2 ms·
I suppose one difference is that decompiling might cause one to be considered "tainted" by exposure to the internals, to some degree. Instead observing an opaq
by neilv 6y ago
I suppose one difference is that decompiling might cause one to be considered "tainted" by exposure to the internals, to some degree.
Instead observing an opaque box's external behavior, and reasoning from that, seems more "cleanroom".
I don't know whether that difference matters in this case, but I've long assumed it matters in some cases.
- wejn 6y agoThat’s a good way of looking at it. And yes, it is one of the unvoiced assumptions: as long as I heard two devices speaking, I can’t be breaking any EULAs or what not. Decompiling something would be another kettle of fish entirely. Not to mention that often times apps (even Java/Android apps) are obfuscated, which might make the reversing much harder (than sniffing traffic).