4 ms·
> the prices given for consumers assume that they are not going to max out the bandwidth all the time Consumers should be free to violate any and all assumptio
by matheusmoreira 6y ago
> the prices given for consumers assume that they are not going to max out the bandwidth all the time
Consumers should be free to violate any and all assumptions with no negative consequences. Especially unstated ones that only people familiar with their business model would know about.
If an ISP advertises 1 gigabit/second internet, consumers should be able to fill that pipe with 1 gigabit of data every second. In practice only a minority is going to do that but it should be possible with no punitive throttling of bandwidth whatsoever.
- shawnz 6y agoRight, if they think customers need less then they can just advertise less. They shouldn't get the benefit of advertising a big number while providing a small number just because most customers can't tell. That will make it impossible to fairly compare them with their competitors.
- mrtksn 6y agoSure, customers can do that. That's how you get quotas, fair usage limits, higher prices when the average usage pattern diverges from the intended use cases before the technology or infrastructure upgrades catch up.
- buran77 6y agoThe one caveat is that today all ISPs advertise their plans as "up to" a certain speed very prominently in all marketing material. It's no even fine print or byline. The "fair usage" clause is the kind of thing that's buried deep to hide that they may employ throttling. Think of a "service" you provide. If your employer was expecting you to deliver peak performance 8h per day, 5 days per week, for the rest of your employment with no exception, would you still accept the salary you get now, or would ask an order of magnitude more? It's just that your employment contract and law introduce some "fine print" to allow downtime, and the chance to make mistakes or run at lower efficiency with no (immediate) termination. Why is the same so unacceptable when it comes to a product or service you pay for?
- goodpoint 6y ago> Why is the same so unacceptable when it comes to a product or service you pay for? ...because it could be described and measured precisely. And it's not.
- buran77 6y agoMy friend, there are very few things that we can describe precisely, from a legal standpoint or even for technical specs. It's all about "ranges". And the higher the precision and the guarantee, the higher the price, or the converse. Which was my point, in case I couldn't manage to make it clear enough even when putting it next to something an average person could relate to. There's leeway built into any legal or technical framework and the contract terms should follow. Your "precisely defined and measured" SATA3 6 Gbit/s interface never delivers the 6.000Gbps to you by design (8b/10b encoding). So are all SSDs and motherboards in breach? SSDs rarely hit any of the advertised speed. By comparison their endurance is defined far clearer for the consumer. Whether it's an SSD or an internet connection they come with clear predefined conditions that are legal* and the customer agrees to. Everything else is high consumer expectations meeting low consumer willingness to pay, or even to understand the relationship. *Of course there are plenty of illegal and abusive clauses but giving a stated 900Mbps average speed with a 1Gbps contract, or selling an SSD with stated low DWPD don't really fit that description.
- goodpoint 6y agoDon't shift the goalposts. You started from a very broad claim: > Why is the same so unacceptable when it comes to a product or service you pay for? ...and now you are talking about "ranges". Datacenters and ISPs for commercial use can provide very detailed SLAs. Consumer ISPs refuse to publish metrics or have 3rd party services monitor them to create accountability. They refuse to provide the most basic SLAs and refuse to adopt any user-friendly quality rating.
- buran77 6y agoMeh: > The one caveat is that today all ISPs advertise their plans as "up to" a certain speed very prominently in all marketing material. I literally started how describing something as "up to" [ostensibly a range] is not outright misleading, if at all. It was also strictly speaking of marketing material and how well you can convey info in one banner. Seems you're not a stranger of moving goalposts and dodging question. You're selectively arguing some of my points, while so elegantly avoiding others because "oh that's different". Which is a very immature way of pretending to have a meaningful conversation, and a good way of hinting you have no counter for that one. You're doubling down on your misconceptions. Whatever "they" do it's because it's legal. And I'll be blunt: your definition of what is moral and what things should mean is irrelevant. If you want to be right at any cost you can just keep inventing personal definitions to apply to others but not to you because "that's different". I made my point at quite some length. If that didn't do it, nothing will.
- pixl97 6y agoThen expect to pay significantly more. TANSTAAFL
- Aerroon 6y agoI think this is unrealistic. Very few consumers are going to have high utilization of their bandwidth. The connections are going to be mostly idle. It makes sense from an efficiency standpoint to then share that resource among more customers. That way you can bring down the price. Look at the cost of business internet. It's guaranteed. If it says 100 Mbps then you're going to get it with effectively no interruptions. But you're also paying 5-10x more than a consumer connection, because the ISP can't resell some of that connection that you don't use.
- convolvatron 6y agoall that may be true. but capturing reality and providing sales terms that reflect it is the responsibility of the seller. one that they have clearly abrogated in the interest of extracting more money from the market.
- matheusmoreira 6y ago> Very few consumers are going to have high utilization of their bandwidth. The connections are going to be mostly idle. It makes sense from an efficiency standpoint to then share that resource among more customers. That's okay. What's not okay is suddenly punishing users who for some reason decided to use a lot of bandwidth because they were under the impression that they could.