3 ms·
People aren't hyper-polarized about Clubhouse, they're polarized by the hype surrounding the product/service, partly cultivated by the people behind and on Club
by Apocryphon 6y ago
People aren't hyper-polarized about Clubhouse, they're polarized by the hype surrounding the product/service, partly cultivated by the people behind and on Clubhouse. Honestly, this sort of messianic blather only serves to make it sound even more pretentious and elitist. It's a solid audio platform, sure. What does it do that private chat groups- Slack, Discord, even Houseparty, doesn't do? Imagine if Yahoo Groups had offered voice chat. Or Facebook Groups- actually, Menlo Park is already building such a thing already.
You could have run all of the symposiums and Chautauquas you wanted through these preexisting platforms. But Clubhouse, like NFTs, openly flaunts its exclusivity. It advertises private conversations to the world to boost demand. Creating artificial scarcity to overvalue itself.
And your anecdote? I don't doubt it happened, even if it sounds dubious. How did a struggling musician even get onto this platform? And if he did, then what does it say about the exclusivity it promises? Plenty of services were invite only at the onset, from Gmail to Spotify. Will Clubhouse remain that way indefinitely? Or will eternal September come for you, too? At best, perhaps it will become another MasterClass, with hyped experts in their field hawking their wisdom in different rooms for pay (this, too, must monetize). This magic you describe, it is as fleeting as in any platform. The only way to preserve it is to embrace privacy and anonymity. Private Slack servers, private Discord servers. Telegram and Signal conversations. A platform that brags about exclusivity yet does not embrace anonymity is just begging for the masses to drop by.