3 ms·
brings an odd question, will we have to have artifical exposure to diseases just to ensure our immune system is capable ?
by agumonkey 6y ago
brings an odd question, will we have to have artifical exposure to diseases just to ensure our immune system is capable ?
- coderaptor 6y agoI'd also like to know where I can read further on discussions on this. My understanding is that it's the same for chickenpox - that lack of frequent natural exposure now requires artificial exposure with boosters to prevent shingles. Feels like vendor lock-in to me - often valuable but with some downsides that need to be evaluated on a case by case basis.
- manwe150 6y agoFrom my layman's reading (start from https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Shingles#Epidemiology https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Shingles#Epidemiology), I think the chickenpox vaccine is potentially somewhat the inverse of vendor lock-in: that giving the vaccine to children decreases the possibility of shingles complications later for them, while studies potentially show an increase in the prevalence of complications among unvaccinated older folks, thus making it relatively worse to not vaccinate for it, as you get older, and as others opt into it. Since there's also multiple shingles vaccines now, this sounds to me more like a typical network effect from vaccination? To make up an unrelated tech example of that, my impression was this would be like picking a Blackberry phone, while all your friends have Windows phones. You weren't forced to pick a Blackberry by vendor lock-in, but you may miss out on being in some social circles. Changing that group dynamic would require everyone to switch, not just on a case-by-case basis. But in this example though, the Window's phones (aka vaccination) have strictly more features than the Blackberry (aka kills you less often), so if you can afford to (aka you have an average immune system), it would be more logical to get a new phone yourself and join the network, than to ask all of your friends to get new phones.
- staticassertion 6y agoYou mean a vaccine?
- agumonkey 6y agoI meant that in a future where you never have to fight viruses your immune system will be weakened.
- da_big_ghey 6y agothis are theory on case of allergy rising, no? child in early times exposed to more, played in dirt, strong immune system. child today play with i pad, use school antibacteria soap, weak immune system, allergy.
- agumonkey 6y agoYes, same idea. We need some amount of stress to train our system. (in 2020s trend it would be linked to hormesis)
- roywiggins 6y agoOne theory about the 1918 flu us that it hit young people harder because older people had encountered a similar flu already, before the younger generation were born. But in general, being exposed to (say) seasonal flu every year might not help you at all when a new strain of pandemic flu shows up. The 1918 flu tore through young healthy people.