4 ms·
> as much of a monopoly/monopsony as Walmart is, it's far less than what Amazon is. Walmart retail sales are significantly larger than Amazon's retail sales.
by sokoloff 6y ago
> as much of a monopoly/monopsony as Walmart is, it's far less than what Amazon is.
Walmart retail sales are significantly larger than Amazon's retail sales.
For 2019 (chosen to avoid the disparate impact of pandemic), Walmart sold $514B while Amazon retail sold only $135B first-party and $200B third-party. Given the growth rates, Amazon will pass Walmart, but I don't think Walmart has "far less" power in retail than Amazon.
- TameAntelope 6y agoThis, and Walmart isn't just going to sit by and let Amazon win, why would they? I think folks on the Internet generally tend to assume Amazon is inevitable, but I doubt that's how Walmart thinks of it. Walmart and Amazon are both good for one another, and their competition helps us, except for when they basically non-compete over things like wages.
- sokoloff 6y agoI agree about the internet/tech user part of that. If you asked me to give estimates of their relative size 5 years ago, I'd have probably said that Amazon was much bigger than Walmart, which would have been entirely wrong, of course. The pandemic was a huge boon for Amazon, but I don't think the battle for retail will have a clean, singular winner and consumers are endlessly demanding in terms of what it will take to remain the winner. Toys-R-Us and Sears learned that painful lesson within our adult lifetime. They won't be the last.
- ethbr0 6y agoFrom a little bit of retail corporate experience: people are used to seeing Amazon roll over competitors with under-invested supply chains. There aren't really any of those left. Amazon taking on Walmart, Home Depot, or (I assume) Target is going to look very different. Because all have been shoveling money into their supply chain efficiencies for the last 10 years.
- lupire 6y agoI think mail order and brick&mortar compete in some product segments, but are separate in others. For example, perhaps split off much of grocery and bulky cheap items as well as legally constrained products from WalMart's total (although Amazon is making inroads there).
- ethbr0 6y agoWalmart has a huge online/mail component too. They basically bought and (unlike so many) successfully integrated and digested Jet (and now Bonobos) explicitly for that.