6 ms·
Ooh, the original Chaum paper! Chaum "coins" behave a lot more like bearer instruments or "free banking" notes; they're IOUs issued by a bank that can be trade
by pjc50 6y ago
Ooh, the original Chaum paper!
Chaum "coins" behave a lot more like bearer instruments or "free banking" notes; they're IOUs issued by a bank that can be traded.
The advantage over a database is that there's some ability to do offline transactions, although the double-spend prevention is done through the originating bank.
The advantage over bitcoin is that is uses a tiny fraction of the energy. It's also naturally a "stablecoin", rather than highly volatile.
- wyager 6y agoThe disadvantage compared to Bitcoin is that it’s hardly meaningfully different from using Paypal or something.
- helen___keller 6y agoHow do you figure?
- capableweb 6y agoIn short, the suggested method by Chaum requires a trusted 3rd party (bank). The topmost invention of Bitcoin is that it requires no trusted 3rd party.
- 1e-9 6y ago> it requires no trusted 3rd party Or, at least not the same 3rd parties. Instead, it requires trusting a much larger host of other 3rd parties, many of which are anonymous, and likely none of which will provide recourse if you lose your bitcoin due to their failure or malicious intent.[1] Bitcoin represents a shifting of trust; not an elimination of trust. That's not to say there is no value. It's just that there are significant risks involving trust that are overlooked by most holders. [1] https://www.schneier.com/blog/archives/2019/02/blockchain_and_.html https://www.schneier.com/blog/archives/2019/02/blockchain_an...
- shawnz 6y agoI wouldn't say those risks are overlooked by most holders, rather that risk profile is exactly the reason why anyone would want to use cryptocurrency to begin with. Perhaps some hype artists would claim otherwise, but they shouldn't be defining how you view the technology itself.
- ineedasername 6y agoYes, I think it's important to distinguish between the technology & its current use case. The technology is promising (though in bitcoin, stagnant). The primary use case right now seems to be financial speculation. That would have to change in order for any crypto currency to really gain any sort of mainstream traction as an alternative to traditional cash or credit (banks).
- rogueSkib 6y agoI don't believe this is accurate. As trust is spread across the network to an increasing number of people running nodes, the trust assigned to any individual participant approaches zero. This can be observed in the resilience of the network, as it self-heals against any attacker or alternative fork from the consensus. Bitcoin has democratically ossified into a store-of-value with absolute scarcity, deterministic monetary policy, and a priority on decentralization. It's extremely unlikely that those attributes will be compromised.
- 1e-9 6y ago> As trust is spread across the network to an increasing number of people running nodes, the trust assigned to any individual participant approaches zero. If only we knew this was true. An increase in the number of people running nodes does not guarantee that the maximum trust assigned to any individual participant approaches zero. What is the size of the largest Bitcoin whale? What is the size of the largest Bitcoin cartel? How do you know that the share of the largest Bitcoin whale or cartel isn’t increasing? What prevents China from deciding to eliminate the Bitcoin threat to its control by taking over the Chinese miners and launching a 51% attack? Even if you are willing to believe that trust is well distributed across many independent entities, you still need to have greater trust in your own security and IT skills. When your wallet is hacked or you lose your credentials, there’s no number to call to recover your Bitcoin. Bitcoin still requires significant trust, which is often overlooked.
- betterunix2 6y ago...and to achieve that, Bitcoin has a backwards approach to security where the honest parties must work harder than the attackers, which ultimately means that nobody can confidently say that the system is secure unless a majority of energy produced on Earth is being devoted to honest parties mining Bitcoin. It is also wrong to suggest that the bank in Chaum's system is a "trusted third party," as if the bank can unilaterally break any security property of the system. In fact the bank in an ecash system is very much constrained. The bank cannot violate a user's privacy (in the sense of linking a user's transactions) unless the user attempts to spend the same coin twice. The bank's ability to claim that a user was trying to conduct some kind of double-spending attack is also constrained (the no-frame-ups property) so that a user must actually attempt to double spend a coin for the bank to produce evidence of such a crime. It is also possible to create a distributed trust model where several parties must jointly issue the coins (threshold blind signatures). Unlike Bitcoin, the security model of ecash is well-defined and follows the basic philosophy of cryptographic security: the computational difficult of attacking the system grows exponentially with the computational work performed by honest parties. Put another way, the energy expended in an ecash system will grow linearly with the number of transactions being performed in the system, and the incentive is to reduce the energy consumption by finding more efficient ways to process transactions. If the cost of a well-defined, rigorous security model, a system that incentivizes minimizing energy consumption, and features that Bitcoin can never actually support (e.g. direct peer-to-peer payments that do not require an Internet connection or any communication with any third parties), is to have a central bank or consortium of banks that issues the coins, you can count me in.
