15 ms·
Mining robot stranded on Pacific Ocean floor in deep-sea mining trial
- flohofwoe 6y agoI hope it's not just another cover story to get ahold of a sunken Russian submarine this time ;) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Project_Azorian https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Project_Azorian
- PLenz 6y agoHa! I see our brains are in sync!
- pelagic_sky 6y agoFascinating read! Thanks for that link.
- pjmorris 6y ago'Blind Man's Bluff: The Untold Story Of American Submarine Espionage', Sherry Sontag covers this story and a number of others of similar ilk.
- LinuxBender 6y agoOr if it is a sub, let's get it out of there to reduce marine pollution.
- okprod 6y agoThe aliens from The Abyss are actually back
- baryphonic 6y ago> Critics, including environmentalist David Attenborough, say seabed mining is untested and has a largely unknown environmental impact. Google, BMW, AB Volvo, and Samsung SDI have backed a call for a moratorium on deep-sea mining. > > Dr Sandra Schoettner, deep-sea biologist at Greenpeace, said: "Losing control of a 25-tonne mining machine at the bottom of the Pacific Ocean should sink the idea of ever mining the deep sea." Sheesh, I guess these particular environment activists can never allow anything new, since we don't know what impact it will have and any failure of any part of a system, no matter how repairable or minor, is ipso facto proof that the project is a disaster. This would be like completely writing off SpaceX after a Starship tank rupture in a launchpad test. The article seems to indicate that this project is being done responsibly, with oversight and caution. Things will go wrong (as they have), but this wasn't some sort of catastrophic failure like Deepwater Horizon or something. I'm curious to see if they can extract these minerals without doing widespread environmental damage, and I think they should at least be given a chance to prove it or not.
- nerdponx 6y agoMy understanding is that marine ecosystems are interconnected and can be surprisingly sensitive, and that we humans depend on them mre than you'd think. It also makes sense to assume that deep-sea mining is damaging and disruptive by default. It therefore makes sense to be very very cautious about it. That's as far as I can wrap my head around it. Maybe there are people here with some expertise who can elaborate.
- mienski 6y agoYou're really going for the straw-man argument here I see, there is a huge difference between launching a space ship and creating a new way to mine the earth and destroy the environment. I understand that they have this little catch-all: > GSR has said it will only apply for a mining contract if the science shows deep seabed minerals have advantages, from an environmental and social perspective, over relying solely on land mining. But I'm not going to hold my breath thinking that if they find a rich-enough deposit of minerals - that they wont suddenly discover enough "advantages" for the ocean to now be open to the same decimation as land mining has seen for many years.
- the-dude 6y agoThis. And ocean is really scarce.
- nitrogen 6y agoOur planet has way more ocean than land. In what way is that scarce?
- igetspam 6y agoI'll take the bait. Planets that are capable of sustaining human life are scarce. Putting aside the divisions on our maps, we have a total of one ocean. Since we have exactly one planet to live on and one ocean to sustain life, I'm gonna go ahead and call that pretty scarce. There's a massive amount of water but if we ruin that one ocean, I believe we all die. So now it's time for a judgement call: what is so valuable at that depth that you're comfortable having people poke holes in it hoping to determine the science is good and worth the risk?
- PLenz 6y agoFlashing back to the Glomar Explorer/Project Azorian: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Project_Azorian https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Project_Azorian
- pas 6y agoumm.. it's not lost, the current title is too clickbaity. > "On its final dive in the GSR area, a lifting point separated and Patania II now stands on the seafloor," a GSR spokesman said in an emailed statement. > A spokesman for GSR said the company has not lost control of Patania II, and that projects like this always have challenges to contend with.
- dang 6y agoSubmitted title was "25tons seabed mining robot prototype was lost at 4km depth in Pacific Ocean". That broke the site guidelines: "Please use the original title, unless it is misleading or linkbait; don't editorialize." Submitters: please don't do that. We eventually take submission privileges away from accounts that do. https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
- canadianfella 6y agoWho is we?
- gertrunde 6y ago"lost" may be overstating things a bit. It appears that the tether became disconnected, and they're working to reconnect it.
- jbk8210 6y agoI'd suppose there might also be increased interest in mining areas near black smokers and other geologically and biologically active regions of the seabed.
- monkeybutton 6y agoI don't really know anything about geology so apologies if this is a naive question: Is the effort to mine under the ocean predicated on the belief that we only have access to ~29% of the precious metals / diamonds etc. because that's just how much of earth's surface isn't underwater?
- warmwaffles 6y agoI know that mining methane hydrate off of the ocean floor has been a discussion. We would be wise to try and get that out and contain it / burn it before it is released into the atmosphere as pure methane.
- JoeAltmaier 6y agoIt's been forming there for a billion years. There's no hurry.
- nitrogen 6y agoThe hurry is if warming temperatures cause it all to sublimate and release rapidly as gas, AKA the clathrate gun.
- JoeAltmaier 6y agoIts distribution is sparse and on the surface. Its been forming for a billion years. Conclusion: it's sublimating all the time and being replaced. If there's any danger, its from the billions of cubic meters under the ocean floor (the source of the nodules, seeping from underneath). More carbon than all the oil we ever burned in our civilization so far. Is that in any danger of accelerated release? I've not heard of that.
