11 ms·
It's no surprise that Clubhouse values none of the things presented in the title because it's completely orthogonal to what makes Clubhouse 'valuable'. It's lik
by Barrin92 6y ago
It's no surprise that Clubhouse values none of the things presented in the title because it's completely orthogonal to what makes Clubhouse 'valuable'. It's like saying "Elsevier is a billion dollar business despite being unfriendly to readers, researchers, and limiting access to human knowledge". No that's the reason, why in the logic of our economic system they have any price attached to them.
Clubhouse's entire value proposition is artificial scarcity. It's the NFT of social networks. Take something that is abundant and cheap in the world of software (communication, space, room size) etc, and artificially bog it down to create a zero-sum game of status.
It's basically 'un-innovation' for a lack of a better term. Technically there's nothing in Clubhouse that if it doesn't already exist anywhere else cannot be copied in five minutes. All the things clubhouse places limits on already are abundant, which is why their market value is, ironically enough, 0.
- areoform 6y agoExcept that's not true, having experienced it, I would say that ClubHouse produces intimacy as a service. I've had magical conversations on the application that I've never had anywhere else. Saying that it's just another product and that it can be copied in 5 minutes is missing the point. The choices that they've made, their decision to eschew everything except for voice, help create a medium that is intimate, thoughtful, and kind. And otherwise busy people are addicted to it. Someone I know said that talking on ClubHouse felt like being back at Stanford. Just the electrifying conversations. The sense of possibility. There's something special here. Recently, I decided that I'd like to interview a cosmonaut who has never been interviewed by the west before. To tell his story before a broader audience. And I started a ClubHouse room to do it, and people from around the world came together to help me. Including people who knew him! I'm just a stranger, but they heard me explain why I wanted to preserve this man's legacy and that was enough. People were happy to chip in and help. That's magical. And I haven't experienced anything like that before. There's this profound sense of intimacy that this platform produces that's missing elsewhere. I keep repeating myself, but there is something here. It's a mistake to discount it.
- exogeny 6y agoIt's hard for me to think of anything less niche than "like being at Stanford" given the extreme, tech-focused, affluent, bourgeois-as-fuck description that implies. The average person doesn't want to spend hours listening to thought leaders who are in love with their own voice pontificating randomly on topics that don't affect or address their lives in any way. To believe that they will to such an extent that A16Z is willing to give them a $4B given zero revenue, declining traction, and no clear business shows that all you need to do to gain ever-increasing valuations in the tech world is to serve up the exact kind of frou-frou, nebulous bullshit that you wrote and that VCs eat up.
- areoform 6y ago> given the extreme, tech-focused, affluent, bourgeois-as-fuck description that implies While I understand where you're coming from, this is the kind of conversation that has turned me off from most of the internet. On the months I've been on ClubHouse, I've never had an exchange like this. But elsewhere on the web? It's fairly common. Text is a hard medium to discuss complicated ideas in. It's too easy to be snarky. You get kudos for it. But that's harder to do in voice. Because you'd have to hear my reaction, and the reactions of others. You'd have to hear how off-putting it is. I prefer ClubHouse now, because the rest of the web is so snarky. And do you blame me? Given how you've reacted to me?
- Judgmentality 6y agoYou're telling me right now Clubhouse has no trolls, and you believe the reason for this is because it's hard to troll with voice? I'm pretty sure it's because trolls have simply never discovered it. Honestly, I would vastly prefer to be snarky to people in real-time with my voice and hear their immediate, unedited reactions. For the first time I actually want to try Clubhouse.
- areoform 6y ago> Honestly, I would vastly prefer to be snarky to people in real-time with my voice and hear their immediate, unedited reactions. That's very sad. You'll get booted the second you try and the conversation will continue on. You'll then get banned from the room/community. And if you do it often enough, from the platform. The person who invited you will also get banned if enough of their invitees do such things. That's one of the benefits of making it invite only. There's an inherent social graph to who is inviting whom; it's like a giant house party. You don't want to be the person who brought the asshole who harshed the vibe. Even if you don't care, the house rules are simple - bring bad guests often enough, and you won't get invited to the party. It's that simple. So yeah, use your shot to chill with interesting scientists, engineers, artists, and assorted people from across the world to troll them. It's yours to waste.
