3 ms·
The weird part to me is the issue of ownership. Why would she own the photo or the meme just because she appears in it? Usually the photographer owns photos th
by bluefirebrand 6y ago
The weird part to me is the issue of ownership.
Why would she own the photo or the meme just because she appears in it? Usually the photographer owns photos they take, unless they give it away or are paid for the rights to it?
And once something is uploaded online, it becomes more murky. Don't a lot of services will claim ownership of any photo uploaded to them, in their TOS?
Like others in this discussion I think NFTs are just a scam
- cblconfederate 6y agoThat leads to the question what is IP. NFTs may not answer that, but they put a price to it
- jrochkind1 6y agoNot really. It's not clear to me that any IP in the photo was sold. The OP says "And as is the case with many NFT sales, the Roths also retain the copyright to the image and will make 10 percent off any future sales of the NFT." If you want to buy the copyright to something (or a license to it), you don't need an NFT. There was already a market price put on IP, you don't need NFTs for that. I have no idea what NFTs are for.
- cblconfederate 6y agoNothing, no legal base. This is an unregulateable market, nothing is enforced, but they all participate voluntarily. If a concept of ownership emerges it will be out of consensus not enforcement
- ghaff 6y ago>Why would she own the photo or the meme just because she appears in it? It's somewhat complicated IANAL. She has certain publicity rights to her own image. So while the photographer probably holds the copyright, if a company wanted to use the image in an ad after obtaining rights from the photographer, she would likely have a claim. That's why stock photography typically requires model releases for recognizable people in the photo.
- jrochkind1 6y agoIn this case, the article said her father took the photo, so I don't think there's going to be a dispute over that. But also, it's not entirely clear to me you "need" to own the copyright to something to sell an NFT based on it. All you "need" is whatever the buyers think you need, and since the whole thing makes no sense to me either, I don't especially expect that to make any sense either. Note that selling the NFT is not the same as selling a license or a copyright. The article also notes "And as is the case with many NFT sales, the Roths also retain the copyright to the image and will make 10 percent off any future sales of the NFT."
- danShumway 6y agoThis has come up a couple of times, and I always wonder about it. I'm sure Disney would sue regardless of whether or not they had any right to, but as far as I can figure out, anyone could make NFTs of Disney's entire online movie catalogue and there'd be no copyright issues at all. Someone like Banksy or even just some random person off the street could make another NFT of "Disaster Girl" and sell it for the same price, and it's not clear to me that the original author could do anything about it. It's worth hammering home over and over that the vast majority of NFTs are just a link. They don't carry any ownership rights at all, or any exclusivity rights. It's no different than pasting a link into a Facebook post.