6 ms·
The Enemy as Sociologist
- tgv 6y agoI cannot take the style of that article seriously. It seems to be about the magazine Signal, a Nazi magazine. E.g.: > Signal was an insidious tool of Nazi ideology, meant to counteract an image of fanaticism and indiscriminate violence: by late autumn 1943, as many Jews as Signal readers had been murdered in Poland’s extermination camps. There is absolutely no relation between the magazine and the Holocaust. The date is arbitrarily chosen. And reading literally, it says that millions of Signal readers had been murdered. It's writing at its worst. For those of you who haven't opened the article yet, a question: can you guess which person is named first, in the article's opening sentence, two words in?
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- alex_h 6y agoI think the sentence is meant to be read: "As many Jews as [the number of] Signal readers" i.e. equating the size of the groups, not saying that they were the same group.
- tgv 6y agoI understand that. It's probably also the reason the date (late autumn 1943) was picked. But in the haste of claiming guilt-by-association and showing a razor-sharp anti-fascist mind to the reader, the author wrote a meaningless sentence, and then fucked it up. That's bad writing.
- hutzlibu 6y ago"There is absolutely no relation between the magazine and the Holocaust" There is no relation between a nazi propaganda magazine and the holocaust? Erm. Sorry, but I don't see that logic.
- hutzlibu 6y agoTo reply myself: I actually do see a strong connection between a state magazine activly promoting the awesomeness of that state - while that same state is activly doing the holocaust more or less in secret. Because people believing propaganda leads to less resistance to the Nazi forces military and diplomatically, effectivly meaning more jews could be gassed. But .. there is likely no point here, debating this any further.
- tgv 6y agoIf you'd had written that wrt to something like the Völkische Beobachter, fine, but this was a rather dumb glossy, which doesn't appear to have aimed at inciting antisemitism. When it was first published, gassing hadn't been considered yet. And there has never been enough resistance from the population to overthrow the Nazis. The only thing that could overthrow them, was a war at enormous scale on two fronts, and I don't see how a Finnish or Flemish publication could have affected that in any significant way. It's just too far fetched, too "wings of a butterfly". You could just as well argue that the Chicken Dance is responsible for us letting our guards down, which led to 9/11, which led to the bloodshed in Iraq and Afghanistan.
- hutzlibu 6y agoSignal was intentionally not using aggressive antisemitism the same way, whole nazi germany got very soft before the olympics 1936 in germany - to spread a false image. Propaganda. So people not yet occupied get a wrong image like "maybe the Nazis are not so bad after all and we can still do buisness". German resistance groups struggled hard to get evidence out. And then it was not believed, because of propaganda like this. Signal on its own might have been not that big factor, but it was no random butterfly, but willingly part of the bigger propaganda machine, which main purpose was to support nazi domination, which includes the holocaust.
- icegreentea2 6y agoI think the opening of the article is unfortunate. It doesn't relate that strongly, or support the bulk of the article, which is a skim through different Signal (which as you say was a Nazi magazine). The rest of the article is better, but still kind of surface level I feel. There are two broad strands of thought in the rest of the article: a) Signal critiques of America could be "surprisingly" nuanced and/or still resonating today and b) the tone of signal critiques show a surprising acceptance of some level of greatness of America. I say surface level, because a) seems kind of obvious. The best propaganda is to selectively choose (and perhaps mildly exaggerate) your opponents true weaknesses/downsides, while emphasizing (or perhaps fully fabricating) your own strengths. Especially when your target is notionally the land of freedom. For b) that's also not completely surprising. It was simply NOT feasible not acknowledge America's material strength and wealth. You could not have plausible propaganda claiming that America did not have admirable resources or industry. Fundamentally this boils down to, Nazis were not cartoon caricatures of humans. They were humans like us, spanning the entire spectrum of temperaments, "high browness", education, and tendencies. Even more, they were humans raised in the western tradition - there were Nazis who were ever bit as informed by enlightenment thinking and greek rhetoric as we are here today. And therefore they could choose to write propaganda that would appeal or at least resonate with us to this day. The final line however is probably the most interesting bit: "What if our enemies know us better than we know ourselves?". This line of thinking invites us to ask all sorts of interesting questions such as: * What are the means by which we "know ourselves" - who teaches us about ourselves? * Is our failures to change really a failure of knowledge? Amongst which group of people?
