3 ms·
The shape of the curves of the spokes doesn't depend on the speed. If you take the picture of the wheel, and fix the aspect ratio so that it is circular, then t
by mnw21cam 6y ago
The shape of the curves of the spokes doesn't depend on the speed. If you take the picture of the wheel, and fix the aspect ratio so that it is circular, then the spokes will have a curve independent of the speed of the wheel. Speed determination is purely based on the aspect ratio of the entire wheel.
To reason on why this might be true - consider that the bottom of the wheel is stationary, and the top of the wheel is moving at twice the speed. This is the case regardless of the speed of the wheel. If you rolled the wheel past the camera really slowly, the entire wheel would be stretched out horizontally, but the spokes would all be in the same arrangement.
The reason for this is that the camera is a fixed position line scan where the variable is time only. If we switch to thinking about standard video cameras with a rolling shutter, then these have a line scan where the variable is time and space - that is, the camera samples a scan that is moving at a known speed. If you have a video with a camera like this of helicopter blades, for instance, then you can determine the blade rotation speed from a single frame. But with this finish camera, that doesn't work.
So, to determine speed, the best possible action is to pick two points on the rigid body that is moving, and time how long it takes to pass the recording line. The further apart these points are, the more accurate the average speed determination will be. The trade-off for this is that the speed measurement will be the average between the time the first point and the second point passes the recording line, and we are only interested in the average speed at the point the front of the bike passes the line.
What we can show however, as pointed out elsewhere[0], is that one bike was in front of the other when the front of the wheel, the hub of the wheel, and the back of the wheel passed the recording point. When the back of the wheel passed the recording point, the front of the wheel definitely passed the actual finish line, so assuming the two wheels are the same size then the front of that wheel passed the finish line before the other one.
[0] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26978621 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26978621
- tomglynch 6y agoGreat comment! Super informative and something I had not properly thought about. But you're totally right, curvature of the spokes is based only on the fact it's rolling past the camera, and two wheels rolling at different speeds will result in the same spoke pattern.