3 ms·
One possible way to test this: compare the outcomes of people with All But Degree to people with degrees. If human capital is the important factor then being 6
by yummyfajitas 15y ago
One possible way to test this: compare the outcomes of people with All But Degree to people with degrees.
If human capital is the important factor then being 6 credits short of a 140 credit degree shouldn't affect outcomes. If signalling matters, it should have a rather large effect.
- paganel 15y ago> If human capital is the important factor then being 6 credits short of a 140 credit degree shouldn't affect outcomes. If signalling matters, it should have a rather large effect. It it matters, I'm a CS dropout from an an Eastern European country which is also part of the European Union. Let's say I've got 125 out of 140 credits (so I got pretty close to actually finishing it). Anyway, I have a pretty good job and all, but once in a while I receive a job offer that actually sounds interesting. It did happen to me to actually get rejected from such a job "because as you don't have a degree, and as we work with an European Union agency, and as said EU Agency requires that all our employees should have a CS degree, we're sorry to announce to you etc", as they elegantly put it. Some other guys said no to my salary requirement "because you don't have a CS degree, we won't receive the tax breaks given by the Government to us for hiring people with CS degrees, so we're going to pay you less". Fuck them, I said :) I don't know what the moral of the story should be. What I got out of it all is that I should always work in an environment very close to a meritocracy (and small startups seem to be the closest thing to this), and maybe later down the road open my own shop.
- megablast 15y agoAs someone who worked in the EU before, I was never asked to prove I had a degree or an honours degree. Have you been asked to prove it, or are you just being honest?
- paganel 15y ago> or are you just being honest? I hope I'm being honest, why would I lie? Anyway, said company had a contract with a European Union Agency, and, as mentioned, said Agency was putting a major emphasis (as in more points awarded as part of the tender process) on sub-contractors that had only CS-graduates as programmers. And the "tax-deductions for companies hiring CS-graduates part" I'll admit, it's not an EU-wide, EU-mandated policy (hence my mention that the tax was collected by my country's Government), but my suspicion is that my country is not the only one adopting this particular tax treatment. I think the people that came up with this policy thought that this would somehow create an IT bonanza. It might achieve that, who knows? But you'll have to admit it has some perverse effects, such as non-graduates like myself being at a disadvantage compared to degree-holding programmers.
- zach 15y agoThis is a great study on this subject, although the data is getting a little old by now (1993 study with 1979 high school students). http://www.irs.princeton.edu/pubs/pdfs/311.pdf http://www.irs.princeton.edu/pubs/pdfs/311.pdf Quote of interest: "We generally continue to find positive and significant coefficients on numbers of credits completed, as each year's worth of credits was associated with a 3-5% increase in both hourly wages and annual earnings. Perhaps surprisingly, the estimated 'sheepskin effects' of degree completion over and above the value of the credits completed were often small when studying wages and earnings."