- pmurt7 6y agoFirst line: "Trump"; second line: "Nazi". Sociology should be renamed "far-left propaganda". This is the most bullshit science ever.
- iagovar 6y agoI studied sociology in Spain. Here going to uni you can't choose much what you want to study so you have to go through every roadblock and eat that theory timesinks. There's too much activism in the field. I know people in social sciences hate to talk about this because they see as an attack from outsiders that they don't understand the limitations of current methodology, but it's true. It's too much to deal with. My university had some ideological diversity among professors, yet I was subject to veiled attacks from professors who feeled that I asked to many questions or that I wasn't aligned with them. Such as talking about me to other classes in a demeaning manner, saying I was too liberal, and trying to frame me. I went to uni in my mid 20s and I am actually someone who was poor, who comes from an unstructured family, and who had to do all the route from basic education to uni by myself, while working and living in less than desirable places, so I'm one of those "oppressed folks", and I clearly saw that being from that background and confronting them didn't sit them too well. And I wasn't unpolite or anything, I just had questions and wasn't 18, nor shy. This of course translates to other dynamics, like publications and grants. In Spanish there are some publications who I would classify as "serious" in the field (like REIS) yet some obvious ideological BS slips from time to time. There was also plenty of network effects for getting money for research, and some other professors, which I personally considered more... professional, or serious, or whatever you want it, where affected by this dynamics because their personality didn't allow them to play office politics. It was a shame, and seeing that is one of the main things that prevented me to pursue an academic career. One of my professors told me once something that IMO is very true. Fields like sociology are in desperate need for outsiders. Not everything is activism nor far-left propaganda (google functionalism, symbolic interactivism, systems theory to name theree schools of the top of my head) but if nobody who's willing to fight BS stays (like myself), it will just perpetuate, and there's an actual need for this field to develop further. Hm, idk if I should post this, it's too personal.
- deleted 6y ago
- thu2111 6y agoWell, that was a pretty interesting article about history but it won't do any good for the perception that academia is filled with dangerously hard left radicals. The author is a "Stenbeck Fellow in Cultural Reporting and Criticism at NYU’s Arthur L. Carter Journalism Institute ... a graduate of Princeton University and the University of Edinburgh, where she was a Witherspoon Scholar". These sorts of people are notorious for being unable to recognize that Nazi-ism was an ideology of the hard left, an ideology that the academic classes are extremely susceptible to. And indeed, we can feel her discomfort at nearly realizing the truth in the final paragraphs: "Reading Signal today, I had the strange, uncomfortable feeling that I was agreeing, at least partially, with analyses promoted by the United States’ most notorious enemy ... its analyses of problems in the United States have a ring of accuracy to them—in many cases, more so than even US publications ... Without the clear nationalist rhetoric of other Nazi publications, Signal’s critiques of American capitalism scan as accurate, even percipient—prefiguring the work of later US writers like David Riesman and C. Wright Mills, who analyzed the effects of capitalism on an increasingly uniform, alienated American middle class." Yes, you agree with them because the National Socialists were on the hard left and so are you. The analyses in question are bog standard Marxism in which capitalism is equated with moral degeneracy, exploitation and "imperialism", the exact same tactic used by the Soviets. The concept of widespread "alienation" is also distilled Marx: you just don't find that word or concept outside of Marxist literature. Yet there is absolutely nothing accurate or percipient about Marxism nor Nazi-ism. Their social analyses were dangerous garbage designed to sound clever without actually being so, and that fact is widely understood everywhere except the sort of places the author has spent their life in - places that are today riven with the same old ideas posing in new clothes. The fact that the Nazis were leftists is a fact the modern left constantly tries to deny today, but they were as far from Constitution-loving capitalists as it's possible to get. This article shows that extremely clearly: in their own analyses of their enemies they were inseparable from the Soviets they were fighting. What's scary is, even after the defeat of the Nazis and the fall of the USSR, in the western world this type of racist leftism was not wiped out as commonly assumed but merely retreated to its stronghold in academia. The exact sort of people who are obsessed with equating Nazis and conservative white men are also the sort of people who write glowing reviews of Nazi propaganda magazines. "The Enemy as Sociologist" indeed. How very ironic.
