5 ms·
I know that many of us here don't like what labor unions have become in the 21st century. But they do need some labor representation that can ensure the trucks
by fortran77 6y ago
I know that many of us here don't like what labor unions have become in the 21st century. But they do need some labor representation that can ensure the trucks used by drivers have working lights, mirrors, and safe tires, and that the company negotiates use of restrooms around the city. Maybe just a "safety only" union that only deals with safety issues?
- ganafagol 6y agoA forum mostly frequented by us overpaid workers doing little-more-than-if-any work that society actually needs is not the right place to discuss unions. Of course people in our industry, no matter devs or ops or founders or "founders", despise unions as they get in their way with demands of some basic workers rights. But there are industries where unions are desperately needed to keep workers sane, safe and overall dignified. With little first hand experience it's just too easy to dismiss that.
- elite_hackers3 6y agoSpeak for yourself. I write java scripts for Facebook. I’m EXTREMELY valuable to society and deserve every penny I get.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- tomnipotent 6y agoUnion shops like UPS have the exact same issues as Amazon or FedEx (including urine bottles).
- missedthecue 6y agoUPS is union and their employees urinate in bottles. I don't think unions are the magic wand that a lot of people assume they are
- mindslight 6y agoWhile "urinating in bottles" sounds like some sort of standard by which to indict, if you tried it you would find it's quite convenient. I'd guess that it's far down on the list of drivers' actual concerns. What are you proposing should replace this? Trips back to the depot would be terribly inefficient. Portapotties in trucks would be just fancier bottles. And time to visit public restrooms would be better spent taking an actual break and then still using the bottle.
- yibg 6y agoI assume this is more true for men than women.
- BlueTemplar 6y agoYeah, that's what I was wondering : is this why I haven't seen a single delivery gal in my life ? ( Unlike trucker women.)
- bell-cot 6y agoA little company I worked for ~20 years ago (Michigan, U.S.A.) had a female UPS driver. Her route was ~99% residential - so extremely few bathrooms. (Vs. it was easy, then, for UPS drivers delivering to office buildings, restaurants, etc.) We made it clear that she was free to use our bathroom at any time. She made it clear that our package delivery time & pick-up time could be far, far better than "that's where you are on my route" when we needed them to be. (And I'm sure more things got shipped UPS than should have...I guess you'd call that "UPS's cut" of the deal.)
- mindslight 6y agoThere are portable solutions for women, but since they're built for the purpose they don't sensationalize as well as "peeing in bottles".
- adamredwoods 6y agoSource: https://www.browncafe.com/community/threads/urine-bottles-in-package-cars.356807/ https://www.browncafe.com/community/threads/urine-bottles-in... Apparently, drivers are given plenty of break times and are allowed bathroom breaks, but this behavior continues. I wonder what the economic impact of putting a portable toilet closet in the truck is? Each truck would have 30% less capacity? Would employees get less breaks then?
- mertd 6y agoAll of those should be a law of some form.
- agumonkey 6y agoMy foray into 'blue collar' society (in large urban areas at least) taught me this clear and wide: most of it is run by vultures. The simplest equipment is optional, safety equipment is optional, hygiene is optional. Inhumane production rates are mandatory. Companies will scam you as much as the first stranger on an undeclared gig. It's adversarial relationships from top to bottom. People are clueless, and don't want to make things better. Things rot as long as people involved are accepting, or forced to accept, the situation. Actually one gig I did was newspaper delivery and it's clear that the web took a lot of the money from them and they're barely surviving at the cost of employees. Another factor, systems struggle accelerate when out of the mean, the lower the company is the lower the work life is, the worse the employees they can get is .. less means, less profits, more work.
- rsj_hn 6y agoLabor unions work when a firm is earning economic rents, and there is a political struggle over who gets those rents. For example the auto-industry prior to the invasion by Japanese imports. The issue is that when there are no economic rents, then labor unions no longer work and indeed become an added cost. A lot of people don't seem to understand that, neither do they understand that economic rents are something that dissipates over time as new entrants come in with cheaper products. Especially in the world of free trade where you are competing with China and other low cost countries (in China labor unions are controlled by the state and starting your own is illegal). But the trouble with journalism is not that fat cat firms are swimming in loads of cash and only if workers could orgnanize and demand a bigger slice of the pot they could get that. So the job security that a union job can provide an individual in one industry is not generalizable to a dying industry where companies are going bankrupt and need to cut costs as their revenues shrink. But, you object, what about places like Germany where basically every firm is unionized? Well, unions in Germany are very different. Germany didn't even have a minimum wage until recently. None. And pay in Germany is lower. So you can't look at, say, what an UAW worker or Teamster in the US makes and then think that's what a typical worker in Germany is making because they are all unionized. So again we have this generalizability problem, where the _real_ sources of high income for workers are not unions but increasing return to scale, high productivity jobs. That is why tech workers make more than journalists. And that is why nations like Germany or China that want a society of high wage jobs fight to keep their manufacturing sector and high value add sectors, while nations like the US that are focused on short-term GDP growth have no issue selling off their high productivity jobs and shipping them overseas, at which point no amount of unionizing is going to help bring those high wage jobs back. Similarly when your industry is going bankrupt and shrinking, no amount of unionizing is going to give you the job security and good wages the prevoius generation of workers had in the same industry. This is not a problem of labor policy but industrial policy, and no amount of labor policy intervention is going to solve the industrial policy problem.
- lr4444lr 6y agoNot that I dislike your idea or unions at large, but mission creep will be inevitable: limiting hours and mandating benefits to ensure physical and mental health of the drivers will be linked to safety, and the whole host of benefits for worker wellness in the name of safety will follow. What you are asking for is what OSHA is for.