3 ms·
Racism didn't "come from, all of a sudden". As history demonstrates, racism is an endemic problem in both places. The question isn't "does it exist" it's "how i
by wpietri 6y ago
Racism didn't "come from, all of a sudden". As history demonstrates, racism is an endemic problem in both places. The question isn't "does it exist" it's "how is it being expressed today".
You really seem to be having trouble getting my point about views, so I'll try again. "Party X should be in charge" is not what I'd call a view. It's generally more a tribal affiliation and a placeholder for a basket of actual opinions on specific policies and issues. If "viewpoint diversity" actually matters in a business context, we need to be specific about which views exact views are vital to business success.
And if you are really having trouble understanding how some of the Brexit-related views might be racist, it seems like you aren't trying very hard there either. I was going to Google it for you, but that rarely turns out to be worth my time. So let's try this: you tell me what you searched on when you failed to find the material and I'll suggest some better searches.
You also seemed to miss with the Southern Strategy bit. Lee Atwater isn't accusing anybody of racism. He was a hugely important figure in the Republican party and was one of the architects of Reagan's 1984 campaign. It wasn't an accusation; he was bragging.
Of course, even with open admissions like this, American conservatives will do the same sort of straining-out-gnats-and-swallowing-camels routine you're doing here. "Racism?!? Surely that stopped existing about the time I was born. How dare you accuse us conservatives of doing what we have been doing all along. Where's your evidence?"
It may work to re-convince the true believers, but it has been some years since I found it persuasive, so if you want to keep this dialog up, I'd suggest some other tack.
- brippalcharrid 6y agoI wasn't being obtuse, I wanted to give you the opportunity to explain your claims in your own words, because I didn't want to risk misrepresenting you. I also wanted to withhold judgement about your level of knowledge concerning the subject matter. > The question isn't "does it exist" it's "how is it being expressed today". I'm glad that you've come out and said that, because it drives right to the heart of the issue. The problem with the proposal to recast racism into the the mould of an immutable characteristic (I would say redenominating is also a good metaphor) is that we have developed a real moral aversion to transferring individual guilt for events permanently onto groups, and for good reason. On a related note, the problem with claims that we can identify racism through the disparate impact of policies on marginalized groups is that it tends to falsely equate correlation with causation, and in practice it tends to be the result of politically-motivated reasoning. Overall, I think you've perfectly illustrated the problem that the article was pointing to: "anyone who disagrees with my particular set of claims is bad, and anyone who then claims not to be bad is super-bad".
- wpietri 6y agoI see you've decided to make up a cartoon version of my views and argue with that. I'll try one more reply, but I'm not optimistic. I didn't say it was an immutable characteristic. I said it was an endemic problem. I would like it to go away, but we won't get there by pretending it has gone away. We have to make that happen, and that first requires looking honestly at the history and present facts of it. A positive example here is Germany. They stopped denying they had an antisemitism problem and have worked assiduously to remove it. And plenty of western nations have moved fitfully in the direction of acknowledging previous and current oppression. In the US, both Reconstruction and the Civil Rights movement are positive examples there. But in both cases, society gave up before finishing the job (see first and second Nadirs). My proposal: this time let's not let those trying to conserve oppression win. As with polio, it's perfectly possible to eliminate something endemic. But also as with polio, some people of a conservative bent will try to conserve even the harmful parts of the status quo. (My part of the US was settled by a bunch of Dutch who thought things like vaccines and insurance were refusing to accept God's will, for example. And in the modern era, the US right has caused at least a couple hundred thousand deaths through various pro-Covid actions.) So yes, conservatives trying to conserve harmful things may end up feeling bad about that. I'm fine with that. I understand that conservatives are used to being coddled by society, and that this is uncomfortable for them. As they say, when you're used to privilege, equality feels like oppression. But my goal here is minimizing actual oppression, and I think that's more important than preserving the very delicate feelings of those who previously got away with not examining the consequences of their politics.