2 ms·
The Challenges of Animal Translation
- ggm 6y agoI posted this to suggest we stop citing Wittgenstein's comment quoted here: if a lion could talk, we could not understand him—our human minds would not share the sensory and conceptual landscape that lion-talk would express. (probably not a literal quote) We now know there is inter-species communication of sorts, in bird and other communities: They have learned to understand each other's warning sounds. It might be primitive, but the hypothesis Wittgenstein put forward that we could not inhabit their mind because we could not conceptualise what they sought to say, is really species-ist. Even in the act of trying to imagine what a bat's core drive might be, is the latent ability to project beyond yourself. If a crow can "talk" to a sparrow, why should we believe we cannot talk to a dolphin?