3 ms·
Yes, that's the hypothesis of the "There's no Covid-19" crowd that will disappear whenever hospital corridors are filled with dead bodies. On the other hand PC
by mrtksn 6y ago
Yes, that's the hypothesis of the "There's no Covid-19" crowd that will disappear whenever hospital corridors are filled with dead bodies.
On the other hand PCR test are not inaccurate at all, at least regarding false positives. There are detailed articles and even Youtube videos on the process and if you take a look, you will understand why it's quite accurate.
In essence, they create a reaction that will mass produce specific parts of the virus gene until it's detectable with a sensor. They run the reaction multiple times and then the sensor looks for luminance if I recall correctly.
Because you can't accidentally produce Covid-19 genes, the tests are very accurate. However, you might not get enough virus material when taking the sample from the patient(which can fail your reaction or you might need more cycles than usual to create a detectable amount) or it could be the case that there's a mutation in the gene that you are attempting to multiply, therefore you can get a negative test for an infected person.
- collyw 6y ago> On the other hand PCR test are not inaccurate at all, at least regarding false positives. https://www.thelancet.com/journals/lanres/article/PIIS2213-2600(20)30453-7/fulltext https://www.thelancet.com/journals/lanres/article/PIIS2213-2... between 0.8% and 4% false positive rate according to that, making them completely unsuitable for mass testing. On top of that BBC's panorama did a program pointing out the sloppy standards at centers where the tests are processed.
- mrtksn 6y agoHow did you decide that this range exactly is unsuitable enough that we are better off we simply assume that the reality is the one that suits our agenda? IMHO that's a pretty good accuracy, significantly better than the "I feel like", "I want to believe that", "what if it's all about" or the "It's suits me better if" methodologies. I'm not being snarky, I simply want to outline the alternatives I'm aware of. I respect the accuracy of the PCR, it can literally tell us why people in India are dying off on the streets right now in thousands and we even cannot see the assailant through optical magnification. It can also tell us that it's the same thing that caused the exact same situation in NY and Italy. It's amazing, much more intriguing than any other explanation that I came across.
- MR4D 6y agoI’m not the OP, but the rest of the paragraph that the quote above was linked to reads as follows (note the last 3 words in the quote): * This rate could translate into a significant proportion of false-positive results daily due to the current low prevalence of the virus in the UK population, adversely affecting the positive predictive value of the test.2 Considering that the UK National Health Service employs 1·1 million health-care workers, many of whom have been exposed to COVID-19 at the peak of the first wave, the potential disruption to health and social services due to false positives could be considerable.*
- collyw 6y agoAt the height of the "second wave" here, it was estimated that around 0.8% of the population was infected at the time. That means that if you were randomly tested there was a greater chance that you would have a false positive than an actual infection.
- mrtksn 6y agoThat would be unfortunate to all those prevalence studies where the difference between 1.1 and % 0.3 means the world for them. They may never know if it was %0.5 or %0.8 of the people infected. On the other hand, it's a pretty good accuracy when you have a hospital full of sick people. Sure, you may end up recommending 14 days of staying at home every now and then when it's not necessary. See, the PCR test is just one of the clues that is used to diagnose people. Negative test with clearly Covid-19 symptoms and medical image of the lungs showing spots gets you a bed and treatment in the hospital. Positive test and no symptoms gets you stay at home and wear a mask recommendation.
- collyw 6y agoThat's why I said they were completely unsuitable for mass testing. I said nothing about them being used where covid is suspected.
- SketchySeaBeast 6y agoNevermind the fact that as we find more people positive we see an increase in hospitalizations and mortality shortly afterwards, why in these charts[1] did Alberta get so many sub 0.8% 7 day rolling averages then? https://www.alberta.ca/stats/covid-19-alberta-statistics.htm#laboratory-testing https://www.alberta.ca/stats/covid-19-alberta-statistics.htm...
- petertodd 6y ago> On the other hand PCR test are not inaccurate at all, at least regarding false positives. PCR tests work by selectively amplifying DNA. Each PCR test cycle approximately doubles the amount of the selected DNA. (for SARS-CoV-2, an RNA virus, the RNA is first converted to DNA) Since each cycle approximately doubles the amount of selected DNA present, PCR tests can be extraordinarily sensitive if enough cycles are used. In theory, just a single fragment of RNA could result in a positive test. As Health Canada says: "There are numerous studies that demonstrate prolonged detection of SARS-CoV-2 RNA that extends beyond the resolution of COVID-19 symptoms and can persist for several weeks or months." https://www.canada.ca/en/public-health/services/diseases/2019-novel-coronavirus-infection/guidance-documents/repeated-pcr-testing-individuals-previously-positive-covid-19.html https://www.canada.ca/en/public-health/services/diseases/201... Hospitals are testing pretty much everyone who comes in the door for COVID-19. The fact that people can test positive long after they were actually infected should obviously raise questions about the accuracy of our statistics with regard to COVID-19 hospitalization and death rates. Additionally, contamination is a potential problem. For example, the BBC's undercover reporting found significant cross-contamination between samples at one testing lab: https://www.bbc.com/news/uk-56556806 https://www.bbc.com/news/uk-56556806 Contamination could be showing up as a multiplier on true positives: as positive % increases, opportunities for contamination also increase. Since PCR tests work by replicating DNA, they also have the unusual property that the testing process itself creates large quantities of potential contamination. Good lab practice will eliminate that problem. But that's hard to guarantee when testing volume is increased enormously in a short period of time.
- mrtksn 6y agoThat's not PCR's but the sample processing error rate. It's not inherent to PCR but the specific organisation that runs the mass testing efforts. If UK's has these issues the maybe they should improve their quality standards. Thankfully we don't have to stop with a PCR test.