3 ms·
I don't believe luck is a significant factor. The number of entrepreneurs who have second and third companies with successful exits effectively demonstrates tha
by onion2k 6y ago
I don't believe luck is a significant factor. The number of entrepreneurs who have second and third companies with successful exits effectively demonstrates that someone can consistently do the right things to win, react to challenges in the right ways, and repeat their success. If luck was a significant factor that would not happen.
- noofen 6y agoIt could be both. Some people are better at others at identifying market currents. From the outside, we call it "luck," because how else would you explain it? I'd imagine a lot of it is based on gut-feeling after months of research / interaction with the market.
- johnnycerberus 6y agoThe more you win, the more you are going to win. The more you lose, the more you are going to lose. If you win one time people will treat you differently than if you lose. Easier to get capital. Psychologically it will affect you and others around you. Win twice, and this will escalate, people will literally be in awe over you. People will literally do whatever you will tweet. There is also an extremely low chance that you are always going to win in your lifetime, many books will be written about you while a huge graveyard of entrepereneurs that were more capable than you have written on their tombstones: "But what have I done wrong?". But it wasn't their fault, they actually did whatever it was in their power. They were fooled and led to ruin by randomness.
- AbrahamParangi 6y agoIt seems odd to me to simultaneously hold the view that luck is the dominant factor and advantages (like being lucky once) are incredibly important. If advantages are important doesn’t it follow that advantages like intellect, wisdom, or courage might be decisive?
- tjs8rj 6y agoYou have to consider the problem from first principles. A startup is always: creating value by addressing a need for a group of people. Skill and luck weave through all of this. Finding the group of people? Maybe you strategize and seek those out, often they end up being the group you’re a part of or adjacent to (luck or skill?). How about finding that need for that people, and an important need too? If you have past experience maybe you know where to look, maybe you know how to filter the opportunities better and what to focus on. The process of creating value? Maybe you went into a discipline seeking those skills specifically for a startup, or you just happen to know people with the necessary skills to execute. Overall: it’s a hard problem with constantly changing rules and strategies, and often you end up competing with other smart and talented people. Skill stacks the odds, but the problem is so complex that what we call luck is just the lack of deep understanding of the problem. There is probably a set of steps that you could take one after the other that guarantees you’d make $1 billion dollars. Figuring that out is so difficult and complex and changing that thus far the best one can do is be as skilled and hardworking as possible, optimizing where you can, but even that doesn’t guarantee the solution: hence luck. The whole thing IS a skill problem, but it’s so complex that all the parts we can’t fit in the equation we just call luck. Serial founders have gone farther in deciphering that “luck” into skill, so luck is less of a factor for them.
- ClumsyPilot 6y ago>"The number of entrepreneurs who have second and third companies" If that were true, I would expect each next conpany to be much more succesfull as the person accumulates capital, network and skills. Instead what I've seen (and i do not study this as my day job) is that someone has a very successfull startup, and then creates a few 'meh' companies. Peter Thiel never replicated his success, Elon's Boring Company and Hyperloop are unimpressive, Mark Zukerberg or Blly G never surpassed their initial success. This leads me to conclude that with the right skill, funds and connections you can create a business, but to have explosively growing startup is really not a repeatable process
- onion2k 6y agoPeter Thiel never replicated his success, Elon's Boring Company and Hyperloop are unimpressive. Thiel's Palantir is a $40B company. That's a long way shy of PayPal but its certainly quite successful. Musk has had moderate success with Tesla and SpaceX. They might not have surpassed PayPal (yet) but they are both doing successful second and third businesses.
- ClumsyPilot 6y agoSo to me this disprobes the hypothesys: if it were a skill the way programming is, your 5th business should be mwaay more successfull than your first, just like your 5th react app is better thsn your first
- onion2k 6y agoI'm not saying founder ability is the only consideration. There's plenty of other factors - timing, market size, team, etc. Those are things that can be improved with skill and practise. I'm just saying luck - something that can't be improved with experience - isn't a significant factor in my opinion. I'm not suggesting that poster above is saying this, but I have found a lot of founders who fail say that luck is important, while a lot of serial entrepreneurs say luck isn't a big factor. On some level it might be the case that people use luck as an excuse for their failure because they're unwilling to be introspective enough to work out a more tangible set of reasons why their startup failed. On the other hand, maybe the serial entrepreneurs are just lucky and like to say it was actually their skill instead.