4 ms·
The post doesn't say "all outsourcing is bad", and your 3 examples are all companies that (as far as I can tell) are very deliberate about what they outsource a
by detaro 6y ago
The post doesn't say "all outsourcing is bad", and your 3 examples are all companies that (as far as I can tell) are very deliberate about what they outsource and deliberate about keeping control of the things they want to keep doing:
NVIDIA is not going to go out to someone else and say "we want a GPU chip", but rather they are designing them end-to-end to make full use of what their production partners can do.
iPhones are built in China, but Apple keeps tight control over how they are built. They control and manage the supply chain, they buy companies making tools used to make iPhones to keep control over this. They operate the cloud service stack around them. They made massive investments into doing more themselves: building a world-class CPU design group to get independence from what other SoC makers offer them. They are now leveraging that to outsource less of the Macbook design: move away from outsourcing CPU design and production to Intel, to design inhouse.
They understand very well what the post warns about: If they stop being involved with these parts of the process, they will a)likely fall back and b) have a terrible time trying to recover the ability if they need to, so they only outsource selected parts of their work. The breaking points are further down the curve, and they stay the hell away from them.
One could argue that Apple's attempts at making Macs in the US again are an example of how difficult it is to reclaim such ability, even if the company still has the know-how to oversee it. Especially since nearly everybody else in California also has stopped doing this kind of thing - Apple would need to train people a lot. Which Apple at least can afford, if they want to.
- jasode 6y ago>The post doesn't say "all outsourcing is bad", I didn't interpret his essay that way. His acknowledgements of some outsourcing being valid doesn't address my criticism. >and your 3 examples are all companies that (as far as I can tell) are very deliberate about what they outsource and deliberate about keeping control of the things they want to keep doing: NVIDIA is not going to go out to someone else and say "we want a GPU chip", but rather they are designing them end-to-end to make full use of what their production partners can do. And this is a great example that ties back to the author's point because he criticized Boeing. Boeing designs the planes and tells the outsourced partners what to make. Boeing then does final assembly in Boeing-owned factories in Washington and North Carolina. So to use your wording, Boeing does not go to somebody else and say "we want a 787 plane". Boeing does more building than NVIDIA. I think a fair reading of his essay is that he thinks that a company that is more vertically integrated via less (but not zero) outsourcing leads to more innovation. He was lamenting that outsourcing productivity software like MS Office 365 wasn't a good trend so presumably, companies that insourced that inhouse would be "more innovative".
- detaro 6y agoFrom the article re Boing: > They were even telling the manufacturers look, we only put up requirements, we don’t actually tell you what to do From other sources: > Starting with the 787 Dreamliner, launched in 2004, it sought to increase profits by instead providing high-level specifications and then asking suppliers to design more parts themselves. [...] > Rabin, the former software engineer, recalled one manager saying at an all-hands meeting that Boeing didn’t need senior engineers because its products were mature. “I was shocked that in a room full of a couple hundred mostly senior engineers we were being told that we weren’t needed,” https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2019-06-28/boeing-s-737-max-software-outsourced-to-9-an-hour-engineers https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2019-06-28/boeing-s-... That's the point where you loose your in-house grip on things, and run into trouble if your contractors are not up to it. Keep that up, and you loose the ability to fix it. The chip-designing companies are betting that there always will be an external fab that's world-class, and likely better than what they can do themselves. AMD literally couldn't afford to keep up. (and when world-class was inside Intel, they somewhat suffered for it, but didn't really have an alternative)
- jasode 6y ago>That's the point where you loose your in-house grip on things, and run into trouble if your contractors are not up to it. What definitive conclusion are we supposed to get from that Bloomberg article you cited? That cheap outsourced $9/hr programmers from India caused the MCAS flaws which led to plane crashes? Therefore, if Boeing had used in-house American programmers, it wouldn't have been a problem? But if the specifications for the software were designed by Boeing management, it wouldn't have mattered where the programmers were located that actually coded it. From the investigative reports I read, it wasn't the programmers that decided 1 Angle-of-Attack sensor instead of checking 2 redundant ones -- it was the aerospace engineers and managers above the programmers. The Bloomberg article uses a narrative technique to bias the reader a certain way (reader nods in agreement "outsourcing caused the problem") -- rather than present unbiased Root Cause Analysis. As counterpoint, Tesla has programmers inhouse in California to code the self-driving software and yet it had serious flaws which contributed to fatalities. So is the correct conclusion to say that inhouse programming is "bad"? Of course not. Your cite of that type of Bloomberg article gives me an idea of what you found compelling about this thread's blog post. In my case, I was more focused on the "more outsourcing means less innovation" aspect which wasn't convincing.
- hellbannedguy 6y agoI still think Apple should bring some manufacturing back to the USA---if for nothing else---Goodwill. I do give them credit on customer service. As far as I know it's still American accents. I am aching to drop Apple. I will buy their used products, but try to avoid their pricy new stuff. I don't need the latest, lightest computer either? My budget is not what it was ten years ago either? I am waiting for a viable alternative, and it's pretty bleak. I honestly fear what's going to happen to this once great country. I fear workers are becoming as disenfranchised as myself.