4 ms·
It sounds like you think all tech companies just make stuff for consumer websites. There are quite a few that don’t interact with global customers and literall
by kortilla 6y ago
It sounds like you think all tech companies just make stuff for consumer websites.
There are quite a few that don’t interact with global customers and literally never have to even discuss those things.
- vidarh 6y agoI've worked across a wide range of companies in tech for 25 years, so no, I don't. But I've also yet to work for or with a single company where tech decisions were not inherently political. E.g. I had a contract to do a communications system to relay debug mapping data from an autonomous submersible. For a military research institute. It was inherently political because I had to consider if I was ok with working a project that might end up being used in armed conflict in the future my code certainly wouldn't). Or when I worked on code to maintain the quality documentation for a systems integrated that delivered backend systems for the police. I had no problems with that, but I might have if it'd been somewhere where the police had a worse reputation than in Norway where I did that job. I've worked on billing systems where we had to decide on anti-fraud measures. Sounds non-political, until you realise it often involves broad blocks that stereotypes behaviours based on factors that very easily ends up effectively profiling users. I could list many more. I've yet to work on a single software system where the higher level architecture did not involve consideration of political issues whether explicitly, or implicitly. I'm sure there are some, but I think there are far fewer than you imagine.
- kortilla 6y agoDo you consider a farmer’s decision to sell food to the public political since he could be feeding terrorists? Pencils can be used to write manifestos that result in countless deaths. Is the pencil manufacturer responsible for that? I worked for a company that had train control systems as a product. How do you suppose that was political? Do you think we should have spent more time considering that maybe we shouldn’t have been making trains safer because we could accidentally save the next Hitler?
- darkerside 6y agoParent offered since terrific examples. The least you could do is give an example of a company unaffected by politics. Frankly I'm skeptical of your line of reasoning but happy to entertain it.
- katbyte 6y agoI don’t think they exist because even something as simple as “changing master to main” gets pushback because “political” It’s a name, it’s generally not hard to change, and if it makes someone happier why not main is shorter to type! But people still push back against it for.. reasons
- goatinaboat 6y agoBut people still push back against it for.. reasons It's pretty simple, actually Person A: We need to do thing X Person B: Why? Person A: Because I am morally superior to you, and I say so You really don't understand why person B would push back against tacitly accepting that they were the moral deficient? It's the same reason people dislike vegans who say "for moral reasons", they're asserting that everyone around them is immoral, and people find it obnoxious.
- katbyte 6y agoIm sorry but I really don’t follow. How is asking making any moral judgements? Your either reading into what people say and not handling your own discomfort very well or making assumptions on what person a would say? When this first came up I too asked why: “Because it reminds people of slavery which is still fresh in the minds of many and makes some uncomfortable” “Oh, Ok” changes it and moves on with her life Another way of looking at it is “why not?”
- goatinaboat 6y agoBecause it reminds people of slavery which is still fresh in the minds of many and makes some uncomfortable Well, "main" is like "mainmast" of the sailing ships that brought the slaves over. See, once you start this game, it never ends. The master in "master branch" was never anything to do with slavery - and everyone knows it. No one in the world equated committing to master with endorsing slavery, but that is what you are accusing them of. Same as master bedroom and master's degree and mastering a skill and countless other examples. And why is "master" problematic but not "owner"? After all the common term was not "slavemaster" but "slaveowner" remember. Shall we do branch owners or code owners or file owners next? Another way of looking at it is “why not?” Why not leave it as it is then? Why step onto a never ending treadmill of arbitrary changes for change's sake? Anyway I'm not trying to convince you here (I get the feeling that that would be pointless) I am merely explaining to you the behaviour you have observed but don't understand the motivation for.