7 ms·
I'm with you on almost all of this, but can you explain why you think it's incorrect that Yahoo wouldn't have to spend a lot of money to keep up with Google? G
by wpietri 6y ago
I'm with you on almost all of this, but can you explain why you think it's incorrect that Yahoo wouldn't have to spend a lot of money to keep up with Google?
Google's origin story doesn't seem relevant to me, in that Google won because they made radical leaps forward in search quality, compute cost, and and compute scale. As well as company culture around innovation/continuous improvement, I suspect. All at a time when the web was exploding: only 19% of people used the web at Google's launch; by 2008 it was circa 70%. [1]
It seems to me that by 2008, there were fewer easy innovations lying around to make. Or if there were, Google was well prepared to match them. That, plus the way the size of the web had exploded [2] in the decade since Google's launch suggests to me that competing with Google would have been extremely expensive. The way that other people have tried and failed since points that way too, as Google's market share is even larger now than it was in 2008.
[1] See https://www.statista.com/statistics/185700/percentage-of-adult-internet-users-in-the-united-states-since-2000/ https://www.statista.com/statistics/185700/percentage-of-adu... and https://www.statista.com/statistics/214662/household-adoption-rate-of-internet-access-in-the-us-since-1997/ https://www.statista.com/statistics/214662/household-adoptio...
[2] From 1997 to 2008, there were more than 100x more websites, and I expect those websites got larger both in number of pages and per-page size. https://www.internetlivestats.com/total-number-of-websites/ https://www.internetlivestats.com/total-number-of-websites/
- cbsmith 6y ago> Google's origin story doesn't seem relevant to me, in that Google won because they made radical leaps forward in search quality, compute cost, and and compute scale. That's the myth, but it's pretty far from the reality. Long before Google became such a dominant player, competing search engines had matched or exceeded its quality, compute cost, and ability to scale. > All at a time when the web was exploding: only 19% of people used the web at Google's launch; by 2008 it was circa 70%. Bingo. You nailed it. It turns out the search market was largely a distribution game. You wanted to be the search engine distributed to that massively growing audience, and Google did a great job of establishing itself as the first search engine presented to people. > It seems to me that by 2008, there were fewer easy innovations lying around to make. There's certainly been a lot of innovations in search since 2008, but nothing that was "disruptive". It's very hard to get more than a small percentage of people to change what search engine they use, and advertisers are not particularly interested in chasing that segment of the population. > The way that other people have tried and failed since points that way too, as Google's market share is even larger now than it was in 2008. Yeah, I really have to scratch my head at how people look at the empirical evidence and think that in 2008 it was a mistake to recognize the losing position competitors were in.
- Bukhmanizer 6y ago> Long before Google became such a dominant player, competing search engines had matched or exceeded its quality, compute cost, and ability to scale. Just curious, which ones? I remember Google felt so far above any other search engine for a very long time.
- hogFeast 6y agoEssentially all of their tech was taken from Robin Li and AltaVista/DEC. Brin did a lot of the implementation work, Page did nothing (a lot of the work he did do, didn't scale, and was highly inferior to existing work as he wasn't a strong programmer...I think he provided a server room or something, he was the snake oil salesman). The actual technological innovation in the search product was minimal (the stuff they did later to scale was pure innovation, but that came much later). They largely purchased their position (for a good price).
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- cbsmith 6y agoThe tech was "stolen" from HITS/IBM Research. Because of their success with their initial data center approach AltaVista was arguably one of the last to shift to a model that more closely resembled the one Google employed, but they certainly did a very fine job of it (late mover advantage and all that). I still liked AllTheWeb's data centers somewhat better, but at that point the differences were pretty small. I wouldn't agree with your characterization of Brin & Page's contributions, but their direct technical contributions to Google by that time were at best marginally greater than Yang's, so it's not really relevant anyway. Google definitely had some great tech, but the extent to which that won them the game is more myth than reality. Their aggressive strategic moves are really what made them successful.
- cromwellian 6y agoI worked at IBM TJ Watson research at the time. It's hard to "steal" from IBM, because at the time I was there, IBM's #1 problem was getting its research into the world. In 1996, I worked in a group on digital cash payment schemes, digital checking, years before PayPal, they had a trusted enclave (CITADEL PCMCIA card), we had a MIME plugin for Mosaic and Unix email that would do peer to peer digital money transfers, and when it came time to ask "when are we going to try to productize this", the answer came back "we talked with banks and will be ready to do a pilot project in 5 years" This is much like Steve Jobs "stealing" GUI, Smalltalk, and Ethernet from PARC and claiming there was no innovation. At that stage, shipping something consumers can use is innovation. If you were a techie/engineer in 1998, as opposed to a general consumer (of which there were very few), Google results WERE better than AltaVista and competitors. The early adopters and pioneers switched because like with Chrome v1, a lot of the value proposition was obvious. The bigger question perhaps is why didn't their competitors react quickly to prevent their rise, and I think the answer to that is in general, once a company makes a large splash, and gets the public attention, it's hard for others to overcome the free value from being the thought leader. This is true of Apple and true of Tesla in cars. Tesla makes the best EV right now. It's sexy, it's fast, and Elon Musk commands the world's attention. One day, other brands will catch up, they'll be Tesla competitors just as good, but no one will care, and Tesla -- if Musk doesn't fsck it up -- will continue to have a halo effect, a reality distortion field.
- chrisco255 6y ago> It seems to me that by 2008, there were fewer easy innovations lying around to make. Or if there were, Google was well prepared to match them. Except for privacy-centric search. This is what DuckDuckGo has capitalized on and it's worked out for them. Neither Microsoft with Bing nor Yahoo was able to see this as a niche to compete.