5 ms·
> Universal healthcare, say Medicare for All style, does not have to mean higher taxes. How would that be? It seems like it certainly would to me. Maybe by les
by sokoloff 6y ago
> Universal healthcare, say Medicare for All style, does not have to mean higher taxes.
How would that be? It seems like it certainly would to me. Maybe by less than employees plus employers currently pay in aggregate healthcare costs, but I can't imagine a way where the government pays for Medicare-for-all and taxes don't go up.
Do you have a specific idea in mind that I'm missing?
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- munk-a 6y agoI suspect that was a misstatement - I haven't seen a proposal that avoids higher taxes without a large debt being written against something else (i.e. redirecting funding from the military). It is, however, accurate to say that personal out-of-pocket expenses wouldn't increase for most individuals. The cost per patient for government funded healthcare is expected to significantly undercut private costs per patient due to some efficiencies of scale and removal of some pretty big market friction points - so less money would end up being extracted from the economy to pay for an equivalent level of care. In short - you can buy a banana for a dime or give the government a nickle and get a "free" banana.
- maxerickson 6y agoMedicare just forces providers to take less money than insurance companies, it's efficient in some sense, but it's not operational efficiency. I'm super glad my mom has Medicare! But she isn't benefitting from it being efficient, she's benefitting from it setting the rate it pays and requiring providers to accept it.
- munk-a 6y agoTo clarify a bit these market insights don't just come from comparisons to medicare but by comparing patient care costs to similarly developed nations and trying to account for factors like the obesity epidemic - the US just pays a lot more for a patient to get treatment than similar countries.
- sprite 6y agoYou would be able to cut out an entire for profit insurance industry, I would also think people would be more inclined to go to see a doctor before a minor issue turns into a major one than they are now.
- ddingus 6y agoWell, if you and or your employer are not paying premiums, and the overall spend is less (this is a well supported CBO finding), most of us will be better off.
- sokoloff 6y agoTotally agreed. Saying that most of us will be better off even though our taxes will go up is significantly more accurate.
- ddingus 6y agoWhat is a premium but a private tax?
- sokoloff 6y agoOne is an optional payment to a private company to purchase a specific service. The other is a compulsory payment to a government entity as a result of earning income.
- ddingus 6y agoLol, optional? The rest of the developed world would very strongly disagree. The penalty for not making that payment can be death, is likely financial ruin. For many people, that optional payment is enough to buy a home. Ask around about "optional" Then we can set that aside and recognize net, liquid income will go up for most everyone.
- ska 6y ago> Do you have a specific idea in mind that I'm missing? All in the US more or less pays roughly 2x or more what some other countries pay for equivalent healthcare, so there is nominally room to extend coverage while keeping costs flat in theory. In practice, it's complicated. Also 'roughly' and 'more or less' have some wiggle room for systemic differences, but it's about right.