6 ms·
Ask HN: Why are all the submissions about Bill/Melinda Gates being killed?
It looks like about half of the submissions on /newest are about Bill and Melinda Gates divorcing. All of the submissions are flagged/dead. Why is this? I'm not looking to discuss the substance of the articles in this post — just trying to understand how the divorce of one of the biggest names in tech is not allowed on HN.
By contrast, there are many non-flagged/dead articles about Jeff Bezos' divorce.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- BitwiseFool 6y agoI'm starting to wonder what's actually going on here. So many posts about the same subject from almost every mainstream source imaginable. But they're all getting flagged and killed. I understand why all of those submissions are getting this treatment, but why are so many accounts still trying to post this news? Do they not see the new queue? Are they bots?
- slater 6y agoSome might be bots, but also, HN allows easy posting via bookmarklet https://news.ycombinator.com/submit https://news.ycombinator.com/submit
- gnicholas 6y agoIf someone doesn't have showdead turned on, they wouldn't see all the dead posts on /newest. They would just see that it's not on the front page and think that no one had yet posted it. This would be an increasingly unlikely explanation as time goes on, but with breaking news it's possible to be the first.
- bombcar 6y agoPeople see it, go to HN, don't see it on the front page, hit submit and submit it, and then it gets flagged dead.
- marto1 6y agoPart of it has to be for easy karma points. A lot of these headlines are specially crafted to arouse emotional responses from their readers especially if they are the "TV after work" kind of people. My personal opinion is I wouldn't want HN to turn into a mainstream news discussion board. It's not only pretty boring, but will also eventually attract other people interested only in that and the good stuff will drown.
- ErikVandeWater 6y agoPeople who are flagging it probably consider the articles insufficiently deep for HN. Most of the significant details won't be known for a while. Not to say the initial articles on the Bezos' divorce were deep.
- gnicholas 6y agoThat's true. I would still say that there is something of interest to discuss here, which is the trend (if n=2 can be a trend) of ultra-wealthy tech moguls getting divorced after being married for decades. These are two of the five richest couples in the world, and they were both married before being ultra-wealthy. Many people envy them for their wealth, power, access, health, etc. But apparently having all of these things does not secure marital bliss. And perhaps having access to everything under the sun actually makes marital happiness and security harder to come by. This raises the question: if this is true for the wealthiest people, is it also true for 'mere' hundred-millionaires or millionaires? What are the actual impacts of achieving high levels of wealth, and should we actually be happier having less money/power because it means that we are more likely to have better relationships?
- throwaway3b03 6y ago> This raises the question: if this is true for the wealthiest people, is it also true for 'mere' hundred-millionaires or millionaires? What are the actual impacts of achieving high levels of wealth, and should we actually be happier having less money/power because it means that we are more likely to have better relationships? I don't think there's any difference at all between having a net worth of $100m, or tens or hundreds of billions. Once you're at a point where you know that you'll never worry about money, you have enough estates, you can do anything within reason, you're not that sensitive to the number of digits on your bank statement. Scope insensitivity.
- gnicholas 6y agoI would guess that this is probably true, but then again I don't have $100M. It's possible that those people look up at wealthier folks in the same way that working wealthy look up at them (and working poor look up at working wealthy).
- jensgk 6y agoI don't understand it either. I think it is relevant. This flagged post has over 150 votes: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27030269 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27030269
- lox 6y agoThat one was mine, from the original tweet about 5 seconds after it was posted. I was perplexed that it was flagged given the impact the news will have on a variety of tech issues.
- BitwiseFool 6y agoAdditionally, the tweet itself is a primary source - directly from Bill Gates' own verified account.
- mtmail 6y agoDid the Bezos divorce have any impact? Maybe on the stock market, maybe on the Forbes list of riches people, but when it came to any of the businesses I can't identify an impact. She donated a lot of money, that came months later in a press release. None of the Bezos stories today have any valuable details beyond the initial tweet in my opinion.
- lox 6y agoIn this case they share a charitable foundation that contributes to lots of projects that are frequently discussed here.
- moralestapia 6y ago>Did the Bezos divorce have any impact? Of course it did! Among other things, on the stock market, on the Forbes list of riches people, and then afterwards, she donated a lot of money. Source: you.
- lifeformed 6y agoDoes it have to have an impact? There's so many trivial and inconsequential posts on the front page of HN every day, and they're not flagged to death. I thought the criteria for posts were interestingness, not impact to our daily lives.
- rvz 6y agoI don’t see a reason for the flagging. It is ‘news’.
