Agreed but I also think this depends heavily on context. If the organization cares a lot of clean commit messages, have a nice git history, and want PRs to be

Agreed but I also think this depends heavily on context. If the organization cares a lot of clean commit messages, have a nice git history, and want PRs to be submitted in a clean state, great! This is not always the case. I've worked on codebases where we rarely scan the git history messages for anything useful, it's just as easy for us to dig into the code to figure out what's wrong.