4 ms·
Apparently close to 30% of household income right now is from government payments. I think on average people are getting the equiv of $15/hr from gov checks.
by mc32 6y ago
Apparently close to 30% of household income right now is from government payments. I think on average people are getting the equiv of $15/hr from gov checks. So for people to want to work it’s going to have to exceed that by some non trivial amount.
- jnwatson 6y agoUltimately, this is a problem with all government benefits with an strict binary income limit. The result is that, in some circumstances, earning 1 more dollar results in losing thousands of dollars. The marginal income tax system was set up this way for a reason. If these unemployment benefits were paid out UBI-style, regardless of current employment, there wouldn't be a disincentive to find work.
- petre 6y ago> earning 1 more dollar results in losing thousands of dollars They might either go out of business or automate those roles if they can't afford to pay blue collar workers a living wage. I'm not a socialist, but some business do rip off low income workers. So they might as well cease to exist if they can't find workers to rip off, instead of claiming that people are lazy.
- christophilus 6y ago> The result is that, in some circumstances, earning 1 more dollar results in losing thousands of dollars. I think your new marginal rate only applies to anything over the limit that bumped you into a new tax bracket, so I don’t think this is right. A raise always gets you more money. The exception being if it bumps you out of the government assisted healthcare bracket. Then, a raise could indeed be a loss. Edit: I thought you were talking about income tax, but you might have been talking about business subsidies, which I know nothing about.
- somebodythere 6y agoThey are talking about welfare benefits. Many of these are structured so that the marginal dollar you earn results in $0.75 to $1000+ being taken away from you in benefits.
- LatteLazy 6y agoI'm a brit so I'm far from an expert but I though you kept the US covid payouts whether you worked or not? (unless you earn something like 400k a year)? Sorry if I'm missing your point...
- jpindar 6y agoThe three individual "stimulus checks" went to everyone whether they worked or not. But in addition, unemployed people have been getting unprecedented amounts of weekly Unemployment Insurance payments. In normal times, you can only get these for a few months while proving that you are actively looking for work. During the pandemic, these have been extended and greatly increased, and the government has mostly stopped checking whether people were really looking for work. The normal rules are going to go back into effect soon, though.
- intergalplan 6y ago> Apparently close to 30% of household income right now is from government payments How much is it normally? Definitely not 0%. Also, what's "government payments"? Does it include wages to government employees, for instance? (I expect the figure is higher than normal, I'm just not sure from this how much higher)
- mc32 6y agoIt does not include wages. These are “welfare/unemployment benefits” These are spikes. During the last recession it spiked into the teens. Before that it was lower. So, yeah, it’s a lot of money.
- intergalplan 6y agoAh, OK—if so then the total share of all household income from all government sources must be well over 50% right now, no? Wages, pensions, (including military, in both cases, and state and local government) Social Security, et c.
- paulpauper 6y agobut much of that temporary.