4 ms·
Everyone knows that they are workers, right? Not just random workers that do something else every day, workers on their own devices but workers for a company a
by mrtksn 6y ago
Everyone knows that they are workers, right? Not just random workers that do something else every day, workers on their own devices but workers for a company and they works the way that company says.
Why not start from here and work on the employment laws to allow for the flexibility or whatever works for that kind of employment?
Why pretend that an Uber driver is a businessmen that may actually expend his/her business or go through other company stages? Obviously that's not happening, therefore they should have the rights and obligations of a worker, not a business.
- briandear 6y ago> Obviously that's not happening Do we know that to be true?
- mrtksn 6y agoYes, for all the gig jobs that I'm aware of. If it looks like a duck, swims like a duck, and quacks like a duck, then it probably is a duck. Last time I checked, Uber wouldn't let you simply fulfil your duties of transporting people the way you find fit, for example. It's really not a B2B relationship in any meaningful way. For those who do, sure. They are not gig workers, they are contractors.
- mattm 6y agoI think really what is needed is a new employment classification to deal with gig workers. It's clear that they're somewhere in the middle between an employee and contractor/freelancer.
- topkai22 6y agoDefinitely, although the legislative slog that would present makes me believe it'll be tough to get there. Part of the Uber/Lyft "ickiness" factor is that you have a giant company that has defined a "contracting" relationship with 100s of thousands of individuals. That is big power and capcity differential. Its not unreasonable to expect that the gig service companies be required to provide more services for their drivers than, say, local independent window washer who contracts individually with many businesses. Automatic tax payments, minimum wage for callouts and depreciation payments for self provided equipment are not unreasonble past a certain scale point. That being said, the people I've known personally who have drove for Uber/Lyft (around 4, so a small number admitadly) really were doing it just for a bit of extra cash on the side and would not have wanted or been able to be an employee of Uber/Lyft.
- randomsearch 6y agoWhy should the gig economy even be a thing? It seems really great for the companies (make huge amounts of money), pretty great for users (cheap taxis, cheap accommodation), and absolutely terrible for most others - whether that’s the drivers (I’m sure some are happy, but the fact is the pay absolutely stinks, which is how the companies want it) or people suffering from increased traffic (Uber) or the disturbance of community (Airbnb). It’s just an incredible feat of mental acrobatics that hacker news convinces itself that the gig economy must be a good thing and must exist and it’s the government that’s behind, rather than the more obvious conclusion that _we have worker protections for a reason_ and these companies are not “disrupting” anything other than employment laws that protect the exploitation of workers, and other laws that protect wider society. Just because some says it is “tech” doesn’t meant it’s good or we have to support it. Just feels like massive groupthink or lack of experience of the reality on the ground for most people.
- junar 6y agoThis actually exists: it's called "statutory employee". But according to current regulations, only a few specific types of workers can be classified this way. https://www.irs.gov/businesses/small-businesses-self-employed/statutory-employees https://www.irs.gov/businesses/small-businesses-self-employe...
- LatteLazy 6y agoThe issue is the exact same thing applies to your plumber. So either you owe him decades of back pay and healthcare or it is OK to hire people for a job and not keep them permanently...
- mrtksn 6y agoMy plumber can fix my pipes however he wants. He is a sole trader, I will pay him for his service. If I sign a contract with him to go around other houses and make him fix the pipes the way I see fit, for example, using only black tape and stamp my logo on it, I receive the payments from the customers and pay him, he is my employee. People are not hiring him, they hire me and I employ him to do the job. It's not even a marketplace, it's just me who finds the customers and the plumbers.
- LatteLazy 6y agoSo, I actually think the directions you give the plumber are MORE specific. I won't accept sewage in my drinking water. I don't care if my Uber driver takes third street or 4th avenue. But that's not really the point here. The point here is that there used to be a pretty well defined line between the self employed and employees. That's not the case anymore. So we either spend decades making ever more complex unenforceable rules, and pretending taxi drivers deserve more/less from their jobs than (say) plumbers. Or we man up and stop pretending this makes sense and use a different system.
- mrtksn 6y agoNot at all, giving that kind instructions to the plumber is like telling the Uber driver not to hit and run women and children. You don't give instructions on the core job competences, if you do, you are a teacher not a client or employer.