5 ms·
Coming out of high school, one of my first jobs (during my college years) was selling knives as a gig. Since we weren't employees, they couldn't necessarily say
by dragontamer 6y ago
Coming out of high school, one of my first jobs (during my college years) was selling knives as a gig. Since we weren't employees, they couldn't necessarily say "come in on these hours", but there were meetings scheduled at the beginning of the day (where we'd get the next list of customers to call and/or sell knives to), among other stuff.
-------
There are also lots of Barbers who have to basically come in at certain hours to keep the barbershop open. Barbers however, are largely "gig" work by technicality. You're technically an independent contractor.
Etc. etc.
These sorts of positions are only "gig" because the companies are exploiting those workers. You really can't choose your hours in sales and/or barbershops. You gotta come in when the customers come in. You gotta close up shop and/or open up in the morning, (kinda like open / close employees / managers).
But they're "gig" because the companies want to avoid paying social security taxes, among other taxes associated with proper employment.
----------
Freelancing probably is a "proper gig". That's not the segment of the economy that people are talking about. There are true gig workers. And then there's the huge number of "non-employee / gig-work" where its just a collection of companies avoiding social security taxes.
- abunuwas 6y agoThat's a good point. One suspects tho that governments are more interested in getting the "proper freelancers" to be treated as employees, since they usually have higher earnings and therefore offer higher revenue possibilities. The UK is going through a similar reform process right now and lots of people are being classed as employees and therefore taking massive pay cuts. End the end, you end up with temporary workers who're taxed as employees but have almost none of the benefits of permanent employees (in the UK at least).
- dragontamer 6y agoIn the USA: the government gets its cut no matter what. Employees are taxed 6.2% by the government, and 6.2% to the Employer. Gig workers are taxed 12.4% by the government ("self employed" tax). So in US-law, the government gets its money either way. That's why a "gig-worker in name only" is such an advantage to companies in the USA. It allows companies to cut out 6.2% of its taxes and shove it to the gig-worker instead.
- google234123 6y agoI wouldn't mind changing this.
- adolph 6y agoThe total cost of an employee isn't different to the employer in either case. For any X which is the cost of an employee .124X goes to govt. When .062 is sent to govt directly from the employer the govt is effectively hiding .5 of tax liability from the employee. Gig worker sees the whole .124, which is probably why govt wants more classed as employee. TANSTAAFL
- Red_Leaves_Flyy 6y ago>TANSTAAFL There ain't no such thing as a free lunch
- jbn 6y ago"the govt is effectively hiding .5 of tax liability from the employee " <--- this. this is the important part. that extra 6.2% isn't a tax on the employer at all! it is a tax on employment, and it really is part of the employee's taxation (in fact that 2 * 6.2% is a "socialized" part of the employee wage, that fraction of wage goes to the Social Security Administration to be put in a fund used then to pay out retirement pensions). Hiding this fact is the best part of tax: a tax you do not feel is the best kind of tax from the point of view of the tax collector... of course it is the worst kind of tax from the point of view of the taxed entity. "Gig worker sees the whole .124, which is probably why govt wants more classed as employee." <-- that's right! however one could argue that everyone should see the whole .124 so that they know better how they are taxed (I'm not saying this level is too high, on the contrary I think it's too low, but what irks me is that it is done under the covers...).
- AnthonyMouse 6y ago> There are true gig workers. And then there's the huge number of "non-employee / gig-work" where its just a collection of companies avoiding social security taxes. That doesn't make a lot of sense when the employee still has to pay the tax. Nobody is avoiding it. The claim that employers pay half is just a feel-good claim with no economic basis. There is no real difference between paying $10.62 to a contractor who has to pay $0.62 more in social security tax and paying $10 to an employee and $0.62 to the social security administration. And the employee would (all else equal) choose a job paying $10 as an employee over a job paying <$10.62 as a contractor, so the companies hiring contractors have to pay that much more or offer some other countervailing benefit to be competitive.
- dragontamer 6y ago> There is no real difference between paying $10.62 to a contractor who has to pay $0.62 more in social security tax and paying $10 to an employee and $0.62 to the social security administration. And the employee would (all else equal) choose a job paying $10 as an employee over a job paying <$10.62 as a contractor, so the contractors have to pay more or offer some other countervailing benefit to be competitive. Except the ads posted in your local bulletin board / signposts are "Want a job for $10/hr?!??" So what happens in practice, is that the gig-worker is paid $10 (costing the company $10), vs the employee who'd be paid $10 (costing the company $10.62 + other bits, like health care and various insurances)
- AnthonyMouse 6y agoWhich lasts until you send them the documents showing the real numbers and they figure it out. Give people some credit. The education system isn't perfect but people can do basic arithmetic. Or if they can't then maybe solve that instead of this.
- dragontamer 6y ago> Or if they can't then maybe solve that instead of this. Why not both? If a problem is identified with our culture, its not exactly a strong argument to say "Well, here's another problem I'm more concerned about". All I'll say is: lets solve both problems simultaneously. There's many problems in the world, and we should work on solving as many of them as possible. I've got friends (who were with me in that knife salesman gig work) who didn't understand the difference at all, no matter how many times I explained it to them. People's brains just don't work the way you say. Sure, I understood the difference and how to do my own taxes, but not everyone has that capability unfortunately.
- conductr 6y agoWanted to chime in with my $0.02 regarding barbershops. My family owned a salon growing up. I’m sure you’re right and abuses exist. But in my experience, the shop is a landlord. The independent contractor rents a chair. They can come/go at will. Having a schedule is useful so not everyone is there the same time fighting over walk in traffic. People regularly no show and that’s ok too.
- Red_Leaves_Flyy 6y agoThat may be how your families shop was run, but your experience is not representative of the industry at wide which uses various schemes to staff their shops from straight hourly, tipped, rented, etc. Source: I like to get to know my barber's and every shop was run different.
- conductr 6y agoYou say barber and I say salon so I wonder if that’s part of the difference. I tend to go higher end places where women are the main customers. I know my stylists too and it’s almost always either been rent a chair and a few W2. Also my experience was a collection of talking to every stylist that ever worked in our salon and that’s a lot because churn is high. But I’d not be surprised if what you’re saying is also true. I have no idea how the chains are ran for example (Supercuts, etc)