3 ms·
3.5 cents per sachet seems very expensive in bulk. A sachet probably only contains a gram or so, meaning these ingredients are being sold at $35/kilo. $3/kil
by londons_explore 6y ago
3.5 cents per sachet seems very expensive in bulk. A sachet probably only contains a gram or so, meaning these ingredients are being sold at $35/kilo.
$3/kilo sounds far more reasonable, and it should be sold in 1kg containers and users instructed to use a teaspoon per large bucket.
- kijin 6y agoThere seem to be two main use cases for this stuff. One is everyday disinfection of drinking water. For that purpose a large container might be more economical, provided that it can be kept reasonably watertight through three years of daily use. (1 gram per day per family means a 1kg container will last 2-3 years.) The other is emergency use in disaster zones for a limited amount of time. For this purpose a bunch of sealed sachets is much easier to transport and distribute despite the high unit cost.
- leetrout 6y agoAt least for sodium hypochlorite in solution it loses its disinfection properties quickly as I understand it. I wonder if it would have to stay in the packets or smaller containers to maintain its efficacy?
- londons_explore 6y agoAnything sealed will work. A glass jam jar is 8 cents and can hold 1 kg.
- leetrout 6y agoSunlight destroys chlorine — is it only when it’s in water or would it affect the powder too?
- raverbashing 6y ago"By 1kg bucket" sounds good but it is probably very unstable outside of the sachet (hygroscopic, could dissociate, could clump up, etc) (probably more than 1g per sachet, 4g as it says in the picture)
- vorpalhex 6y ago$0.035 to clean 10 liters of water is very good. $35/kilo doesn't seem unreasonable given that chlorine itself is $16-$22 a kilo through consumer stores. Given that these are pretty gnarly chemicals in bulk, I don't think you want users handling them. Training users on PPE and procedure and supplying the PPE is a whole mess. I have no idea where you got $3 from.
- engineer_22 6y agoDon't really need any special ppe for hypo and ferric. They're common industrial water treatment chemicals, meaning they're handled daily by low skilled workers without much news of accidents. There aren't even any special containment requirements for small quantities <500 gallons. Crystalized these chemicals are very stable and represent low risk to operators. As a yard stick of cost: surface water treatment costs somewhere in the neighborhood of $1/1,000 gallons in the developed world.