- gkoberger 6y agoIf you only talk about the tech behind it, then you're correct. However there is a scarcity of time and attention, which is what Clubhouse aims to capture. People want to be where things are happening. That's why land is abundant, yet I pay $2600 for a one-bedroom apartment in a city. I've been using Clubhouse for a year, and seen various iterations. Earlier, there was so much human connection. I talked to amazing people almost 1:1, and it was like being part of a small club. As it grew, it became more like a 24/7 conference where you could drop in to hear any topic you want. Less my thing, but still fascinating.
- areoform 6y agoHave you heard of Prelon and Small Steps, Giant Leaps? https://prelon.org/ https://prelon.org/
- tolbish 6y agoSo their aim is to solve the societal problem of "How can we monetize the concept of FOMO". I see why it is both popular yet despised.
- gkoberger 6y agoI don't think that's what it is. It's a bit hard to get an invite (although allegedly there's 10 million users now, so not that hard), but once you're inside, everything is open and free and accessible to anyone. You could argue that things being realtime cause FOMO, but that's true about conversations. Everything is so "on-demand" now; there's something nice about the ephemeral, realtime nature of it. It encourages spontaneity.
- bonoboTP 6y agoYou don't mean "orthogonal" (that would mean something like "independent", "non-interfering"). You mean it's "in direct opposition to" or something like that.
- noodles_nomore 6y agoantithetical
- th0ma5 6y agoNFTs only present an illusion of scarcity.
- SilverRed 6y agoThey are like picking up a grain of sand and trying to claim its rare. Yes, there is only one of that grain of sand you are holding but that doesn't mean a whole lot.
- cortesoft 6y agoIt means the same as any other valuable thing in our society caused by artificial scarcity - limited printings, trading cards, dollar bills, stamps, Bitcoin, software, music, books, etc.
- SilverRed 6y agoWith most of these things, its all about using the item as a status symbol. Having a rare painting on your wall shows status. NFTs don't and likely never will have the same impact.
- cortesoft 6y agoThe people who are buying them are absolutely buying them as a status symbol, so that appears to be working.
- th0ma5 6y agoA great many people are starting to look down on NFT buyers and sellers. I'm not sure what status they provide since either someone has to maintain the chain somehow forever which is impossible, but also there isn't anything stopping someone from creating alternative timelines of sales.
- cortesoft 6y ago
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- baryphonic 6y agoI spoke on the app one night with a Chinese dissident about his experiences in the Tiananmen Square protests in 1989. Nowhere else is it possible to make that conversation happen right now except for Clubhouse. Is the app some deeply innovative technology? No. But it is a thoroughly well-done combination of existing technology, and it has evolved social networking to be much more pleasant, thought-provoking and intimate than what has come before. Status-seeking is the reserve currency of social networking applications (including this one we're using right now), but at least Clubhouse aligns the incentive to seek status with generating a quality product for the community. (Maybe it's just too soon to say for sure; I imagine there existed a time when people on Instagram really did get attention for interesting photos.)
- BiteCode_dev 6y agoI've played hundred of hours of gaming online, and ni all plateform with a voice chat, you could do that. Even before voice, we could do that on text chat (Wow and SC were quite political if you wanted to) And of course IRC and forums. But don't worry, as soon as the CCP realize Clubhouse is a place for talking about this, it will take actions.
- baryphonic 6y agoI'm not sure it would be so easy to find a fifty-year-old who had been in the Tiananmen Square protests and who was playing WOW or Starcraft, but fair enough. My post explicitly said that Clubhouse's combination of existing technology is what makes it unique - voice chat, topic/person discovery, search. All of those things are possible through other mash-ups of existing technology. Hell, you could conceivably clone Clubhouse with a Minecraft server and Discord. But CH has the overall experience that reduces friction. And now it also has network effects, since enough interesting people are on it that the experience is just that much better. I, likewise, share the concern that the CCP will use its heavy hand to destroy CH. I hope the founders are smart enough to divest from CCP-controlled tech ASAP.