4 ms·
> Here’s the thing - you shouldn’t have to choose between a career and having children. I actually disagree, and that's the reason I loved this article so much
by hn_throwaway_99 6y ago
> Here’s the thing - you shouldn’t have to choose between a career and having children.
I actually disagree, and that's the reason I loved this article so much: it acknowledges that, at the upper end, you do have to choose.
Of course, everyone should be able to have a career and also have children, and I agree that there are a lot of things society can do to make this an easier tradeoff. However, should everyone be able to be the CEO of a high growth startup (if that's your chosen career), and also have kids? Perhaps some people can manage that, but without a good support system in place (which usually means a stay-at-home spouse or at least enough for a nanny) one or the other usually suffers.
Fundamentally, life is about choices. Time is finite, so you can either spend some specific hour going over sales projections, or you can spend it with your kids - you can't do both. Even if the government had better leave policies, it's not like they can enforce you to take it. If you want to be the CEO of a startup, and you choose to spend your hour taking care of your kids, there is a good chance some other CEO is reviewing their sales projections. This is just the reality of living in a competitive economy.
- mcguire 6y agoWell, if you are the CEO of a high growth start up, you really can do what the wealthy have always done: go with the nanny. Here's a question for you: how many innovations (or whatever else you expect to benefit society from a high-growth startup or whatever) are we missing because people cannot do both? The weird thing about competitive environments is that above some level, winners and losers seem to be chosen based on everything except the competitive skill.
- alex_young 6y agoI'm not entirely sure we disagree on the point I was attempting to make. I didn't say that one should never be allowed to choose between being the CEO or having children at the same time, but I do think it's a societal failure if the choice is between having a career at all and having children, especially if that's a gendered ultimatum. I may actually disagree with you on the CEO point in another way however - Who knows, but I suspect some CEOs manage to spend time with their kids and run a successful company. As you say there are tradeoffs in life, and some people choose to have a family and others choose to take up fly fishing or something. It doesn't seem like this necessarily precludes anyone from starting a successful company. Some may even find that parenting gives them the insight they need to be successful in business.
- danielmarkbruce 6y agoNo one is saying the choice is "career at all" v "spending time with children". It's "having a crazy busy career" v "spending time with children". It can't be any other way. If one is willing to give up everything for X, they are almost certainly going to do better at X compared to equivalent folks who aren't willing to give it up. And, it isn't a choice society makes. Individuals make it, for themselves. Society isn't failing in the sense of having to make choices. Society is failing when it glorifies those to give up everything for X. It's just a choice, and it's usually not glorious.