspring which makes the scenario trickier. Unless the modified mosquitoes are handicapped by something, they will be selected just like any other, as best fit metrics are superficial. Humans wouldn't be able to detect that a specific partner could only have male offspring unless it brought along visual defects. If the population survives for many generations with a significant population of defect males, if there is a physical characteristic in the defect males, and if that can be detected by a mutation present in some females - the UV marker maybe? - then the female population should slowly be replaced by ones that select against the defective male. That's a lot of ifs though.
- kungito 6y agoweren't they making sort of crossbreed and so made way more changes than 1 gene?
- pvaldes 6y ago> why would the females choose the infected one Why would the females choose the sexy Cuban mosquitoes? I always wonder this. Maybe they sing better songs with its wings. Or maybe, because being genetically different is attractive for females. The bigger the genetic mix, the more healthy, disease free and stronger the offspring. Or maybe they aren't choosing and just have a random brief encounters with as many males as possible. This is a question for an entomologist, but I would not expect mosquitoes behaving as humans in a prom necessarily.
- LeifCarrotson 6y agoMosquito females cannot submit genetic samples of potential mates to a sequencing laboratory. They cannot determine which of two males has a "bigger genetic mix". It's really easy to anthropomorphize the mosquitoes or to anthropomorphize natural selection; we shouldn't ascribe that kind of agency to them. Instead, reason about the consequences that we observe after the fact: perhaps the modified male mosquitoes are drawn from a different population than the local, unmodified males, and the groups have slightly different colorings. A random group of females might prefer the modified color, a different group might have no preference, and a different group might prefer the local color. After a few generations, the latter group will dominate. That's not because the female mosquitoes or Mother Nature made any kind of effort to find mates with good genetic material. No such agency was present in the process. Instead, those random behaviors that incidentally resulted in selecting good mates were more likely to be passed down.
- Grustaf 6y ago> Mosquito females cannot submit genetic samples of potential mates to a sequencing laboratory. They cannot determine which of two males has a "bigger genetic mix". Of course they can, you don't need to sequence DNA to get an idea of genetic affinity, you have the phenotype. I don't know about mosquitoes, but all higher animals obviously judge mates on genetics (based on the phenotype).
- avodonosov 6y agoIt is fascinating that the article does not mention this, if it is true.
- walterbell 6y agoThe 2019 paper [1] has more details. It received an editorial "Expression of Concern" in 2020 [2], but no correction was issued to the paper. [1] https://www.nature.com/articles/s41598-019-49660-6 https://www.nature.com/articles/s41598-019-49660-6 [2] https://www.nature.com/articles/s41598-020-62398-w https://www.nature.com/articles/s41598-020-62398-w
- avodonosov 6y agoYes, the gizmodo.com article has this information. However, the concerns about the critical publication are due to the very broad conclusions it makes. But the mere facts of: - lasting genetic contamination of the mosquito population - failure to erradicate the Aedes aegypti in Brazil are they true? > According to Oxitec, the “OX513A self-limiting gene does not persist in the environment,” and that the “limited 3-5% survival of the OX513A strain means that, within a few generations, these introduced genes are completely eliminated from the environment.” That is about the self-limiting gene. How about the other genes?
- asdff 6y agoThe others would be the same as the unmodified Aedes aegypti.
- avodonosov 6y agowhy?
- neves 6y agoThe Dengue epidemic stopped in Brazil after the release of the GM mosquito. But it also receded in places where the mosquito were not released.
- newdude116 6y agoI got downvoted before for this but I say it again: To fight against evolutionary pressure is a stupid idea. What could possibly go wrong?
- bedobi 6y agoThis is an invasive species, it didn't evolve there
- tzs 6y agoA species that evolves in one habitat and gets moved to another doesn't stop evolving.
- HenryBemis 6y agoThe "What could possibly go wrong?" is a question we need to be asking on almost everything. This is why we look both ways when we cross a one-way street. The weak point in this case is that this happened initially in Brazil (below average on: https://worldpopulationreview.com/country-rankings/most-corrupt-countries https://worldpopulationreview.com/country-rankings/most-corr...), and now in Florida. Although I 'trust' US, I cannot forget of the legalized bribing called "Lobbying". When $bn roll, politicians roll over. USA is also missing from the above list. In this specific case, in the worst case, an aerial mosquito spraying plane can fix this in a couple of days, killing majority of insects in the area (even the beneficial ones) and the 'damage' is contained. It's not like they will evolve to become "Mimic" (https://www.imdb.com/title/tt0119675/ https://www.imdb.com/title/tt0119675/) within a couple of weeks.
