2 ms·
It's not unreasonable to demand a higher standard of the police. The real flaw is in assuming that all "police killings" are murders. You would expect some pro
by AnthonyMouse 6y ago
It's not unreasonable to demand a higher standard of the police.
The real flaw is in assuming that all "police killings" are murders. You would expect some proportion, and a higher number than the general population because of the nature of the job, to be legitimate self-defense or defense of others. So then you need to distinguish those cases from wrongful killings.
Which is hard, because the usual way to do that would be to look at how many of them are convicted of murder. But if the case you're trying to make is that not enough of the actual murders are successfully prosecuted, that's not satisfactory. And then what? Data not available, so everybody assumes what they want based on their own politics.
- wizzwizz4 6y agoOr you could go through them all, and judge how murdery each case was. (I couldn't deal with doing that, but some could.)
- ALittleLight 6y agoI think it is unreasonable to demand a higher standard of the police. "Don't murder" is what we ask of everyone in society. If we had a reliable way to preemptively detect murderers we'd solve a lot of problems. Given that we don't, how could we expect to prevent murderers from being police officers? On top of that police are typically younger men - the demographic that commits almost all murders. Police always have guns. They are the kind of people willing and able to deal with hostile and potentially violent people. They have natural inclination to violence, to be able to deal with and dispense it. Personally, I'd expect the police to be more likely than average to become murderers, not less.