8 ms·
From a section on theory of self-reinforcement Once an office assembles a staff that has handled a capital trial, it draws upon this capacity to pursue the dea
by graderjs 6y ago
From a section on theory of self-reinforcement
Once an office assembles a staff that has handled a capital trial, it draws upon this capacity to pursue the death penalty in subsequent cases, which further augments the office’s institutional capacity to pursue the death penalty. This self-reinforcing dynamic between capacity and caseload makes it more likely for offices that obtain death sentences to seek the death penalty going forward. Conversely, offices that cease to obtain death penalties (or never obtained death penalties in the first place) may be less likely to reverse course as institutional capacity for death penalty sentencing erodes (or is never developed). … This path dependency may reflect practices of prosecutors who make the charging decisions whether to seek the death penalty, but it may also capture defense lawyering, judges, jurors, and other features of a county that make it more likely to continue to death sentence over time
Wow, Kafka couldn't have said it better himself. Morbid bureaucratic mechanism of horror
- fnord77 6y agoThe Penal Colony. That story is etched into my brain. Ugh
- gustavo-fring 6y agoThe Repeat Player vs. The One-Shot Player https://hschottlaender.wordpress.com/2013/10/17/the-repeat-player-vs-the-one-shot-player/ https://hschottlaender.wordpress.com/2013/10/17/the-repeat-p... (I don't know how good this source is.) Ideally this dynamic would also mean that defense lawyers and norms would get better over time instead of atrophying.
- throwaway8581 6y agoWhat is so horrible or kafkaesque about that? Prosecuting death penalty cases is hard and politically contentious. It also not a necessity, as you can secure life imprisonment sentences with much less effort. It makes sense that only those places committed to the practice will continue it.
- elliekelly 6y agoMore people being put to death because the autonomous bureaucracy has gotten better at putting people to death is pretty kafkaesque. It reminds me of the short story with “the machine” that cuts progressively deeper over time.
- lupire 6y agoWhy isn't it Kafkaesque the other counties are ineffective at capital cases? The only difference is who you believe morally right.
- oblio 6y agoIn almost the entire developed world, there is no death penalty anymore.
- elliekelly 6y ago> The only difference is who you believe morally right. This is also a theme frequently explored by Kafka. Especially in the machine short story I mentioned. People who believe they’re “right” in sentencing a person to death will come up with all sorts of ways to justify their amoral actions and Kafka created several characters who do.
- KingMachiavelli 6y agoSort of? Depends on who is the subject. 'Kafkaesque' doesn't just mean bureaucracy is bad but that it alienates the individual. Most defendants would probably expediency more alienation if the likelihood of a death penalty depended on which county tried them. Actually, The Trial itself references circumstances very similar to this. On the other hand, if there was some super depraved criminal that had a chance of walking free due to bureaucracy, then a individual on the prosecution side could be subject to disillusionment and alienation. So sure either side can be Kafkaesque but since it's more a one vs many i.e the individual facing society, the defendant's situation is more likely to be the loosing end.
- 6y ago
- bdefore 6y agoExceptionally well written. I clicked into the source but was disappointed the quotation didn't have a way to read more.
- swiley 6y agoThis kind of thing is why I've always argued against the death penalty. There are people that deserve it but it's very hard to figure out who.
- MomoXenosaga 6y agoMy country has life imprisonment. And we are not woke: you don't get out after 20 years. You get thrown in jail and you will rot in there while society forgets you. The death penalty is completely unnecessary. Hell some of those in prison after 30 seasons with no future probably wish they were dead.
- swiley 6y agoI argue against life imprisonment for the same reasons.
- canadianfella 6y agoReally? What about a serial killer that killed 50 kids?