3 ms·

Why does it take 33 posts to tell a story on Twitter? I know why, but _WHY_?

exciteabletom 5y ago
What's the point of being a micro blog platform if long-form text is written anyway? Twitter either needs to disallow long text in threads or just remove the character limit.
- majewsky 5y ago
  Both of your proposals would make Twitter significantly worse. - Removing the character limit would just make the feed unwieldy and unpleasant, especially when reading it in chronological order (bottom-up) like it was meant to be read. Typically a follower's feed will contain a collapsed version of the thread showing only the first one or two tweets and a "Show whole thread" button, so they can read a short summary in order to decide whether or not to go into the entire thing. - Disallowing long text in threads would just push people into writing the first half of their post on Twitter and the second half on $THING (there were once specialized websites for this format, like Twitlonger), which makes the reading and commenting experience unnecessarily disjointed. Another advantage of tweet threads is that people can share/like/comment individual tweets, which serves to surface the one or two interesting highlights out of a 30-tweet-long story. It's sort of like line highlights or line comments in some blog platforms. (And if you disagree with my viewpoint, that's fine. I'm not intending to convince you to use Twitter, just explaining why things are the way they are to the best of my knowledge.)
  - exciteabletom 5y ago
    These are good points. I especially hadn't considered the commenting on individual tweets aspect. IMO it's a bit esoteric to click on an individual tweet to read the comments, because it breaks the flow of my reading. But I can totally understand the upsides of that. After hearing your thoughts, Twitter could improve by removing the character limit BUT: - Showing only the first 250 characters of a post on user's feeds. - Putting a like button next to each paragraph - Making it easy to inline quote sections of the text in comments by building it into a context menu when you highlight text This UX would only apply to >250 character tweets, so the micro blogging aspect is not totally lost. Perhaps a option could be added to filter out long tweets for users who prefer micro blogging. This way you wouldn't have to laboriously chain tweets together, and you would actually gain flexibility in quoting specific sections without breaking the flow of reading.
  - deleted 5y ago
    [deleted]

What's the point of being a micro blog platform if long-form text is written anyway? Twitter either needs to disallow long text in threads or just remove the character limit.

majewsky 5y ago
Both of your proposals would make Twitter significantly worse. - Removing the character limit would just make the feed unwieldy and unpleasant, especially when reading it in chronological order (bottom-up) like it was meant to be read. Typically a follower's feed will contain a collapsed version of the thread showing only the first one or two tweets and a "Show whole thread" button, so they can read a short summary in order to decide whether or not to go into the entire thing. - Disallowing long text in threads would just push people into writing the first half of their post on Twitter and the second half on $THING (there were once specialized websites for this format, like Twitlonger), which makes the reading and commenting experience unnecessarily disjointed. Another advantage of tweet threads is that people can share/like/comment individual tweets, which serves to surface the one or two interesting highlights out of a 30-tweet-long story. It's sort of like line highlights or line comments in some blog platforms. (And if you disagree with my viewpoint, that's fine. I'm not intending to convince you to use Twitter, just explaining why things are the way they are to the best of my knowledge.)
- exciteabletom 5y ago
  These are good points. I especially hadn't considered the commenting on individual tweets aspect. IMO it's a bit esoteric to click on an individual tweet to read the comments, because it breaks the flow of my reading. But I can totally understand the upsides of that. After hearing your thoughts, Twitter could improve by removing the character limit BUT: - Showing only the first 250 characters of a post on user's feeds. - Putting a like button next to each paragraph - Making it easy to inline quote sections of the text in comments by building it into a context menu when you highlight text This UX would only apply to >250 character tweets, so the micro blogging aspect is not totally lost. Perhaps a option could be added to filter out long tweets for users who prefer micro blogging. This way you wouldn't have to laboriously chain tweets together, and you would actually gain flexibility in quoting specific sections without breaking the flow of reading.
- deleted 5y ago
  [deleted]