5 ms·
I think this may literally be the same argument as the one for banning D&D for corrupting the minds of youth. I suspect most (nay, all?) paraphilics have the ab
by roenxi 6y ago
I think this may literally be the same argument as the one for banning D&D for corrupting the minds of youth. I suspect most (nay, all?) paraphilics have the ability to differentiate between reality and a page of text - just like many of us have avoided going full Don Quixote after reading Lord of the Rings.
Maybe they'll get addicted to reading. Society will not crumble, and no children will be harmed.
- ahelwer 6y agoIt has nothing to do with differentiating reality from fantasy. It has to do with whether a given pleasure association is strengthened or weakened. Pedophiles seek out these stimuli because of a pre-existing attraction toward children in the real world.
- roenxi 6y agoIt is simpler than you think. If you're at a screen full of text and get a dose of dopamine or whatever, you're simply going to spend more time staring at screens of text. If your theory was true, we'd have seen historically massive upticks in violence from videogames. It is yet to materialise. This is an era of unusual peace.
- ahelwer 6y agoReal-world violence is so far removed from its video game counterpart that there is no real comparison, as anyone who has been in any sort of fight understands. In contrast, pornography (visual or textual) is quite similar to its real-world counterpart.
- Thiez 6y agoIt is though? I'm thinking you and your partner(s) must either be very athletic, or you're watching some pretty tame porn.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- claudiawerner 6y ago>In contrast, pornography (visual or textual) is quite similar to its real-world counterpart. A cursory look around online erotic roleplayers, online stories, the manga/doujinshi sold in huge numbers every year in Japan at Comiket, or even the plots of mainstream porn will quickly disabuse you of this notion. I'm also not convinced on the 'no real comparison' for video games. I'm reminded of the fact that the US Army recruits first-person shooter players, and that video games can show a rise in aggression in lab settings, similar to real sports do. Even if they were all that different, you'd still have to specify in which specific ways, and the extent of those ways, the difference between the two entertainments is relevant to your argument.
- versteegen 6y agoPlease, let's not get distracted by videogame violence. We have seen historically massive upticks in child abuse material [1], caused by two inventions: the internet and smartphones with cameras, and there's a strong case made that it reflects an actual, large, increase in child sexual abuse. I don't have a specific article to link to, but Gabriel Dance discusses in a podcast [2] how many paedophiles are gradually indoctrinated by communities; they are made, not born. [1] https://www.nytimes.com/interactive/2019/09/28/us/child-sex-abuse.html https://www.nytimes.com/interactive/2019/09/28/us/child-sex-... Warning: extremely distressing descriptions. [2] https://samharris.org/podcasts/213-worst-epidemic/ https://samharris.org/podcasts/213-worst-epidemic/ Warning: ditto, though not as bad.
- CuriouslyC 6y agoI don't doubt online pedophile communities support pedophiles, but I don't think they create them. Also, just because we're documenting it now doesn't mean it didn't happen before - sexual abuse of young girls has been endemic since forever, and people go through all sorts of contortions not to acknowledge it.
- versteegen 6y agoGabriel Dance makes the argument much better than I could; I won't attempt it. He spent years investigating, actually doing things such as interviewing paedophiles, asking them 'why'. I don't have reason to doubt his conclusions. But what is clearly new is that now people are encouraged to abuse children because they can take a video, share it, sell it, gloat about it, trade it to get access to more material. Additionally, sharing imagery of abuse further harms the victims. For example, in that podcast it was mentioned that some victims receive a notification every time images of their abuse come up in a court case!
- CuriouslyC 6y agoBlocking child abuse literature and fake child porn isn't going to stop predators from doing the stuff you mention though. That stuff is still going to be teased on social media and shared on the darkweb.
- versteegen 6y agoTextual descriptions of child sexual abuse both desensitise (a thin end of a wedge, a slow on-boarding) and reinforce a habit or desire. See my reply down-thread.
- AnIdiotOnTheNet 6y agoIs the same true of movies where a man goes on a killing spree ala Rambo or John Wick? Or videogames where one does the same? I'm trying to suss out the logic where one indulgence of fantasy through fiction is ok and the other isn't.
- klmadfejno 6y agoI would find it believable that sexual associations are more malleable than arbitrary behaviors.
- AnIdiotOnTheNet 6y agoIf that is true, one would expect significant evidence to back it up exists. Studies on the effectiveness of gay conversion therapy suggest that your assertion is not based in fact.
- klmadfejno 6y agoI guess I would follow that up by saying development of festishes is not the same thing as base sexual orientation. I also don't think this would be easy to study at all. Furries might be a good candidate population to study.
- true_religion 6y agoI think the above poster is implying that no one is a pedophile by choice. That would mean people are choosing to desire heinous crimes, which would destroy their reputations permanently and send them to prison. If that were true, we would expect to see a lot more unity from these self selected people in the same way say cannabis users are always jockeying for laws to change. As it is, it looks like an pedophilia is a unasked for mental state spread out over the population at random.