- newdude116 6y agoI don't understand the downvote again. I makes me wonder about the education and intelligence of the average HN Reader. The article says nothing about the technology Oxitec uses. I checked, and as suspeced, they use a "gene drive" or a "mutagenic chain reaction" https://corporateeurope.org/en/2019/06/efsa-gene-drive-working-group-fails-independence-test https://corporateeurope.org/en/2019/06/efsa-gene-drive-worki... This is a very smart technology that was invented and does not exists in nature to my best knowledge. So you throw this unique genetic mechanism not against the mosquitos, but in fact you have evolutionary pressure against you. In the best case, they become resistant, in the worst case you end up with total other effects in total other organism that acquired this mechanism. An nuclear bomb explosion is limited in location and time. This genetic mechanism, once released, is potentially unlimited in location and time. So serious question, what could possibly go wrong?
- varispeed 6y ago> But at the 18-month mark, the population began to recover, returning to nearly pre-release levels. That's the whole point. Scientists have to build in "rent-seeking" properties into the "solution" so that the company can make money in perpetuity. Nobody is interested in solving mosquito problem once and for all.
- chmod775 6y agoNo. That's just how this works. Because modified males can't have offspring down the line, only females who mate unmodified males produce offspring, selecting for females who would mate with such. This might even hurt a company selling such a solution, because if they released a second batch, nobody would mate with them. Obviously this only works if modified males show any external characteristics. But even without all that, at some point the modified populace is going to die off, since that was the point, leaving only unmodified ones, before finally recovering.
- mrep 6y agoFrom the article: "The genetically engineered males carry a gene that passes to their offspring and kills female progeny in early larval stages. Male offspring won’t die but instead will become carriers of the gene and pass it to future generations. As more females die, the Aedes aegypti population should dwindle."
- irae 6y agoExactly. Your quote does not invalidate the previous statement at all. Per evolution basic theory, the gene most adapted to the environment and which produces more offsprings, survives. Therefore, offsprings of unmodified mosquitos have twice the chance to reproduce, as both males and females can reproduce and both will yield unmodified males and females. I wouldn't know the rate, but even if slowly, unmodified strain will come back, unless extinct. There need be no female preference for this to happen, but of course if they evolve to detect modified males it would accelerate the rate which modified mosquitos get extinct.
- 6y ago
- freddealmeida 6y agoI can see this with Covid vaccines. It is already starting with insurance companies. Negative genetic values are always culled.
- stjohnswarts 6y agoSo an experiment fails once and that's it?
- pessimizer 6y agoIs that what you believe, or do you think just mentioning a previous failed experiment is wrong?
- samstave 6y agoI hate mosquitos as much as the next bag of blood, but what I am not so sure about is the ability for Humans to understand the ecological ripple-effect killing off any large population of insect have on the overall ecosystem, environment and food-chain. We may dislike mosquitos, but there are MANY critters out there that thrive on eating their larvae or their adults. Just as humans have decimated the Monarch Butterfly's food/mating/hatching grounds (Monarch's almost exclusively rely on MilkWeed as a food and laying/hatching of their eggs. This "weed" grew from south america all the way through northern america, which is where the multi-generational-migration path of Monarchs occurs. By killing off MilkWeed with pesticides, as Humans don't find it an aesthetically pleasing plant, effectively destroyed the biological support infrastructure used for eons by the Monarch for their mass migrations up the corridor from Mexico north. So - Sure, we don't like mosquitos, but I would not trust that we understand the true, long-term impact of eradicating them just yet.
- Tagbert 6y agoThere are multiple mosquito species in each area and these control efforts only target a couple of species that are human disease vectors. Even if these specific species went extinct it would not significantly impact other creatures that prey on mosquitos. Previous eradication efforts used pesticides and impacts all mosquito species and lots of other creatures, as well. Using genetic targeting like this is much lower impact. The main question is whether it will be effective.
- betwixthewires 6y ago
- irae 6y agoI wouldn't expect them to not change the strains over such a longe period of testing. But I also expected that changes would be mentioned, so... although I am optimistic about GMO and I believe it is unavoidable, but this could have been more transparent for sure.