5 ms·
The "smarter" scaling solutions still aren't here after years of waiting, fees are hitting all-time highs, and other chains can do >4,000 TPS on layer 1. So no,
by wmf 6y ago
The "smarter" scaling solutions still aren't here after years of waiting, fees are hitting all-time highs, and other chains can do >4,000 TPS on layer 1. So no, small blocks weren't and aren't a good idea.
- rawtxapp 6y agoThey are here, the publicly known nodes alone on lightning have 1.2+k BTC locked in [1], that's ignoring all the private channels which form the majority of the channels (private channels are the end-user channels which don't route transactions themselves and are not broadcast publicly). We have easy to use wallets [2], easy ways to run lightning nodes [3]. And if you look at the average transaction value, you can see that the blockchain itself is acting more of a settlement layer rather than "coffee transactions" as it should [4]. 1: https://1ml.com/ https://1ml.com/ 2: https://phoenix.acinq.co/ https://phoenix.acinq.co/ 3: https://getumbrel.com/ https://getumbrel.com/ 4: https://bitinfocharts.com/comparison/transactionvalue-btc-xrp.html https://bitinfocharts.com/comparison/transactionvalue-btc-xr...
- wmf 6y agothe blockchain itself is acting more of a settlement layer That is a sign of failure.
- sennight 6y agoWhat is a sign of success, multicasting every transaction in the world and storing it on a public ledger? I don't remember that being in the white paper.
- rawtxapp 6y agoBecoming the most trusted decentralized worldwide settlement layer is considered a failure now? Many of the cryptos that claim to scale to thousands of tps on layer 1 are all sacrificing decentralization to achieve it, at which point, I might as well use Paypal/Visa. There's no point in being able to scale to those levels in theory if in practice no one uses them.
- riffraff 6y ago> Becoming the most trusted decentralized worldwide settlement layer is considered a failure now? it is, if the original goal was to be something else. If you start a marathon and stop to eat the greatest hot dog ever made, it wouldn't be considered a successful run, although you can say "but it was the best!" and be happy about it.
- hungryforcodes 6y agoHuh, so every startup thats ever pivoted -- including for example Instagram, AirBnB, and Twitter -- are failures huh? Interesting.
- xorcist 6y agoNot sure if it can be called a pivot when it was in the original release of the software. Payment channels aren't in the white paper but they were in the first public release and had dedicated opcodes. That first implementation wasn't very practical nor was it secure. The fact that modern payment channels are implemented with other opcodes may be a pivot in implementation but not in concept.
- dane-pgp 6y agoStartups have a duty to their shareholders to make money, whereas Bitcoin has at least a nominal duty to its inventor[0] and its whitepaper. There's nothing wrong, though, with someone taking the open source code and creating LightningCoin from it, though. That would be the equivalent of a pivot. [0] http://satoshinakamoto.me/2008/11/02/re-bitcoin-p2p-e-cash-paper/ http://satoshinakamoto.me/2008/11/02/re-bitcoin-p2p-e-cash-p...
- nullc 6y agoPayment channels were invented by Satoshi and actually baked into the transaction format from day one-- it's why transactions have locktimes and sequence numbers.
- 6y ago
- rocqua 6y agoThe nice thing about using blockchain for settlement is that (using lightning) you don't actually need to wait for the settlement to clear before you are certain you own funds.
- vmception 6y agoCan you elaborate on your perspective? I must admit that I don't use layer2 solutions and many people that think they are, are not (ie. users of Polygon's Proof of Stake network instead of their Plasma network), but I appreciate the progress on those layer2 solutions and actively support the bridges to them
- wmf 6y agoLayer 2 is more complex (pretty much by definition) but has no countervailing benefits compared to a scalable layer 1 chain.
- alwillis 6y agofees are hitting all-time highs I just checked https://mempool.space https://mempool.space A low-priority transaction cost $2.36; medium is $4.39 and high is $7.48. To put this into context: you can send $10,000 worth of BTC anywhere in the world in an hour for $2.36 right now. A bank wire transfer for $10,000 is going to be at least $35; often it's more, depending on which country you're sending to and if you have to use an intermediate bank to get to the bank you're ultimately are attempting to reach. Bank holidays, weekends, etc. don't apply to bitcoin.
- garmaine 6y agoMy bank does those wires for free…
- csomar 6y agoInternational SWIFT wires? What's your bank?
- lhl 6y agoMy Schwab account does international wires settled in USD or in a number of foreign currencies for free. (The official fee is $15 but it’s always been refunded for me.)
- argvargc 6y ago"Free". In the case of any currency conversion - you'll likely be silently stung a single digit percentage during conversion. Check rates quoted on the final statement versus those prevailing at that time. For a few limited cases of going USD -> USD (in foreign jurisdiction), and the USD is not converted to anything else ever, there may be a net win. In all other cases (the majority), you, or the receiver will at some point be paying far more than the wire fee for any transfer over a grand or so.
- csomar 6y ago
- delaaxe 6y ago50,000 TPS for Solana
- keymone 6y ago> other chains can do >4,000 TPS on layer 1 read: other chains are centralized databases that have no business being blockchains in the first place and can be replaced by single mysql instance. the trick is not to have high TPS, bitcoin could have unlimited TPS too, it's just a single line of code change. the trick is to have a decentralized system that functions at saturation on commodity hardware. the conservative minds prevailed during scaling debate in 2015-2017, creating selection pressure for scaling solutions that optimize limited resource - chain space, rather than populist simplistic "solutions" pushed by cheap propaganda slogans like "we can do this much TPS!".
- anonymouse008 6y ago> read: other chains are centralized databases that have no business being blockchains in the first place and can be replaced by single mysql instance. This, too, has been a thought of mine, but I'm not exactly sure how I would block diagram the 'locking' mechanism for the MySQL instance. I've come to believe the locking mechanism is the nonce produced to sufficient solution parameters that appears to use the difficulty of finding said solution as its defensibility. So how do you get the 'strength' of the miners throwing ExaHashes at a solution with a single instance? We could easily snapshot the DB and sign them, however, the point of failure is no longer in a 50% attack, but in losing said key... which intuitively feels far less secure? Curious to hear your thoughts
- keymone 6y agolocking is needed to order transactions, mysql already has acid transactions. i use mysql metaphorically to describe a single centralized database protected by single entity that controls all the writes. we already have such payment systems: visa, mastercard, paypal, venmo, etc. blockchain and miners only make sense if you need and actually maintain decentralization. if you don't and/or can't - miners (and validators in PoS systems) are useless overhead.
- anonymouse008 6y agoThank you, I had never heard of ACID -- yeah, centralized vs. decentralized becomes fairly philosophical (eco vs. democratized arguments, etc). To build on the discussion, I'm more amazed at blockchain's capabilities as a cooperation engine outside of the normal channels. To that end, I'm really surprised we haven't seen significant attrition in the current legal system to smart contract systems. I guess the lack of adoption more highlights just how 'customized' a 'standard' contract or dispute is in the real world.