- kingsuper20 6y agoEven given the political kinks of the writer, who is probably just a kid after all, it's not a terrible article. There are some reasonable take-aways. . That 'Signal' existed. It's pretty interesting really, I've got a few hardbound volumes in one of my history book hoards. Worth looking at. . Propaganda is everywhere. The hard part is seeing it in your own world, not others'. . History is complicated. Historian's fallacy is real. Watch out. . Nazis will fascinate people for a long time. I honestly think that a big part of it is their use of symbols, imagery, snappy uniforms, bigger-than-life super villains. An absolutely ridiculous belief system, but that never stopped groups of people from buying into things. Of course sociology is largely self-serving BS (see: Stanislav Andreski: Social Sciences as Sorcery) but then so are a lot of other soft disciplines. You can't blame these people for riding a wave. To tie it back into the article, much of sociology is an attempt to program people with your own belief system, not to understand and predict. Perhaps it's just the advertising business with a figleaf of science.
- mathattack 6y agoI had two writing classes at the university which were driven by activist professors. The first I fought and got a bad grade. The second I parroted and got a good grade. That was enough for me to understand the lesson.
- motohagiography 6y agoThe article ends: > If this extreme myopia does in fact define us as a people, an artifact such as Signal asks us to consider: What if our enemies know us better than we know ourselves? Well, yes, most of what students have learned in schools in the last decade would have been considered enemy propaganda even only a decade or two prior. The object of most theory taught in schools is intended to "destabilize," hegemonic ideas, which is literally a propaganda tactic. Educating young people to adopt an identity of being victims who are not held to the standards of their ostensible oppressors is an old recipe, and one the Germans used to great effect after Weimar, which produced the necessary shame to enable the cruely and zeal of the national socialist movement. It was borrowed from Russians who had recently deposed their Czar less than two decades earlier. The narrative and aesthetic promise of renewal was borrowed from Italy's fascists, who were a just tin pot nationalist movement compared to the totalitarianisms of Russia and Germany. Just like Stalin, Hitler used communist movements with populist fascist narratives and aesthetics as a vehicle for a totalitarian movement, which is defined by its total war on truth itself. If destabilizing propaganda from that era bears some resemblance to the current day, it is because most of the cognitive frameworks we were taught to understand the world through come from the same sources.
- TheOtherHobbes 6y agoYou're touching on something interesting, which is the difference between political narrative and politics-as-action. In politics, narratives are not true or false in the scientific sense. They're created purely for persuasive purposes, as expedient air cover used to justify social actions. Factually the narratives may be completely true but selectively chosen, partially true and distorted, or even completely untrue. The social actions - which can be horrific and impossible to justify on their own terms - are sold via narratives to disguise them and make them palatable, with the aim of increasing the power of the ruling group. Signal is a superb example of creating a selective narrative by copying the style and tone of a successful publication to make it more credible and persuasive to its middle-European middlebrow target audience. Of course all the harsh racism was removed because that was the entire point. Western academic Marxist theory, on the other hand, is a superb example of failing to understand narrative - which is ironic, because Critical Theory is supposed to be the best tool ever created for narrative analysis. It isn't, because it doesn't understand its own politics, never mind the practically-oriented opinion management machinery of Capitalism, or the condescending cynical dishonesty of Far-Right Nationalism. In reality it's intensely tribal and exclusive, and this makes it an incredibly soft and easy target for its enemies.