5 ms·
Nobody’s “existence” has been politicized in the 30 years I’ve been in America.[1] I remember during 2015-2016 my friends were freaking out asking if I was worr
by rayiner 6y ago
Nobody’s “existence” has been politicized in the 30 years I’ve been in America.[1] I remember during 2015-2016 my friends were freaking out asking if I was worried if Trump would be sending people from Muslim countries (like me) to internment camps. I thought they were being completely absurd. I guess it wasn’t just me: a third of Muslims voted for Trump in 2020. People don’t do that when their “very existence has been politicized.”
Government policies may be unfair, unconstitutional, or discriminatory to different groups of people. But that’s not politicizing people’s “very existence.” That sort of rhetoric is just a way to dial up the temperature of political debates by equating any negative impacts with existential harm. People have a right to freely debate things like who the government will let into the country, what benefits it will provide to whom, etc.
[1] Except unborn children, whose very existence has literally been politicized.
- darkerside 6y agoWhat about deportation of undocumented immigrants? Isn't their existence in this country politicized? People are being killed by gun violence, police violence, gang violence. Isn't it fair for people affected by these things to feel their lives have become political footballs?
- rayiner 6y ago> What about deportation of undocumented immigrants? Isn't their existence in this country politicized? Their presence in a country they’ve entered illegally is the subject of political debate, but that’s not equivalent to a threat to their “very existence.” Calling it that is an attempt to emotionalize a basic function of sovereign nations: policing their borders. It’s something every country does—including the countries from where these undocumented immigrants came. > People are being killed by gun violence, police violence, gang violence. Isn't it fair for people affected by these things to feel their lives have become political footballs? If you’ve been killed by gun violence or police violence or gang violence, then you’re dead. If you haven’t, then you’re debating government policy, not the fact of your “very existence.” Even mundane government policy has life or death implications. People running red lights kills six to ten times as many people each year as mass shootings. But framing a debate over stoplight timing in terms of peoples’ “existence” would be a way to shut down rational policy debate. As an Asian person, I’m much more likely to be killed or attacked by a repeat offender than by the police. But that doesn’t mean I can shut down a discussion of eliminating bail by saying it’s a “threat to my very existence.”
- katbyte 6y ago> If you’ve been killed by gun violence or police violence or gang violence, then you’re dead Unless it’s your family/friends who have been? “How was your weekend Mary?” “My husband/kid was shot in the back by police” I find it sad how your arguing how people’s existence can’t be political or if they are it “doesn’t matter” because they unborn or dead while neglecting people who would still be affected daily like family or a mother who wants to get an abortion but can’t/has to deal with the assholes out front protesting
- JamesBarney 6y agoPeople on parole and bail kill more unarmed people than cops do. Is any talk of bail or parole reform an existential threat that denies people's right to exist?
- katbyte 6y agoSource? And no? I don’t think I gave any indication it would?
- JamesBarney 6y agohttps://www.washingtonpost.com/graphics/investigations/police-shootings-database/?itid=lk_inline_manual_5 https://www.washingtonpost.com/graphics/investigations/polic... About 80 / year police shootings of unarmed individuals. There were about 19,000 homicides last year. 1 in 55 people people are on parole or probation. So even if we make the ludicrous assumption that people on parole or probation have exact same rate of violent crime as non probation or paroled you still end up with 345 homicides by people on parole or probation. I assume a rate 2-3x the base rate for population would be a completely reasonable assumption, giving us ~10x more homicides by people on probation/parole. The point is if police shootings rise to being an existential threat, than criminal justice reform is at least a much of an existential threat.
- katbyte 6y ago
- NateEag 6y ago"Existence in this country" is completely different from "existence," even if the two ideas happen to share a word.
- joshuamorton 6y agoNot really if you're limited to talking about a particular country. Like I guess you could argue it's the difference between ethnic cleansing internally and invading a neighbor to engage in ethnic cleansing, but that's sort of not a hugely important distinction.
- JamesBarney 6y agoI think they're arguing the distinction between "I'm not allowed to live in the u.s. so I have to live somewhere else" and "I'm not allowed to live because I shot in front of a firing squad". Which would seem like a very important distinction if it was my existence.
- joshuamorton 6y agoDoes that distinction really matter if you're already here in the US? Where else do you go?
- JamesBarney 6y agoI'm trying to argue in good faith but you're literally asking does the distinction being having to move and being murdered matter.
- joshuamorton 6y agoTo move where? This thread was in part, but not solely, about undocumented immigrants, and sure maybe they have a place they can legally be sent to. But the same argument has been used for racial separation ("No, we don't want to subjugate black people, we just want to have a white ethnostate where the black people will be forced to move". The part not said aloud of of course, being what happens if someone wishes to stay where they have lived their whole life). So yes, I think the distinction between "will be kicked out by force" or "will simply be shot in the street" can be a lot more tenuous than you're suggesting. But even still, if we're discussing any group that isn't undocumented immigrants (or even potentially citizens whom the president wanted to strip that right from) the question of "where do they go" becomes even more important, because there usually isn't a place they can go.
- joshuamorton 6y agoTrans peoples existence certainly has been politicized. In many cases they are de facto not allowed to exist. > Except unborn children, whose very existence To use your same disingenuous measure of argument, no their existence isn't politicized, whether or not they are "persons" (or alive) is. Fetuses quite obviously exist, everyone agrees on that. The HN guidelines suggest you steelman the arguments of people who you respond to. I don't think you're doing that if your entire argument boils down to a weak rhetorical disagreement about how precisely to define "very existence". Since certain forms of discriminatory policy are politicizing people's very existence. I also don't think people ever widely suggested Muslim people's existence had been politicized, so that's simply a strawperson.
- JamesBarney 6y agoIm pro choice and think the banning of gender reassignment in children is bad. But you're arguing that deciding whether or not a fetus or unborn child is a person is not an existential issue, but when someone can choose to get gender reassignment is. One is very literally an argument about personhood and the right to terminate and the other is about children's and parents right to choose appropriate medical care.
- joshuamorton 6y agoI'm not. I'm arguing that they're the same situation. I think there are other factors that make the issue of gender reassignment completely unlike abortion, but yes they're both existential. GP was claiming only abortion was and I pointed out that that was logically inconsistent. The differences are that regulating abortion harms a third party, the woman, while allowing gender reassignment doesn't.
- bob_roberts 6y ago> Trans peoples existence certainly has been politicized To expand on this - If a trans person has a coworker who consistent and deliberately mis-genders them, there's no way for the person to have a discussion about it that's not political.