- billytetrud 6y ago> unless a majority of energy produced on Earth is being devoted to honest parties mining Bitcoin. Nope, try again
- betterunix2 6y agoHow do you know when enough computational effort / energy has been devoted to mining i.e. how do you know that there is no attacker out there who is working harder than all the honest users combined?
- ulrikrasmussen 6y agoWhat do you mean? It's not like PayPal because the sender is actually anonymous (assuming that exact amounts are hidden by always withdrawing fixed size coins).
- ineedasername 6y agoBitcoin isn't quite anonymous, as a variety of criminals have found out. Cash is anonymous: there is no unique identifier associated either with the transaction or the parties to the transaction. Bitcoin on the other hand is, at best, pseudonymous. This is particularly problematic because it gives information about true identities when the owner of coins wants to spend it in any way on anything where bitcoin is not an accepted form of payment. Then, the "off ramp" becomes much more closely associated with the owner of the coins. Heck, even in a world where on-ramps & off-ramps to bitcoin weren't necessary because everyone used bitcoin this would still be problematic: An address suspected of holding coins obtained through illegal enterprise pays a car dealership in bitcoins for a new car, and the authorities simply go to the dealership with a warrant and say "tells us everything you possibly can about that transaction and the people involved in the purchase & delivery of that vehicle".
- ziml77 6y agoAnd figuring out those addresses can come from finding another criminal address. By its whole design Bitcoin lets everyone see which wallets have transacted with each other.
- ineedasername 6y agoPrecisely. I'm not saying it's a bad thing, but it really doesn't mesh with the common bitcoin dogma of a virtual currency free of the ability of governments to interfere with it. There's nothing stopping governments from shutting it down either. The US by itself could practically take it down alone (or any other crypto) by banning US banks from working with it, or from working with any non-US bank that that deals with bitcoin. No need for a 51% attack, no need to track electricity usage to locate potential miners, just a simple piece of legislation. Or even simpler, an executive order issuing the same ban, stating that bitcoin enables significant financial activity by terrorists & criminals.
- betterunix2 6y agoActually the bank does more than just issue coins and detect double spending. The bank is the ultimate authority on whether any coin is valid (just like with paper money), in the sense that the bank can refuse to accept a deposit. This is crucial to the security definition of ecash -- crucial because the security definition of any cryptosystem that is trying to achieve "electronic money" must in some way define "money." Also, double-spending detection can be defined in several ways. My view is that the best definition includes the no-frame-up property and the "full tracing" property. A system that supports full tracing allows a cheating user to be blacklisted completely, since the double spending detection procedure produces a value that can be used to check if any coin was spent by the cheating user (basically, users have secret keys they use to spend; double-spending will reveal the secret key used for double spending). This is a nice property because it allows the bank to issue blacklists of cheating users, which are enforced by the bank's refusal to accept any coins that were spent by that user (even those not double spent), and thus no other party is willing to accept payments from blacklisted users since the coins are effectively worthless (as the bank will not accept them for deposit). In other words there is a meaningful way to punish a cheating user. Finally, there is no reason these systems must naturally be "stablecoins." The bank need not peg the coin's value to anything, it can float freely like any other currency and the bank can choose any monetary policy, including one that results in significant volatility. The bank could even emulate Bitcoin by setting a fixed limit on coins in circulation (the different between the number of withdrawals and number of deposits) and periodically releasing more coins (maybe giving them in fixed amounts to randomly chosen users to simulate mining). If the coins did have stable values or were pegged to a currency with stable value, that would only be because the bank itself thought it was a good idea (perhaps in response to customer demand), not because there is something inherent in ecash that promotes stability.
- billytetrud 6y ago> This is a nice property because it allows the bank to issue blacklists of cheating users That property consequently allows a bank to black list any user, not just cheating users. There are many situations where that can be not so nice. In bitcoin, cheating isn't even feasible. It's better to prevent cheating entirely than to black list cheaters after the fact.