6 ms·
Amazon pays mountains of payroll taxes, as they are one of the largest employers in the world. The "Amazon pays no taxes" meme is a false one.
by sneak 6y ago
Amazon pays mountains of payroll taxes, as they are one of the largest employers in the world.
The "Amazon pays no taxes" meme is a false one.
- spaceribs 6y agoI think the meme is "Amazon pays no federal taxes on it's profits", and that is a correct statement.
- sneak 6y agoIf that were the meme, I wouldn't be trying to dispel it.
- dahfizz 6y agoEven that is not really true. They paid no federal income tax in 2017 and 2018, but have before and since. I'm no fan of Amazon, but you have to admit there is a pretty large distance between "Amazon pays no tax" and "Amazon pays billions in tax, but they didn't pay this one specific kind of tax a couple years ago". https://www.cnbc.com/2020/02/04/amazon-had-to-pay-federal-income-taxes-for-the-first-time-since-2016.html https://www.cnbc.com/2020/02/04/amazon-had-to-pay-federal-in...
- spaceribs 6y agoI think income tax is the most impactful and expensive tax we have in the US, it's the one everyone thinks of when someone says "doing your taxes". The fact that Amazon just this year after not paying for 2 years had to pay a measly 1.6% in taxes does not really negate the argument. Edit: 4 years -> 2 years
- dahfizz 6y agoIt really feels like you're twisting reality. Amazon went 2 years without paying _income_ tax, not 4. Amazon paid $3.5 billion in taxes in 2019 (some of which was differed, but still owed). That is over 25% of their income that year. Their federal income tax rate came out to 1.6%, but its borderline lying to say "they paid a measly 1.6% in taxes". Amazon is an awful company. There is no reason to bend the truth to try and show how awful they are. Being disingenuous only makes your argument weaker.
- spaceribs 6y agoI misread the article, and I'll correct the 4 to 2 years now. Income is income though, not sales or payroll which are the expected and manageable operating costs of overhead and human resources. If I win the lottery, almost 50% of my winnings go back to the state, and I haven't even bought anything with those winnings. What's different about Amazon having a banner year?
- robertlagrant 6y agoBecause that's how lotteries work in the US. Companies don't have to be behemoths to pay no tax on income. They just have to post no profits by spending all the money they make on opex and capex.
- spaceribs 6y agoI understand the system, I just want to be clear how broken this is. Both are windfalls, one gets taxed immediately, the other gets taxed if they don't use up all their profits reinvesting in themselves by the end of the year.
- tick_tock_tick 6y agoI don't see how you can think this is broken. Think about the implications if it wasn't like this. Bankruptcy would be rampant and R&D investment would be impossible for everyone but the largest companies.
- spaceribs 6y agoI disagree, as these companies already calculate how much they need to spend to prevent having to pay taxes.
- robertlagrant 6y agoThat doesn't matter. They're still spending it, rather than keeping it as profit.
- cycomanic 6y agoThis is quite pendandic. When you calculate your tax rate do you also include GST(VAT)? Because this is essentially the same thing.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- dahfizz 6y agoI guess it depends on the context. When I am filing my income tax, I am focused on that. But when budgeting or discussing tax liability in general, I certainly don't forget about the tens of thousands of dollars I pay in local, sales, SS, etc taxes. I would certainly not make the claim "I paid no taxes this year" if I managed to skirt only federal income tax.
- Manuel_D 6y agoIsn't that also incorrect? It would presumably pay the normal corporate tax on it's profits. It's just that Amazon reinvests it's revenue and thus has no (or little) profit.
- Loughla 6y agoIsn't it the workers who (whom? I never know) pay the payroll tax? That's their money, in exchange for their time spent on work, that's not Amazon's money. This doesn't make sense to me.
- dahfizz 6y agoIn the US, "payroll" taxes are split between employer and employee. The biggest items that fall into payroll are Social Security and Medicare. https://www.taxpolicycenter.org/briefing-book/what-are-major-federal-payroll-taxes-and-how-much-money-do-they-raise https://www.taxpolicycenter.org/briefing-book/what-are-major...
- edoceo 6y agoin USA it works like: pay is $100. then take home is $80 because $20 is taken out for various payroll taxes. then also the company pays $20 for their portion. employees only see the -20 from them, not the +20 from Company on wage stubs. also, if the company has profits there is some tax on that (well, my little C-corp did) (numbers are made up to show process)
- josefx 6y ago> also, if the company has profits there is some tax on that (well, my little C-corp did) No large US company has any profits, maybe one of their child companies in Ireland or the Caribic does. They have to beg for billions in government handouts every time they want expand their operations, that is how bad they have it financially.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]