- vkou 6y ago> Conclusion: it's sublimating all the time and being replaced. In the long-term, yes, it will eventually reach a steady state. In the long term, though, we'll all be dead. In the short-term, on timescales that human beings care about, no, we can release too much of it too quickly, before the system reaches a steady equilibrium. Methane has an atmospheric half-life measured in decades, so getting too much of it, too fast, can significantly spike temperatures.
- Jedd 6y agoTitle should be as per article: 25-tonne. (metric unit, equivalent to 25,000kg)
- Symmetry 6y agoThere's only a 10% difference between the two and given that the the weight is rounded to 25 I'd be surprised if it wasn't more than 10% off the true figure.
- Jedd 6y agoGoing out even further along the precariously pedantic limb - tonne is a measure of mass, not weight. ; )
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- jhgb 6y agoTons are metric, too (and the default in most of the world).
- ehnto 6y agoI don't think it is. A ton is an imperial measurement that is close to a metric tonne. A lot of places use the words ton and tonne to mean a metric tonne, but an imperial ton is a different amount if kilograms to a metric ton/tonne.
- jhgb 6y ago"A ton" is a very vague word that can mean lots of things, only one of them being the imperial ton. Some tons can't even be converted to kilograms at all since they're units of volume.
- Jedd 6y agoIn 'most of the world', especially the English-speaking / metric-using parts, the word 'tonne' is used to clearly and immediately make it clear we're using the metric unit for 1000kg. The article itself used the word 'tonne' as it was written by / for people that use metric. 'Ton' is a word with myriad meanings, none sensible.
- tyingq 6y agoThe text makes it sound like a non-violent sort of event, like someone forgot to insert a locking pin or something. As opposed to something like unexpected external forces ripping it loose. "On its final dive in the GSR area, a lifting point separated and Patania II now stands on the seafloor," "An operation to reconnect the lifting point begins this evening and we will provide an update in due course." Also, a picture of it with people, so the scale is more clear: https://www.deme-gsr.com/wp-content/uploads/coverfoto-gsr_patania-1440x0-c-default.jpg https://www.deme-gsr.com/wp-content/uploads/coverfoto-gsr_pa...
- nsbk 6y agoSeems like these freaking huge tracks will treat deep-sea coral nicely
- himinlomax 6y agoIt's the size of a typical tank. This will do as much harm to coral or whatever is down there as one (1) WW2 tank did to the Black Forest. Meanwhile, dissolved CO₂ is killing coral on a global scale. That seems like a very misplaced concern.
- katamaritaco 6y agoThe comparison to a WW2 tank in the Black Forest isn't great though, because the environments live on different timescales. A forest can regrow and thrive after a few decades. The same is _not_ true for the deep sea[1]. 'Life on the ocean floor moves at a glacial pace. Sediment accumulates at a rate of 1 millimeter every millennium. With such a slow rate of growth, areas disturbed by deep-sea mining would be unlikely to recover on a reasonable timescale.' [1]: https://news.mit.edu/2019/understanding-impact-deep-sea-mining-1206 https://news.mit.edu/2019/understanding-impact-deep-sea-mini...
- seiferteric 6y agoAre they mining in sensitive areas? Isn't there an equivalent of an underwater deserts with little life/biodiversity? Not to diminish this idea, but the ocean covers >70% of the earth so I would think this could be done somewhere with relatively little impact, but maybe I am wrong.
- JoeAltmaier 6y agoI daydream that an undersea civilization resented the pillaging of their entire ecosystem and attacked the mining robot in self-defense. But no, probably just a mechanical failure. Soon they'll be back to sterilizing the ocean bottom. Sigh.
- Jiocus 6y ago> I daydream that an undersea civilization resented the pillaging of their entire ecosystem and attacked the mining robot in self-defense. That might be the claustrophobic plot of Underwater (2020). Deep-sea mining operations in the Mariana Trench.
- throw_away 6y agoAlso https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Laundry_Files#The_Jennifer_Morgue https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Laundry_Files#The_Jennifer...
- 542458 6y agoEdit: ignore this post, I was wrong. > Thirty years on, the test that Thiel and a colleague devised is still the largest experiment ever on the potential impacts of commercial deep-sea mining. Called DISCOL, the simple trial involved raking the centre of a roughly 11-square-kilometre plot in the Pacific Ocean with an 8-metre-wide implement called a plough harrow. The simulated mining created a plume of disturbed sediment that rained down and buried most of the study area, smothering creatures on the sea floor. The test revealed that the impacts of sea-bed mining reached further than anyone had imagined, but it did not actually extract any rocks from the sea bed, which itself would have destroyed even more marine life. https://www.nature.com/articles/d41586-019-02242-y https://www.nature.com/articles/d41586-019-02242-y
- JoeAltmaier 6y agoThis is probably one of the most fragile, delicate ecosystems on the planet. It could take 100 or 1000 years to recover from the sterilization. Low-impact? We have very different definitions for that phrase.
- jimnotgym 6y agoThis is not evoking the same kind of drama as the Chillian mining disaster, is it?
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- TedShiller 6y agoThis machine totally destroys the ocean floor. Environmental destruction.
- dillondoyle 6y agoIs it more destructive than Cobalt mining elsewhere? What about when taking account developing nation violence? At least from the photo it doesn't look like they are dredging fish reefs. Though I don't trust the behavior of these corporations & developing nations use loose or non-existent maritime regulations to scoop up, net, and kill more fish than we can sustain and just completely wreck the last untouched environments we have.
- canadianfella 6y agoWhere do you get your metal resources from? Unicorn farts?
- joeblow21 6y agoA 25 ton prototype....