- dang 6y agoPlenty of news is off topic on HN. Most, in fact.
- supernikita 6y agoI am very thankful that HN does not post this type of news. In the same vein, HN has had very little postings on COVID. THANK YOU !!!!
- pcdoodle 6y agoAnything negative about gates gets automatically downvoted here. Some PR botnet maybe?
- dang 6y agoThat's false, and please don't break the site guidelines like this. https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html "Please don't post insinuations about astroturfing, shilling, brigading, foreign agents and the like. It degrades discussion and is usually mistaken. If you're worried about abuse, email hn@ycombinator.com and we'll look at the data."
- moralestapia 6y ago>usually
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- dang 6y agoFor the obvious reason: the community is divided on whether it's on topic, so some users keep submitting the stories and other users keep flagging them. I don't know that there's much here that's intellectually interesting. This is probably one of those moments where HN can distinguish itself by not paying attention to a story. Regarding priors, the argument "$X1 got attention so why shouldn't $X2" doesn't work on HN, because there's a power-law dropoff in interestingness along any predictable sequence. So if Jeff and MacKenzie got a lot of attention, that's actually a reason why Bill and Melinda wouldn't. I'm not really sure that was the case to begin with though—these threads look pretty uninteresting: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18868713 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18868713, https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18865291 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18865291
- gnicholas 6y agoI appreciate that this post was unflagged, after having been flagged. But it appears not to be listed on the front page anymore, or even on /ask. Is that on purpose? If something is not flagged and is popular, what would the reason be for hiding it? People are not discussing the underlying article here — it is just a meta-discussion about what is allowed to be discussed on HN. It's a little surprising that this is being suppressed (either by community members or mods).
- dang 6y agoThe [flagged] marker shows up on a post when there are enough flags to kill an item. Whether it's actually killed or not depends on that and a few other things, such as how active the discussion is. That's why https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27030269 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27030269 shows [flagged] but not [dead]. But flags affect the ranking of a story long before they reach that fatal threshold. That's the case here. Moderators haven't done anything.
- gnicholas 6y agoThanks for the explanation. Is it only possible for people to [vouch] a submission once it is dead? If not, then it seems like posts can get caught in purgatory — not flagged enough to be dead (and therefore vouchable), but not alive enough to be seen anywhere. In this case, it seems a reasonable compromise would be to keep the post on /ask, but let it fall off of the main front page. This is a respectful discussion about HN/moderation, and that seems appropriate for Ask.
- boatsie 6y agoIt is probably considered gossip to discuss such matters, though I often see "person X has quit Y" to which I would say is of similar newsworthiness.
- sys_64738 6y agoBill Gates is the most influential computer man alive. One wonders if he’ll go back to programming now he is single.
- throwitaway12 6y agoThis is very relevant. Many of us work in tech, are married, and know of this couple., just for starters. It's so very sad every time there is controversial topics, out come the bot armies and flag/down vote them into oblivion. How can HN have such strong. encroaching censorship? There doesn't even seem to be many people disagreeing that this is very much on topic.
- naveen99 6y agoMaybe because Bill started microsoft almost 20 years before they got married. So Melinda may have signed a prenup, and might not get as large a split as mckenzie even if she didn’t.
- purplecats 6y agoThat makes me extra curious why she would be the one to initiate the divorce, at least on paper.
- naveen99 6y agoCash value of a losing vote is nonzero before an election.
- purplecats 6y agoSorry, too dumb to make the connection. Can you explain.
- naveen99 6y agoDuring the marriage, Melinda may get overruled in business matters by Bill. After exercising her option to divorce, she cannot be overruled on her portion of the wealth.
- Mandatum 6y agoI was very confused reading this title - I thought Bill and Melinda Gates had been killed, or there was some spam campaign about them being killed..
- dave333 6y agoBill Gates famously listed pros and cons of getting married on a white board so the process of getting divorced is probably just as intellectual. They are still going to work together on their foundation work so they appear to be avoiding a messy emotional split. It may just be a tax strategy who knows.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- CarelessExpert 6y agoSimple: it's just celebrity gossip and last I checked this wasn't People magazine. Just because it's about Gates doesn't mean it's interesting or relevant for this site.
- yamellasmallela 6y agoBecause its celebrity news and people really shouldn't care at all
- jitbit 6y agoHave to admit my own knee-jerk reaction was to flag the article. BUT when I got to the bottom of it (possibly the reason for divorce is to evade the new Biden's tax) - it is actually quite interesting.