3 ms·
I hate subscriptions as much as the next guy, but I also see the flip side of this coin: the legacy auto companies don't have OTA updates, and this affects thei
by gnicholas 6y ago
I hate subscriptions as much as the next guy, but I also see the flip side of this coin: the legacy auto companies don't have OTA updates, and this affects their incentives in negative ways.
I have considered getting a Subaru Outback, a Toyota RAV4, and a Honda CR-V. All of them have 'lane-centering' features, but none of them are good at present. And none of the companies say that they will allow OTA (or any other periodic) updates, even though presumably it would be possible to improve performance without upgrading the hardware.
Why do they do this? Because their business model is to keep selling/leasing new cars. They don't want you to have the newest tech on your older car.
If they had subscriptions for features like these, it would give them a different incentive, which could be good in some cases. It might still be bad on balance (like if they charged huge amounts for these features), but there could be some significant upsides.
- Naac 6y agoI think you're putting way too much faith in these companies. Just going off of your example, they're most likely just going to provide support for 2 years ( if that ), and then say "sorry, the newest version of lane keep assist isn't available for your model". A la Apple.
- AlexandrB 6y agoWe'd be lucky if auto manufacturers supported cars with updates as long as Apple supports hardware (5 years+ in some cases). It'll be more like Android hardware support - you get the version your car shipped with and maybe the next one.
- gnicholas 6y agoI’d certainly not trust them right out of the gate. But after several years of seeing their practices, I could have a decent expectation of what would be supported and for how long.
- Toutouxc 6y agoMacs from 2012 got the latest security update four days ago. Macs from 2013 are supported by the newest macOS. iPhones and iPads from 2013 got the latest security update a month ago. iPhones and iPads from 2015 and 2014 respectively are supported by the latest iOS and iPadOS. Classic Apple, right?
- brokenmachine 6y agoDid you see the article today saying they run the Apple Store at a 78% profit margin? Their raison d'etre is keeping you trapped in that cage.
- insulanus 6y agoI admire your optimism. Here are some reasons I don't want to see car makers selling software: 1. There is a huge power imbalance between a car company and a car "owner" (licensee?) 2. The incentives on the car company side are not aligned with the desires of the car owner. 3. The will be incented to lock you in, a la the google/apple store. 4. You now have sunk costs in a hardware platform. What if you want to change from Honda to Toyota? 5. Almost no one is good at making software, and that includes car companies. One year marketing driven turnarounds won't help with safety.
- gnicholas 6y agoI'm not an optimistic person! I just see there being different ways to innovate here. Right now, Tesla is pretty much the only one offering OTA updates, and they don't charge extra for it. It's just built into the price of the vehicle (as far as I understand). I think a healthy market would have more OTA offerings, which could be purchased outright (if you planned to have the car for many years) or paid year-to-year. Basically, there has been very little innovation/competition in this space, and Tesla is shaking things up. I see that as a good thing, since innovation and competition will make things better for customers on balance.
- jjav 6y ago> the legacy auto companies don't have OTA updates That's a huge feature. OTA updates means: 1. An attack vector that will (when, not if) be exploited by bad guys. 2. An attack vector that will (when, not if) be exploited by the manufacturer itself to make your car worse (Tesla already doing this sometimes). A secure and reliable car must not be modifiable remotely.