6 ms·
I use synology because I tried many alternatives, and none worked out of the box. I finally got one (SmartOS; I also tried FreeNAS) working, but I used the int
by hedora 6y ago
I use synology because I tried many alternatives, and none worked out of the box.
I finally got one (SmartOS; I also tried FreeNAS) working, but I used the intel chip with a timebomb clock line for the build.
Then, I gave up. 4 hours after the synology was home, I was much farther along than I’d gotten in a month on the other machine.
I’d definitely pay a premium for a supported open source + hardware NAS combo that supported docker, vm’s and offsite client-side encrypted backup (with dedupe/compression) out of the box. Also, I want it to draw < 10W, excluding disks.
Until then, synology wins, and isn’t a hobby project.
- gh02t 6y agoiXSystems, the company that develops FreeNAS (now called TrueNAS), makes their own hardware for it with full support and decent prices. TrueNAS has also come a very long way in the past couple of years, before it used to be a bit rough around the edges but it's now a very solid competitor especially running on their hardware. The one potential downside is it's not as beginner friendly as Synology or QNAP UI-wise, but I actually like that about it as I'm not a fan of the UI on either.
- kalleboo 6y agoThe major downside to ZFS-based systems like TrueNAS is that for a home or small business user you can't expand the storage with a new drive when you're running low on space. It's designed for data centers where you can afford to build a whole new array when you need more storage. With Synology you go "oh, I'm down to 1 TB free, well there's this deal on a 10 TB drive, pop it in, now I have 11 TB free"
- fiddlerwoaroof 6y agoThis isn't really true: you can add new vdevs at any time: when you start running low, you just buy two drives and install them.
- kalleboo 6y agoRight, 2 drives. Not "a new drive". Now you're buying twice as many disks as you would with a Synology and wasting 50% of your capacity on parity. And you better have set up your initial array with 2 drive vdevs as well or you're going to have a sub-optimal experience. This is the attitude I see a lot in ZFS support forums. "I don't see the problem, just buy twice as many drives!"
- jjav 6y ago> This is the attitude I see a lot in ZFS support forums. "I don't see the problem, just buy twice as many drives!" This is incorrect on several levels. You most certainly can create a vdev with a single drive in it and add it to the zfs pool. So go ahead, buy that single 10TB drive and add it to your pool. That's not a wise thing to do though, so I don't understand why you'd want to. You'll have no redundancy at all, as soon as the drive dies everything is lost. Which pretty much completely defeats the point of having a NAS. So don't do that. But if you really want to, you can.
- katbyte 6y agoBut doesn’t that come back to their point? With syno you pop in a new disk and it rebuilds the array with the new disk and you have more space and the same redundancy? Raid 5/6 whichever
- KozmoNau7 6y agoWith btrfs, you can add one or however many new devices you want to a storage pool, then rebalance to ensure redundancy across the whole pool. If the device you add is already btrfs formatted, its contents get added to the storage pool, rather than requiring a reformat. It really surprises me that zfs apparently cannot do this. The main reason I use btrfs is the flexibility. Subvolumes instead of partitions, and easy expandability. Storage should be dynamic, not static.
- fiddlerwoaroof 6y ago
- jjav 6y agoYou most certainly can add drives to a zfs pool to expand it. I've been running zfs on my file servers for ~17 years, have expanded the pool many times. In all that time I've only built a new machine once. Currently still running on my 2009 file server build. I've swapped and added drives to it over the years though.
- vetinari 6y ago> You most certainly can add drives to a zfs pool to expand it. You can't replace drives with bigger ones and expand the pool. This is important, if you have 4/5/6/8 bay chasis and exactly the same amount of drives in the pool.
- xoa 6y ago>You can't replace drives with bigger ones and expand the pool. Yes you can. That's exactly what the 'autoexpand' property is for. It's odd how this kind of thing floats around on the internet.
- vetinari 6y agoJust because there's a property doesn't mean that it works. It floats around on the internet, because that's the experience people have.
- rleigh 6y agoIt works just fine. I've upgraded vdevs this way several times, and it worked without a hitch on every occasion.
- vetinari 6y agoIt didn't for me; in the end, I backed up the files, scraped the machine and put the drives into Synology box. So take it as an piece of the puzzle why is Synology more popular.
- 6y ago
- techrat 6y ago> makes their own hardware for it All of their hardware is off the shelf parts, including the case, the motherboard and the drives. I built my own FreeNAS setup using the same components that FreeNAS was selling bundled together at the time. It ended up being about 2/3rds the price.
- gh02t 6y agoThis is true, but it's more about support. iXSystems provides full testing and support on their hardware, which OP mentioned as a want. DIY is cheaper, especially since you have the option to buy used parts, but the premade systems are actually reasonably priced especially compared to some of the markups on Synology hardware.
- NikolaNovak 6y agoThis. I've tried most solutions under the sun, but now that I'm 40 with kids, mucking up with my storage is just not how I spend my weekends anymore.
- syshum 6y agoUnraid is what you are looking for then