2 ms·
I see this spectacle as punishing the UMN IRB which has demonstrated an inability to prevent issues like this occurring in the future. If any readers have not
by hinkley 6y ago
I see this spectacle as punishing the UMN IRB which has demonstrated an inability to prevent issues like this occurring in the future.
If any readers have not learned that the trick to inter-organizational progress is to get the right questions into the right ears, now is a good time to look at that concept. You can tell your own people until you're blue in the face that the customer has a very expensive XY problem, or you can buddy up to one of their engineers and have them ask their management chain for Y, at which point the seas part and you have budget to solve the problem correctly.
The IRB's bosses need to be audited, and as far as I'm aware the IRB hasn't volunteered that it was part of this dustup and promised to do anything about it. Which means someone has to make them do it. Which means their boss needs to care. I don't know how universities are organized, but I'm betting that the president/chancellor of the school has hire/fire control over that group. And if not them, then the board. How do you get the board's attention?
More importantly, if I'm a Gatech student and I don't think my university is being ethical about open source, I can make them care by pointing out how UMN got exiled for doing the same sorts of things we are suggesting doing. If UMN just gets a finger wave they'll just shrug and wait for theirs.
- seoaeu 6y agoThe entire point of an IRB is that they have independence from the rest of the institution, so they can make decisions on ethics without coercion. You're also ignoring that the UMN IRB never said this research was ethical. All they did was compare the experimental parameters to the definition of human subject research they were given. Since no biological specimens or personal information were being collected, they decided it was outside their jurisdiction and not their problem. Also if I recall correctly this evaluation was done retroactively after the experiment had already happened.
- shinjitsu 6y agoThat lasts until the IRB embarrasses the University: https://www.enterprisenews.com/story/news/education/2021/03/02/bridgewater-state-university-black-lives-matter-movement-survey-wild-beast-preying-college-statement/6879868002/ https://www.enterprisenews.com/story/news/education/2021/03/... https://www.bridgew.edu/racial-justice/messages/research-survey-update-mar-10-2021 https://www.bridgew.edu/racial-justice/messages/research-sur...