4 ms·
Being far from Constitution-loving capitalists as it’s possible to get does not make one leftist. Your perception of what makes one leftist is badly distorted.
by syops 5y ago
Being far from Constitution-loving capitalists as it’s possible to get does not make one leftist. Your perception of what makes one leftist is badly distorted. At the extremes of ideology one finds people for whom the cause is more important than the truth. This typically occurs when adherents conflate being true to the cause with being correct.
Consider this possibility. The writer loathes Nazism to such a degree that she hates to agree with Nazis (the real ones from Germany in the 1930s) on anything. This speaks to other things but does not suggest that both she and Nazis are leftist. It is absurd to think that a political movement will have no good ideas. As such one can find agreement or praiseworthy aspects of odious political movements. That does not suggest complete or even significant overall agreement with said political movement.
I suggest that you are letting your adherence to your political ideology cloud your intellectual thinking.
- thu2111 5y agoYou haven't really refuted any of the points I made here about the essay itself. Can you quote any section where she writes about how much she loathes Nazi-ism? I quoted sections where she says outright that she agrees with their worldview and that made her uncomfortable. The writer probably thinks or thought she loathed Nazi-ism, right up until she read and agreed with their propaganda, which is - as her essay makes clear - entirely mainstream (for that time) leftism. So, what does she really believe?